Combining target enrichment and Sanger sequencing data to clarify the systematics of the diverse Neotropical butterfly subtribe Euptychiina (Nymphalidae, Satyrinae)
Author
Espeland, Marianne
Author
Nakahara, Shinichi
Author
Zacca, Thamara
Author
Barbosa, Eduardo P.
Author
Huertas, Blanca
Author
Marín, Mario A.
Author
Lamas, Gerardo
Author
Benmesbah, Mohamed
Author
Brévignon, Christian
Author
Casagrande, Mirna M.
Author
Fåhraeus, Christer
Author
Grishin, Nick
Author
Kawahara, Akito Y.
Author
Mielke, Olaf H. H.
Author
Miller, Jacqueline Y.
Author
Nakamura, Ichiro
Author
Navas, Vanessa
Author
Patrusky, Brooke
Author
Pyrcz, Tomasz W.
Author
Richards, Lindsay
Author
Tan, Denise
Author
Tyler, Stephanie
Author
Viloria, Angel
Author
Warren, Andrew D.
Author
Xiao, Lei
Author
Freitas, André V. L.
Author
Willmott, Keith R.
text
Zoological Research
2023
2023-02-15
2023
1
73
journal article
10.1111/syen.12590
bfb878f3-8a74-46d3-a104-36485c32aaba
7909395
Occulta ocnus
(
Butler, 1867
)
combinatio nova.
Euptychia ocnus
Butler (1867
, p. 467)
. TL: Tapajos [Pará, Brazil]; Villa Nova (=Parintins) [Amazonas, Brazil].
Types
: ST female: ‘
BMNH
(
E
)-1,266,945//Tapajos, Amazons. H. W. Bates//
Type
of Species//
Type
H. T.//
♀
//
♀
Tapajos
ocnus Butler
Type
//B. M.
Type
No. Rh 3179
Euptychia ocnus
♀
Butl.//Godman-Salvin Coll. 1904:1.
Euptychia ocnus, Butl.
’, (
NHMUK
) [
Figure 30d,e
, examined]. ST female: ‘Villa Nova, Amazons. Coll. by Bates. 56
–
44.//Villa Nova//
BMNH
(
E
) 1497830’, (
NHMUK
) [examined].
=
Euptychia libye f
.
gracilis
(
Weymer, 1911
; 212, figure 48f) TL: Pebas, [Loreto], Peru.
Types
: ST male, ‘
LECTOTYPE
♂
Euptychia libye f. gracilis
Weymer, 1911
By G. Lamas
(‘94//Pebas//Libye - Forma// libyoidea Btlr’), (
SMTD
) (figured in
Warren et al., 2022
, examined).
Taxonomy
.
Butler (1867
, p. 467) described this species from Brazil, based on an unspecified number of specimens from Tapaj́os, in Bates
’
s collection, and ‘Villa Nova’, in the
NHMUK
. The original description closely matches
two female
syntypes
in the
NHMUK
from Tapajos ́and Villa Nova, in particular in describing the five main ocelli in the VHW as comprising three that are encircled with yellow and each having two pupils, and the remaining two as being yellow with a central silver line.
Weymer (1911
, p. 212, pl. 48f) described
Euptychia libye
f.
gracilis
based on an unspecified number of specimens from Pebas, Peru, in the collection of Bang-Haas, and the figure of the ventral surface corresponds with the specimen labelled as
lectotype
by Lamas in the
SMTD
. In comparison with the
two syntypes
of
ocnus
, this specimen is somewhat paler, and it has a distinct rather than vestigial ocellus in 2A-Cu2 on the VHW, but the remaining VHW ocelli and other wing pattern characters are otherwise typical of this species as here defined.
Distribution and natural history
(
Figure 32
).
Occulta ocnus
gen.n.
and
comb.n.
is known to date from the central Amazon basin, with all recorded localities being in the vicinity of large rivers below
250 m
.
A list of specimens examined is provided in Table S3. The only two records from Ecuador are from the region of black-water rivers and lakes north of the Río Napo; at Zancudococha, a male was collected flying near to the ground at the edge of forest and small field, on a low ridge, at 13:00 hrs. Immature stages have not been described. A list of specimens examined is provided in Appendix B.
Discussion.
Occulta
gen.n.
is described as a monotypic genus for
Euptychia ocnus
based on molecular data presented here. As previously indicated by
Espeland et al. (2019a)
,
Euptychia ocnus
is distantly related to the
type
species of
Magneuptychia
,
Papilio libye
Linnaeus, 1767
. Although
Papilio libye
is a member of the clade to which
Occulta
gen.n.
is weakly supported as belonging, expanding the concept of
Magneuptychia
to include
Euptychia ocnus
would be unreasonable, for a number of reasons. First, the support for its relationship with the clade containing
Papilio libye
is low. Second, and perhaps more importantly, such a broad generic classification would be inconsistent with current approaches to building a stable and informative generic classification for the
Euptychiina
, where monophyly, phenotype and ecological information are incorporated in deciding on the most appropriate taxonomy (e.g. Nakahara, Lamas, et al., 2019). This clade not only includes both widespread lowland taxa (e.g.
Magneuptychia libye
) and rather narrowly distributed montane species (e.g. undescribed
Splendeuptychia
species
), but also some of the most colourful euptychiine species in the genus
Caeruleuptychia
. Given that generic names should ideally be informative for the recognition of clades by including species with similar phenotypes, in addition to having potential value in predicting unknown biological traits, we refute the idea of a broad generic classification to include all these taxa contained within the clade containing
E
.
ocnus
, and instead establish a monotypic genus for this species.
Occulta ocnus
BRAZIL
:
Amazonas
: Carauari, RESEX Médio Juruá, [5°8'57"S,67°18'45"W], (Oliveira, F.),
1 Dec 2018
, 1 ♁,
2 ♀
[MN-LEP 0004444, 0004446, 0004453],
2 Dec 2018
, 1 ♁,
4 ♀
[
MN-LEP 0004448 to 0004452]; Ega, [3°22'S,64°42'W], (Bates, H. W.), 1 ♁ [
BMNH
(
E
)-1421814], (
NHMUK
); Igarapé Massauari, [2°54'17''S,57°8'23''W], 1 ♁ [
BMNH
(
E
)-1421845], (
NHMUK
);
São Paulo de Olivença
, [3°28'S,68°57'W], (Mathan, M. de), 1 ♁ [
BMNH
(
E
)-1497827], (
NHMUK
),
Mar 1883
,
1 ♀
[
BMNH
(
E
)-1497829], (
NHMUK
); Villa Nova, (Bates, H. W.),
1 ♀
[
BMNH
(
E
)-1497830], (
NHMUK
);
Pará
: [Rio] Tapájos, [4°16'8''S,55°59'10''W],
25 m
,
25 Oct 2012
, 1 ♁, (
ZUEC
).
COLOMBIA
:
Amazonas
: Leticia, [4°12'S,69°56'W],
82 m
, (Marín, M. A.),
11 Oct 2012
, 1 ♁, (
ZUEC
),
18 Oct 2012
, 1 ♁, (
ZUEC
),
28 Sep 2012
, 1 ♁, (
ZUEC
).
ECUADOR
:
Orellana
: Río Aguarico, Zancudococha, [0°34'23''S,75°26'13''W],
240 m
, (Willmott, K. R., J. C. R., J. I. R., Aldaz, R.), 3,5-
8 Jul 2017
, 1 ♁ [
FLMNH-MGCL-288721], (
FLMNH
);
Sucumbíos
: Cuyabeno Lodge, across lagoon, [0°0'18''S,76°10'23''W],
224 m
, (Turner, J. D.),
6 Dec 2010
, 1 ♁ [
FLMNH-MGCL-150971], (
FLMNH
),
7 Dec 2010
, 1 ♁ [
FLMNH-MGCL-150970], (
FLMNH
); Cuyabeno Lodge, salt trail, [0°0'4''S,76°10'50''W],
238 m
, (Turner, J. D.),
8 Dec 2010
, 1 ♁ [
FLMNH-MGCL-150972], (
FLMNH
).
PERU
:
Loreto
: ‘Cavallo Cocha’ [= Caballococha], [3°55'S,70°31'W],
90 m
, (Mathan, M. de), May-Jul 1884, 1 ♁ [
BMNH
(
E
)-1421876], 1 ♁ [
BMNH
(
E
)-1497832], 1 ♁ [
BMNH
(
E
)-1497833], 1 ♁ [
BMNH
(
E
)-1497835],
1 ♀
[
BMNH
(
E
)-1497834], (
NHMUK
);
55 km
NE Iquitos, Explorama [Lodge], [3°27'S,72°51'W],
120 m
, (Harvey, D. J.),
24 Sep 1995
, 1 ♁ [
MUSM-LEP-103309], (
MUSM
), (Lamas, G.),
24 Sep 1995
, 1 ♁ [
MUSM-LEP-103306], 1 ♁ [
MUSM-LEP-103308],
1 ♀
[
MUSM-LEP-103311], (
MUSM
), (Robbins, R. K.),
24 Sep 1995
, 1 ♁ [
MUSM-LEP-103310], (
MUSM
);
55 km
NE Iquitos, Explorama [Lodge], [3°27'S,72°51'W],
140 m
, (Harvey, D. J.),
23 Sep 1995
,
1 ♀
[
MUSM-LEP-103312], (
MUSM
); Boca Río Samíria,
130 m
, (Lamas, G.),
14 May 1990
, 1 ♁ [
MUSM-LEP-103307], (
MUSM
); ' Explorama
50 mi
NE of Iquitos' [=Explorama Lodge
55 km
NE Iquitos], [3°27'S,72°51'W], (Brown, H.& B.),
30 Nov 1982
, 1 ♁ [
FLMNH-MGCL-296549], (
FLMNH
);
Iquitos, [3°45'S,73°15' W],
100 m
, (Whitely, H.), 1 ♁ [
BMNH
(
E
)-1497836], 1 ♁ [
BMNH
(
E
)-1497837],
1 ♀
[
BMNH
(
E
)-1497828], (
NHMUK
); nr. Iquitos, Explornapo Camp, [3°15'S,72°55'W],
120 m
, (Brown, H.& B.),
9 Feb 1982
, 1 ♁ [
FLMNH-MGCL-296551], (
FLMNH
); Sarayacu, [6°43'S,75°8'W],
160 m
, (Garlepp, G.), 1885,
1 ♀
, (
MNHU
).
SURINAME
:
Not located
: ‘Surinam’, 1 ♁ [
BMNH
(
E
)-1421815], (
NHMUK
),
1 ♀
[
BMNH
(
E
)-1497831], (
NHMUK
).
Country unknown
:
Not located
: no data,
20-22 Jun 2000
, 1 ♁ ['RTPRS'], (
ZUEC
)