Pliocene marine mammals from the Whalers Bluff Formation of Portland, Victoria, Australia
Author
Fitzgerald, Erich M. G.
School of Geosciences, Monash University, Vic. 3800, Australia and Museum Victoria, G. P. O. Box 666, Melbourne, Vic. 3001, Australia
efitzger@museum.vic.gov.au
text
Memoirs of Museum Victoria
2005
2005-12-31
62
1
67
89
https://museumsvictoria.com.au/collections-research/journals/memoirs-of-museum-victoria/volume-62-issue-1-2005/pages-67-89/
journal article
10.24199/j.mmv.2005.62.2
1447-2554
10665561
Superfamily
Delphinoidea
Gray, 1821
Incertae sedis
Referred specimens.
NMV
P218283, P218284 and P218286, all isolated teeth (not figured).
Description
. P21283, P218284 and P218286 all represent small odontocete teeth possessing conical enamel-covered crowns that bear fine wrinkling ornamentation, and curve lingually towards the crown apex. As in kentriodontids, there is a lingual bulge at the base of the crown but this feature is not as prominent in the teeth from Portland. None possesses an open pulp cavity suggesting that all were derived from adult individuals.
P218283 is an incomplete tooth, its preserved maximum length and maximum width of the crown being
16 mm
and
6 mm
respectively. Due to the incomplete nature of this tooth it does not warrant further description.
P218284 is the most highly polished and the most complete. It differs from the others in having a mediolaterally compressed root with a more prominent mesial-distal bulge at its midpoint. The preserved apex of the root curves posteriorly.
The most notable feature of P218286 distinguishing it from the other teeth is its bulbous root, which contrasts with the transversely flattened morphology of P218284.
Discussion
. Only one delphinoid odontocete has previously been described from the Tertiary of
Australia
, the latest Miocene-earliest Pliocene “
Steno
”
cudmorei
Chapman (1917)
from the Black Rock Sandstone of Beaumaris,
Victoria
(
Fitzgerald, 2004b
).
Fordyce (1982)
questioned the taxonomic identity of “
S
.”
cudmorei
(the
holotype
, P13033, being an isolated tooth) and
Fitzgerald (2004b)
referred “
S
.”
cudmorei
to
Delphinidae
, genus and species indeterminate.
Chapman (1917)
assigned P13033 to
Steno
on the basis of the resemblance of its crown ornamentation to that seen in the teeth of the extant
Steno bredanensis
Cuvier
in Lesson, 1828 (e.g.,
Miyazaki and Perrin, 1994
). Given that
Steno
is probably in a basal position in the phylogeny of
Delphinidae
(
Miyazaki and Perrin, 1994
;
LeDuc et al., 1999
) and that some of the presumed ancestors of
Delphinidae
, the
Kentriodontidae
(
Barnes, 1978
,
2002
;
LeDuc, 2002
), possessed
Steno-like
crown ornamentation (e.g.,
Kellogg, 1966
), the anastomosing striae on the crown of P13033 (and P218283, P218284, P218286) are of dubious use in assessing the phylogenetic affinities of isolated teeth. Furthermore, non-delphinid small odontocetes such as
Lipotes vexillifer
Miller, 1918
possess anastomosing wrinkling on tooth crown enamel (
Miller, 1918
;
Brownell and Herald, 1972
;
Barnes, 1985
) which casts doubt on any perceived taxonomic or phylogenetic signal present in these teeth.
The isolated teeth from Portland are assigned to
Delphinoidea
incertae sedis. None of the Portland Pliocene teeth share demonstrably close affinities with the
holotype
tooth of “
Steno
”
cudmorei
.