Weevils, weevils, weevils everywhere *
Author
Oberprieler, Rolf G.
Author
Marvaldi, Adriana E.
Author
Anderson, Robert S.
text
Zootaxa
2007
1668
491
520
journal article
10.5281/zenodo.274039
2d13c1a2-0d8f-4031-986a-3900e879582c
1175-5326
274039
Brentidae
In the wide sense as adopted here, the family
Brentidae
is about as diverse as the
Anthribidae
, with approximately 400 genera and 4 0 0 0 species described, and it also has a cosmopolitan distribution. About 90% of the species belong to the derived subfamilies
Brentinae
and
Apioninae
, which are about equal in size (ca. 1 700 and 1 900 species, respectively), while the
Nanophyinae
(ca. 270),
Microcerinae
(67),
Eurhynchinae
(31) and
Ithycerinae
(1) are much poorer in species and also geographically more restricted.
Brentidae
are almost exclusively associated with angiosperms, only very few and unrelated apionines occurring on conifers, and since nearly all the putatively basal groups (
Ithycerinae
,
Microcerinae
,
Eurhynchinae
,
Nanophyinae
,
Brentinae
: Cyladini,
Apioninae
: Tanaini, Mecolenini) live on angiosperms, it appears that the family was ancestrally associated with this group of plants. Conspicuous in
Brentidae
is also the absence of associations with monocotyledons, and although the family is indicated to be at least as old as
Curculionidae
(extending back to the mid-Cretaceous in the fossil record), it species richness reaches not even 8% of that of the latter. The larvae of
Ithycerinae
and
Microcerinae
(fig. 10) feed on roots in the soil, those of
Eurhynchinae
(fig. 8) and
Brentinae
(fig. 11) tunnel in living or dead branches and trunks (where some
Brentinae
may be predaceous on other xylophagous beetles) and those of
Apioninae
(fig. 12) and
Nanophyinae
develop mostly in young stems and inflorescences, fruits or seed pods.
FIGURES 9–16.
9—the South African
Microcerus latipennis
,
a member of the enigmatic African
Microcerinae (Brentidae)
. 10— larva of
Microcerus latipennis
feeding on the taproot of
Sida rhombifolia
(Malvaceae)
. 11—the ant-associated
Cordus ganglbaueri
(
Brentidae
:
Brentinae
) from Australia. 12—the South African
Tanaos interstitialis
(
Brentidae
:
Apioninae
), a primitive apionine developing in flower heads of
Protea caffra
(Proteaceae)
. 13—a pair of the South African
Antliarhinus zamiae
(
Brentidae
:
Apioninae
) on a cut cycad seed hollowed out by their larvae. 14—dead female
Antliarhinus zamiae
with her rostrum stuck in a cycad seed. 15—the large Australian Grasstree Weevil,
Trigonotarsus rugosus
(
Curculionidae
:
Dryophthorinae
), on dead trunk of its grasstree host,
Xanthorrhoea
(Xanthorrhoeaceae)
. 16—the large, colourful Elephant Weevil,
Brachycerus ornatus
(
Curculionidae
:
Brachycerinae
), from southern Africa on leaves of
Ammocharis coranica
(
Alliaceae
or
Amaryllidaceae
), its larval host.
The family concept of the
Brentidae
remains in dispute, some authors (e.g.,
Crowson 1955
,
Zimmerman 1994b
,
Wanat 2001
) treating some or all of the subfamilies recognised here as distinct families. The case for amalgamating them (except for the African
Microcerinae
) into a single family was first made by
Morimoto (1962
,
1976
) and consolidated by later studies (
Thompson 1992
,
May 1993
) and phylogenetic analyses (
Kuschel 1995
,
Marvaldi & Morrone 2000
,
Oberprieler 2000
,
Marvaldi
et al
. 2002
). The
Microcerinae
(fig. 9), which had previously been included in the curculionid subfamily
Brachycerinae
(e.g.
Thompson 1992
,
Kuschel 1995
), were included in
Brentidae
by
Oberprieler (2000)
on the basis of mainly larval characters. A number of characteristic morphological features occur in
Brentidae
in this expanded concept, such as stepped abdominal ventrites (3–5 on a higher level than 1–2), eyes covered by a corneal lens, labial palps sunk into grooves on the ental surface of the prementum and with a reduced number of segments (2 or 1), male tergite 8 pouch-like with medially inflexed posterior margin, aedeagus with frenal sclerities, tegminal ring laterally constricted or articulated; however, none of these conditions are present in all taxa and can be regarded as synapomorphies defining the family
Brentidae
as a monophyletic group. Only two characters have been identified so far as shared by all of them. One is the single median sensillum on the larval labrum, which is otherwise only known in Ocladiini (
Curculionidae
:
Brachycerinae
) but does not occur in the more primitive families (which have a median pair) or in other
Curculionidae
(which have a median sensillum plus a lateral pair). The other is the reduced number of Malpighian tubules (four), a condition that almost never occurs in
Curculionidae
(only a few isolated cases reported in
Cossoninae
and
Rhamphini
, see
Calder 1989
). It does, however, also occur in some
Nemonychidae
and
Anthribidae
(
Calder 1989
,
May 1993
), and although such a reduction is likely to have evolved independently in various groups, its consistent occurrence in all
Brentidae
suggests that it may indeed be a synapomorphic feature in this family. Further morphological and molecular studies are needed to test this hypothesis and to establish the relationships among the subfamilies as recognised here. Phylogenetic relationships within the subfamilies have been addressed in
Microcerinae (
Louw 1986
)
and
Apioninae
(
Wanat 1995
,
2001
) but remain to be extended and especially studied in the other large subfamily,
Brentinae
.