Taxonomic reexamination of Portulaca boninensis (Portulacaceae) in the Bonin (Ogasawara) Islands of Japan using molecular and morphological data
Author
Kokubugata, Goro
Graduate School of Agriculture, Ibaraki University, Ami, Ibaraki 300 - 0393, Japan.
Author
Kato, Hidetoshi
Makino Herbarium, Graduate School of Science and Engineering, Tokyo Metropolitan University, 1 - 1 Minami-osawa, Hachioji, Tokyo. 192 - 0397, Japan.
Author
Iamonico, Duilio
Laboratory of Phytogeography and Applied Geobotany, Department PDTA, Section Environment and Landscape, University of Rome Sapienza, 00196 Rome, Italy.
Author
Umemoto, Hana
Graduate School of Agriculture, Ibaraki University, Ami, Ibaraki 300 - 0393, Japan.
Author
Ito, Takuro
Graduate School of Agriculture, Ibaraki University, Ami, Ibaraki 300 - 0393, Japan.
Author
Nakamura, Koh
Biodiversity Research Center, Academia Sinica, Nangang, Taipei 115, Taiwan. & Botanic Garden, Field Science Center for Northern Biosphere, Hokkaido University, Chuo-ku, Sapporo 060 - 0003, Japan (present address).
Author
Murakami, Noriaki
Makino Herbarium, Graduate School of Science and Engineering, Tokyo Metropolitan University, 1 - 1 Minami-osawa, Hachioji, Tokyo. 192 - 0397, Japan.
Author
Yokota, Masatsugu
Laboratory of Ecology and Systematics, Faculty of Science, University of the Ryukyus, Senbaru 1, Nishihara, Okinawa 903 - 0213, Japan.
text
Phytotaxa
2015
2015-06-25
217
3
279
287
http://dx.doi.org/10.11646/phytotaxa.217.3.5
journal article
10.11646/phytotaxa.217.3.5
1179-3163
13633842
Portulaca psammotropha
Hance (1851: 660)
.
Lectotype
(designated here):—
TAIWAN
.
Pratas Island
,
April 1831
,
Wilford
s.n.
(
K
!, image of the
lectotype
available at http://apps.kew. org/herbcat/getImage.do?imageBarcode=
K000340154
).
=
Portulaca quadrifida
L.
var.
formosana
Hayata (1911: 37)
≡
Portulaca formosana
(Hayata) Hayata (1917: 7)
.
Type:—
TAIWAN
. Lanyu Island,
26 November 1899
,
Miyake s.n.
(
holotype
TAI!, image available at http://tai2.ntu.edu.tw/specimen/ specimen.php?taiid=T00380).
=
Portulaca insularis
Hosokawa (1932: 229)
.
Type:—
TAIWAN
. Liuchiuyu Island,
01 August 1930
,
Hosokawa 1628
. (
holotype
TAI
!, image available at http://tai2.ntu.edu.tw/specimen/ specimen.php?taiid=118821).
=
Portulaca boninensis
Tuyama (1939: 6)
,
syn. nov.
Type:—
JAPAN
. Bonin, Chichijima Island,
24 July 1905
,
Hattori s.n.
(
holotype
TI
!)
=
Portulaca hainanensis
Chun & How (1958: 8
−
9)
.
Type:—
CHINA
.
Hainan
,
June 1932
,
How 70899
(
holotype
SYS
!).
Description
:—Perennial herbs,
3
−
10 cm
tall. Stems not articulated, diffuse, branched basally, ca.
1 mm
thick, basal stems woody, prostrate, upper stems herbaceous, upright, green. Root fleshy, much branched. Leaves spirally arranged or alternate, subsessile, with axillary hairs; leaf blade
2–3 mm
thick, oblong to obovate,
5–8 mm
long, base obtuse, apex obtuse or rounded. Flowers solitary, about
10–15 mm
in diameter. Sepals 2, ovate-deltate, about
2 mm
long. Petals 5, obovate to narrowly obovate, lemon-colored, mostly without margins overlapping. Stamens 8–30. Ovary ovoid. Stigma usually trilobed or tetralobed rarely pentalobed; capsule glossy,
2–4 mm
long,
2–3 mm
wide.
Distribution
:—North Philippine (Batan Islands), South
China
Sea (
Hainan
, Pratas Island), South
Taiwan
(Kenting, Liuciou, Lutao, Lanyu and the
Penghu
Islets), and Bonin (
Ogasawara
) Islands.
Ecology
:—On coastal rocky slopes and sandy beaches, xeric, saline, and exposed to direct sunlight.
Typification
:—
Hance (1851: 660)
provided a detailed diagnosis, the provenance (“
Habitat in insula corallina
˵
Prata Island˝…
”), and habitat (“
ad littora maris arenosas
”). There are
two specimen
at K (codes 000340153, and 000340154) collected by C. Wilford in “
Prata Island
” (= Pratas Island) as reported in the label. However, the specimen code 000340153 (image available at http://apps.kew.org/herbcat/getImage.do?imageBarcode=K000340153) bears a plant collected in
April 1858
. As a consequence, it can be considered a post-1851 addition to the collection, it is not part of the original material for the name
Portulaca psammotropha
, and cannot be elegible as
lectotype
(arts. 9.2, and 9.3 of ICN,
McNeill
et al.
2012
). On the contrary, the other specimen bears a plant collected in 1831 so being useful for the lectotypification purposes. The morphological characteristics of the exsiccatum matches the Hance’s diagnosis, and it is here designated as the
lectotype
of the name
Portulaca psammotropha
.
Morphological notes
:—A diagnostic key to
Portulaca psammotropha
,
P.tuberosa
, and
P. okinawensis
is presented below:
1. Flowers surrounded by sparse hairs ...................................................................................................................................
P. tuberosa
- Flowers without surrounded hairs......................................................................................................................................................2 2. Axillary hairs present ...............................................................................................................................................
P. psammotropha
- Axillary hairs absent...........................................................................................................................................................................3 3. Number of stamens more than 20; petals orange-yellow, obovate to narrowly obovate; stems reddish green....................................
...........................................................................................................................................................
P. okinawensis
var.
okinawensis
- Number of stamens less than 15; petals lemon-coloured, obovate to oblanceolate; stems bright green ............................................. ..........................................................................................................................................................
P. okinawensis
var.
amamiensis
Biogeography notes
:—Although the different climates, the floras of Bonin Islands (subtropics climate), and Ryukyus (subtropical climate) are considered similar from the phylogenetic point of view (
Hara 1959
,Yamazaki 1970).Therefore, it was unexpected that the species identified was not the Ryukyu endemic
P. okinawensis
, but
P. psammotropha
, that is commonly found in the Bonin Islands. The Bonin Islands represent the northwestern limit of the distribution area of
P. psammotropha
which was geographcally isolated from
Hainan
Island of
China
,
Taiwan
, and the
Philippines
(
Chung
et al.
2008
). Since
Portulaca
is a tropical genus and
P. tuberosa
(the sister species of
P. psammotropha
) is distributed in the Malesian and Pacific regions (
Puy
et al.
1993
), we can hypothesized that the Bonin populations of
P. psammotropha
were derived from ancestral southern populations from
Taiwan
or the
Philippines
.
The Bonin Islands were formed during the Paleocene (66 Ma to 56 Ma) and rose above sea level before the middle Pleistocene, about 0.8 Ma to 0.1 Ma (
Kaizuka 1977
,
Imaizumi & Tamura 1984
). They are oceanic islands that have never been land-connected with other islands/landmasses. So,
P. psammotropha
must have migrated to the Bonin Islands oversea. The species has dry dehiscent fruits and its seeds are
0.6–0.7 mm
in diameter (
Tuyama 1939
,
Chung
et al.
2008
). Given that seeds in
Portulaca
do not float,
Geesink (1969)
suggested three possible mechanisms for oversea dispersal: 1) attachment to drifting wood, 2) exo- and/or endozoochory, or 3) artificial dispersal. Artificial dispersal is unlikely because Minami-io-jima has not been inhabited and few naturalized plants have been found in the island (
Kato
et al.
2008
). On the other hand, seeds of some
Portulaca
species
remained viable after floating in seawater for a few weeks (
Ridley 1930
).
P. psammotropha
occurs in coastal rocky slopes in
Taiwan
(
Chung
et al.
2008
), and the Bonin Islands (
Fujita
et al.
2008
, G. Kokubugata, pers. observ.). Therefore, we consider sea-current dispersal a likely scenario to explain the occurrence of the species in the Bonin Islands. The Kuroshio Current washes
Taiwan
and the northern
Philippines
, flowing northward along the Ryukyu and Japanese archipelagos and periodically meanders from
Japan
proper toward the Bonin Islands. The Kuroshio Current is a likely medium, although the absence of the species in the Ryukyus needs to be explained by assuming extinction or haphazard results. Long dispersal with exo- and/or endozoochory by migratory birds is also possible. Further studies, especially phylogeographic/population genetic studies, on plants showing similar distribution patterns could be used to explore the migratory origin and route of Bonin populations.