Clarifying the status of Caribbean Pinguicula (Lentibulariaceae) type specimens
Author
Domínguez, Yoannis
text
Phytotaxa
2024
2024-03-05
638
3
247
256
http://dx.doi.org/10.11646/phytotaxa.638.3.4
journal article
10.11646/phytotaxa.638.3.4
1179-3163
13213022
Pinguicula casabitoana
Jiménez (1960: 238)
.
Type
(
lectotype
, designated here):—
[
DOMINICAN REPUBLIC
]. Prov.
La Vega
:
Alto
de Casabito
, [
1400 m
], s.d. [
17 July 1955
],
J. J. Jiménez
3029
(USD barcode USD00004617!,
isolectotypes
JE barcode JE00024418!,
US
barcode 01068907!;
Fig. 1
).
=
Pinguicula cladophila
Ernst (1961: 175)
.
Type
(
lectotype
, designated by
Casper 1966: 99
):—[
DOMINICAN REPUBLIC
].
Hispaniola
, Prov. De
la Vega
: Civ.
Santo Domingo
,
Cordillera Central
, top of
Loma La Vieja
,
2075 m
,
7 November 1929
,
E.L. Ekman
H 14051
(S accession S05-188!,
isolectotypes
LL barcode 00519065!, NY barcode 01445966!, US barcode 01068906!; image of the
lectotype
available at https://herbarium.nrm.se/specimens/S05-188).
Note
:—The protologue of
P. casabitoana
refers to a single collection as type:
Jiménez 3029
, without flagging it as
holotype
or mentioning any herbarium housing the specimen(s).
Casper (2019)
cited the “
holotype
” as housed at JBSD although he did not see it. Through communication with JBSD staff it was confirmed that this specimen is not in the extant collection (Elizabeth Séptimo, pers. comm.,
3 December 2021
). After the death of J. J. Jiménez, his personal herbarium and library were donated to the herbarium UCMM at the “Universidad Católica Madre y Maestra” (
Zanoni 1983
). However, communication with UCMM staff revealed that no specimen that matches the citation in the protologue is in the collection (Juan F. García Gil, pers. comm.,
13 December 2021
).
Three specimens
of the gathering cited by Jiménez were traced (JE,
US
and USD) and none of them have indication that allows the assumption of them being used by Jiménez when elaborating the protologue. There is the possibility that the specimen at USD may have been used by Jiménez when preparing the protologue. It bears a handwritten label (
Fig. 1
) but it was not possible to conclude that the writing belongs to Jiménez (Ruth H. Bastardo, pers. comm.,
12 January 2023
). The specimen at USD (USD00004617!) is selected as the
lectotype
of
P. casabitoana
. For the name
P. cladophila
,
Ernst (1961)
cited
Ekman H 14051
as the type but he did not mention any herbarium housing the material.
Four specimens
from Ekman’s collection were found at LL, NY, S and
US
.
Casper (1966
,
2019
), by citing the specimen at S as “
holotype
” and the one at NY as “
isotype
”, made his intention clear and inadvertently designated
Ekman H 14051
at S as the
lectotype
. Herewith, Casper’s selection is accepted but the citations are corrected to
lectotype
and
isolectotypes
according to Art. 9.10 of the ICN (
Turland
et al.
2018
).