Account of montane and insular speciation in some Korean megadriles (Annelida: Oligochaeta)
Author
Blakemore, Robert J.
Author
Lee, Seunghan
Author
Seo, Hong-Yul
text
Journal of Species Research
2015
2015-02-28
4
1
1
22
http://dx.doi.org/10.12651/jsr.2015.4.1.001
journal article
58532
10.12651/JSR.2015.4.1.001
a0c1a8e5-7c6d-4083-820d-02293daa5e23
2713-8615
8135064
8.
Amynthas
cf.
chiakensis
Hong & James, 2013: 76
,
fig. 1A, B
(
Fig. 4A
).
Material.
IV
0000261301 (DNA sample HY5) a sub-adult from Bangtaesan Mt. (37̊55′25.30′′N 128̊25′48.42′′E), Inje, Gangwon-do, eastern
South Korea
, collected by Dr H.-Y. Seo, 11
th
July, 2013. Found with a mature
Metaphire hilgendorfi
(Michaelsen, 1892)
(IV0000261302), and one other specimen (IV000261300) described separately below.
Description.
Length 70-82, current
60 mm
. Brown. Perichaetine. Spermathecae in 6/7/8, no genital markings nearby. Male pores superficial surrounded fore and aft by two to four papillae (three in current specimen) per side within elongate, lateral disc. Caeca manicate in 27. GM glands internally (
Hong & James, 2013: 76
note GM glands are lacking around the spermathecal pores, but this is unsurprising when there are no GMs).
Remarks.
This specimen lacking anterior GMs is superficially complicit with
Amynthas chiakensis
(from Mt Chiak) defined by these authors as related to
A. sanchongensis
Hong & James, 2001: 90
fig. 5P-T (from Mt Jiri) that has clusters of small genital markings anterior and posterior to each spermathcal pore. It was said also similar only to
A. sonjaesiki
Hong & James, 2009
(from Mt Songni) that differs in having small GMs close to the spermathecal pores in 7 and 8.
However,
Blakemore (2003: 43
,
2006
;
2008
;
2012f
;
2014
) suggested that
A. sanchongensis
is a synonym of
A. tappensis
(Ohfuchi, 1935)
along with several other Japanese and Korean species that are overlooked by
Hong & James (2001
; 2009; 2013). Moreover,
A. sonjaesiki
Hong & James, 2009
is similarly thought a junior synonym of prior
A. tokioensis
(Beddard, 1892)
with yet other species taking priority as per
Blakemore (2003
b: 43, 2006; 2008; 2010; 2012f). These issues are entirely avoided by
Hong & James (2013: 76)
who merely say “
Resolving the taxonomic issues associated with extensive parthenogenetic modification of sexual characters is a difficult problem in this group of earthworms, among others (cf.
Blakemore 2006
), and will require extensive resampling for molecular data.
” They yet fail to resample nor provide any molecular data to support their work, whereas in the current study COI barcodes (e.g., sample HY
5 in
Appendix,
Fig. 1
) are provided for support and comparison whenever possible.
Interestingly, the nearest BLAST match on HY5 is 621/623 (99%) with “
Metaphire soulensis
” (accessions AB5426642-7 from
Japan
: Aomori-ken, Kanagawa-ken, Sendai City in Miyagi-ken, Hachioji near
Tokyo
, Kobe City and Hiroishima) and 577/579 (99%) with>JET-168
Amynthas soulensis
from
Japan
(Appendix) also 622/623 (99%) with DNA sample>w47 of
Metaphire soulensis
from Ullungdo as described by Blakemore (2013: 62, fig. 7). Current synonyms of
Metaphire soulensis
(
Kobayashi, 1938
)
are
Pheretima shinkeiensis
Kobayashi, 1938
;
Pheretima aokii
Ishizuka, 1999
-
as per
Blakemore (2003
b: 43; 2012b)
-
plus
A. dageletensis
Hong & Kim, 2005
as per
Blakemore (2006
;
2008
; 2010; 2012b; 2013; 2014).
The question now of whether
A. chiakensis
Hong & James, 2013
also belongs in synonymy of parthenogenetic
M. soulensis
(Kobashi, 1938)
is left to its authors to determine.