Bat diversity in the Simandou Mountain Range of Guinea, with the description of a new white-winged vespertilionid
Author
Decher, Jan
Zoologisches Forschungsmuseum Alexander Koenig, Leibniz Institute for Animal Biodiversity, Adenauerallee 160, 53113 Bonn, Germany & Corresponding author: E-mail: J. Decher @ zfmk. de
echer@zfmk.de
Author
Hoffmann, Anke
Museum für Naturkunde, Leibniz Institute for Evolution and Biodiversity Science, Invalidenstr. 43, 10115 Berlin, Germany
Author
Schaer, Juliane
Museum für Naturkunde, Leibniz Institute for Evolution and Biodiversity Science, Invalidenstr. 43, 10115 Berlin, Germany & Max Planck Institute for Infection Biology, Chariteplatz 1, 10117 Berlin, Germany
Author
N Orris, Ryan W.
Department of Evolution, Ecology and Organismal Biology, Ohio State University, 4240 Campus Dr., Lima, OH 45804, USA
Author
Kadjo, Blaise
Université Félix Houphouët-Boigny, 22 BP 582 Abidjan 22, Côte d’Ivoire
Author
Astrin, Jonas
Zoologisches Forschungsmuseum Alexander Koenig, Leibniz Institute for Animal Biodiversity, Adenauerallee 160, 53113 Bonn, Germany
Author
Monadjem, Ara
All Out Africa Research Unit, Department of Biological Sciences, University of Swaziland, Private Bag 4, Kwaluseni, Swaziland & Mammal Research Institute, Department of Zoology & Entomology, University of Pretoria, Private Bag 20, Hatfield 0028, Pretoria, South Africa
Author
Hutterer, Rainer
Zoologisches Forschungsmuseum Alexander Koenig, Leibniz Institute for Animal Biodiversity, Adenauerallee 160, 53113 Bonn, Germany
text
Acta Chiropterologica
2015
2015-12-01
17
2
255
282
journal article
10.3161/15081109ACC2015.17.2.003
470b137b-05b5-468a-b37e-6a315108ecc1
1733-5329
3943621
Neoromicia isabella
sp. nov.
Decher, Hutterer and Monadjem
Isabelline White-winged Serotine
Neoromicia
cf.
rendalli
;
Monadjem
et al.
, 2013
b
Holotype
ZFMK 2008.0292
, field number JD 650, collected by
Jan Decher
on
7 March 2008
. Adult
male
in reproductive condition (testes 5 ×
4 mm
), preserved in 70% ethanol, skull extracted. Tissue preserved (COI sequence
GenBank
no.
KT598187
).
Type locality
Guinea
, Province Macenta, Simandou Range, Foko Confluence,
8°29’48.62’’N
,
8°54’48.22’’W
, ca.
765 m
a.s.l., captured in net set across creek in rainforest.
Paratype
ZFMK 2008.0291
, field number JD 647
; adult female (pregnant with 1 embryo), preserved in ethanol. Netted same day and place as
holotype
.
Referred specimen
DM 12619
,
Mount
Nimba
,
Liberia
; reported as
Neoromicia
cf.
rendalli
by
Monadjem
et al.
(2013
b
)
;
COI sequence deposited under GenBank no.
JX508832
.
Diagnosis
A medium-sized pipistrelloid bat of the genus
Neoromicia
, based on the presence of a single upper premolar (Hill and Harrison, 1987) with white wings; only likely to be confused with
N. tenuipinnis
(slightly smaller and different pelage colour, see below) and
N. rendalli
(larger). Dorsal and ventral surface of wings pure white (as in
N. tenuipinnis
), tips of dorsal pelage light rusty orange-brown (‘isabelline’), not dark brown (as in
N. tenuipinnis
). Baculum similar in shape to
N. rendalli
but smaller. COI sequence different from that of both
N. tenuipinnis
and
N. rendalli
(
Fig. 3
).
Etymology
The species epithet refers (as a noun in apposition) to the ‘Isabella’ colouration (sensu
Ridgeway, 1912
) of the dorsal fur of this bat, and also recalls the name of Jan Decher’s daughter Isabelle.
Description
Neoromicia isabella
sp. nov.
is similar in size and general colour pattern to
N. tenuipinnis
(
Table 3
,
Figs. 4
and
5
) but slightly larger in total length, forearm length, and body mass (
Table 3
). Tail length is 34% of the total length in the
holotype
, and 37% on average. This value in the
holotype
of
N. rendalli
(
Thomas, 1889
)
is 49%, and in the
holotype
of
N. tenuipinnis
39% (
Peters, 1872
). The tips of the dorsal hairs are of a light isabelline colour (
Ridgeway, 1912
), much lighter than in
N. tenuipinnis
(compare
Figs. 4
and
5
). The dorsal hairs are
4.5 mm
long. Ears, lips, wings, uropatagium, and hindfeet are almost white and covered by very short hairs; only the ear tips and dorsal surfaces of forearm, hindfeet and tail have a pale brownish hue.
Ear length is
10 mm
in the
holotype
of
N. isabella
(
10–13 mm
,
n
= 3), and its tip is rounded (
Fig. 4
). The tragus of the
holotype
(
Fig. 6
) is
4.2 mm
long, and represents 42% of the ear length. A small notch is present at the basis of the anterior surface. Compared to illustrations of
N. tenuipinnis
and
N. rendalli
in
Rosevear (1965)
and specimens in ZFMK and DM, the tragus of
N. isabella
is similar to that of
N. tenuipinnis
(tragus length estimated from figure:
3.9 mm
) but the shape of the notch is different (
Fig. 6
).
The penis of the
holotype
specimen is
6.4 mm
long and covered by short whitish hairs. A digital
x
-ray of its baculum is shown in
Fig. 7A
in a semilateral view. It is slightly longer (
3.5 mm
) than in the
N. isabella
specimen DM12619 (
2.8 mm
;
Fig. 7B
) reported by
Monadjem
et al.
(2013
b
:
Fig. 4C
), but very similar in shape, and both are still longer than that of
N. tenuipinnis
(in
Monadjem
et al.
, 2013
b
:
Fig. 4D
), which is
1.8 mm
long and strongly bent (
Fig. 7C
). A baculum figured as
N. rendalli
by
Kearney
et al.
(2002
:
Fig. 1F
) is about
4 mm
long.
FIG. 4. Views of the head and body of
N. isabella
sp. nov.
(holotype) after capture. Note the isabelline-colored dorsal fur and the white wings (Photographs by J. Decher)
The cranium of
N. isabella
is illustrated in
Fig 8
.
Neoromicia isabella
is distinguished from
N. tenuipinnis
(skull figured in
Monadjem
et al.
, 2010: 479
) by slightly larger cranial and dental measurements (
Table 4
), particularly in the greatest skull length and the upper and lower molar rows. Greatest skull length in
N. rendalli
(skull figured in
Monadjem
et al.
, 2010: 475
) is similar to that of
N. isabella
, but its cranium is wider, as expressed by zygomatic width, greatest width of braincase, and mastoid width (
Table 4
).
Within the genus
Neoromicia
the greatest skull length of
N. isabella
(GSKL 12.5–13.0 mm) is of medium size and less robust than in
N. rendalli
, with a narrow maxillary and braincase and a fragile zygomatic arch. Skulls of 15 other species assignable to the genus
Neoromicia
(see accounts in
Monadjem
et al.
, 2010
,
2013
b
;
Goodman
et al.
, 2012
; Happold and
Happold, 2013
) are either larger or smaller in length. The dorsal profile of the skull is slightly concave at the rostrum and slopes gradually upwards to the occiput. There is no sagittal crest, but a faint lambdoid crest. The dental formula is I2/3, C1/1, P1/2, M3/3 = 32, as in the other
Neoromicia
. Several observers have reported the presence of a tiny anterior upper premolar present on either or both sides of the upper jaw in
N. tenuipinnis
(
Hayman, 1954
;
Schlitter
et al.
, 1982
; Thorn and Kerbis Peterhans, 2009). The occasional presence of this tiny anterior upper premolar is not unusual in
Neoromicia
species (e.g. see
Rosevear, 1965
; Happold and
Happold, 2013
); however, not one of the specimens that we examined displayed such a tooth. The anterior upper incisor is more than twice as long as the posterior (about twice in
N. rendalli
and
N. tenuipinnis
—
Monadjem
et al.
, 2010
) and unicuspid. The upper canine is long; 1.6-times as long as the anterior upper incisor, and 2.5-times as long as the subsequent premolar. The upper molar rows (C–M
3
) are almost parallel; the molars are shorter than wide, and all teeth from the canine to the third molar are in contact. The mandible length is intermediate between that of
N. tenuipinnis
and
N. rendalli
(
Table 4
). The lower incisors are all trifid.
FIG. 5. Dorsal and ventral view of a live-captured
N. tenuipinnis
from Liberia. Note the dark dorsal fur (Photographs by A. Monadjem)
FIG. 6. Outlines of the left tragus in
N. rendalli
(left),
N. tenuipinnis
(middle; both redrawn after
Rosevear 1965
), and
N. isabella
sp. nov.
(
holotype
)
Comparisons and Designation of a
Neotype
for
Neoromicia tenuipinnis
Our comparisons are hampered because the
holotype
of
N. tenuipinnis
is lost (Turni and Kock, 2008), and the original description of
Peters (1872)
does not include skull measurements. Likewise, the description of
N. rendalli
by
Thomas (1889)
does not contain skull measurements; however, the
holotype
skull (BMNH 1889.3.2.3) is figured in
Monadjem
et al.
(2010)
and in the
ACR (2015
: Appendix), and was examined by AM. External measurements of the types of both taxa, however, are congruent with the current treatment of the species (
Table 3
).
Externally the new species is quite distinct. Our images (
Fig. 4
) may be compared with those of
N. tenuipinnis
from
Liberia
(
Fig. 5
) and another one from
Comoe
National Park,
Côte d’Ivoire
(http:// www.inaturalist.org/photos/189398). The latter species has much darker body coloration.
Neoromica rendalli
is also darker, and the dark-brown coloration extends to the ventral surface of the body (specimen ZFMK 1977.1015 from
South Sudan
).
Neoromicia isabella
is immediately distinguishable from its sister species
N. roseveari
, itself only recently described, by its white wings and the rich colour of its fur. In
N. roseveari
, the wings are dark and the fur is dark brown (
Monadjem
et al
., 2013
b
). Furthermore,
N. roseveari
is far larger (for the
holotype
, FA is
37.1 mm
and GSKL is
14.36 mm
).
The whole group, however, may include further unrecognized taxa if one looks at the genetic and morphological variation throughout Africa, which is beyond the scope of our paper. Specimens from
Nigeria
to Central Africa mentioned by
Bergmans (1977)
, Viellard (1974), Thorn and Kerbis Peterhans (2009),
Bates
et al.
(2013)
, and other authors should be re-examined in the context of a revision of the genus. It should be also noted that the most current range map for
N. tenuipinnis
sensu lato
(
Fahr, 2013
e
) may contain records of both
N. tenuipinnis
sensu stricto
(see below) and the newly described
N. isabella
.
FIG. 7. Comparison of bacula. A,
N. rendalli
, dorsal and lateral views (adopted from
Kearney
et al
., 2002
); B, C,
N. isabella
sp. nov.
, digital
x
-ray in semi-lateral view (ZFMK 2008.0292, holotype) and dorsal and lateral views of DM12619; D,
N. tenuipinnis
(DM13235, Neotype). Scale bar = 1 mm (C, D modified from
Monadjem
et al
., 2013
a
)
FIG. 8. Dorsal, ventral and lateral views of the cranium and lateral view of the mandible of
N. isabella
sp. nov.
(ZFMK 2008.0292, JD 650, the holotype) from the Foko Confluence, Simandou Range, Guinea. Greatest length of skull is 12.98 mm. (Photographs by R. Hutterer)
Under these circumstances, however, we consider it essential to fix the morphological and genetic characters of
N. tenuipinnis
and to designate a
neotype
for
Vesperus tenuipinnis
Peters, 1872
(now
Neoromicia tenuipinnis
), because the former
holotype
, an adult female from ‘Guinea’ (
Peters, 1872: 264
), in the
Berlin
Museum (ZMB) is lost (Turni and Kock, 2008).
Monadjem
et al.
(2013
b
)
listed a specimen in the Natural History Museum, London (BMNH 1889.5.1.3) as a ‘syntype’ of
N. tenuipinnis
, which however is incorrect, as
Peters (1872: 264)
only mentioned a single specimen in the
Berlin
Museum at hand; the one, which is now lost.
Here we designate specimen
DM
13235 in
the Durban Natural Science Museum as the
neotype
. It consists of a male specimen collected by
A. Monadjem
at
Bonlah village
, near Yekepa at the base of Mount
Nimba
,
Liberia
on
7 January 2012
; external and cranial measurements are included in
Tables 3
and
4
. The body is preserved in formalin with the skull extracted. The tragus and the baculum (also
Fig. 7C
) are documented in
Monadjem
et al.
(2013
b
:
Figs. 4D
and
6D
). A COI sequence is deposited in GenBank (
JX
508831
). The external measurements of the
neotype
are very similar to those of Peters’ (1872) lost
holotype
(
Table 3
).
TABLE 3. External measurements (mm) and body mass (g) of specimens of the new species
N. isabella
sp. nov.
from Guinea and Liberia and of other white-winged
Neoromicia
species from West Africa. Values taken from published resources marked by an asterisk
Specimen or taxon |
Total length |
Tail length |
Forearm length |
Hindfoot length |
Ear length |
Body mass |
Neoromicia isabella
sp. nov.
|
80 |
27 |
31.7 |
7.3 |
10 |
5.5 |
Holotype ZFMK 2008.0292 |
Neoromicia isabella
sp. nov.
|
78 |
24 |
29.9 |
6.0 |
12 |
4.0 |
Paratype ZFMK 2008.0291 |
Neoromicia isabella
sp. nov.
DM 12619
|
74 |
36 |
28.0 |
5 |
13 |
4.8 |
Nimba, Liberia (
Monadjem
et al
., 2013
b
)*
|
Neoromicia tenuipinnis
lost holotype,
|
76 |
30 |
29 |
6 |
11.5 |
– |
Guinea (
Peters, 1872
)*
|
Neoromicia tenuipinnis
Neotype DM 13235
|
72 |
30 |
29.3 |
5 |
12 |
3.5 |
Nimba, Liberia |
Neoromicia tenuipinnis
|
– |
– |
29.0 |
6.2 |
13.3 |
– |
Ivory Coast (
De Vree, 1971
)*
|
Neoromicia
cf.
tenuipinnis
|
– |
31 |
28 |
5.5 |
11.5 |
– |
Guinea, Nimba (
Aellen, 1963
)*
|
Neoromicia
cf.
tenuipinnis
|
83 |
30 |
27 |
– |
12 |
– |
Guinea (
Konstantinov
et al
., 2000
)*
|
Neoromicia rendalli
Holotype BMNH
|
89 |
39 |
36 |
– |
13 |
– |
1889.3.2.3, Gambia (
Thomas, 1889
)*
|
Neoromicia rendalli
DM 13712
|
92 |
36 |
33.7 |
8.0 |
12 |
6.0 |
Sierra Leone (A. Monadjem, unpublished data) |
Neoromicia rendalli
|
89.5 |
41.5 |
34.5 |
7.1 |
13.3 |
– |
Gambia, SMF 91086 (
Kock
et al
., 2002
)*
|
Neoromicia rendalli
|
86.8 |
37.1 |
37.0 |
7.5 |
12.5 |
– |
Gambia, SMF 91087 (
Kock
et al
., 2002
)*
|
In light of our new genetic analysis (
Fig. 3
), the genus
Neoromicia
, at least in West Africa, no longer appears to be paraphyletic (as suggested by
Monadjem
et al.,
2013
b
) but consists of a monophyletic clade. The
type
species of the genus,
N. zuluensis
(Roberts, 1924)
, was studied genetically by
Goodman
et al.
(2012)
showing that it is sister to
N. somalica
. We are therefore confident that our new species has been assigned to the correct genus. In our COI tree
N. isabella
is sister to
N. roseveari
, and both taxa sister to
N. brunnea
, while
N. tenuipinnis
and
N. rendalli
group more at the root of this clade (
Fig. 3
). Hence, whereas morphological characters suggest a closer relationship between
N. tenuipinnis
and
N. isabella
, this is not supported by the genetic analysis.
Remarks
This is the first record of a white-winged bat from the Simandou Range, initially identified as
N. tenuipinnis
. Eleven individuals were captured, all between
7 and 9 March
2008
in the canopy net over the creek at FC, two of which were kept as vouchers. They group with specimen DM12619 from Mount
Nimba
,
Liberia
, that was labelled
Neoromicia
cf.
rendalli
by
Monadjem
et al.
(2013
b
)
.
Neoromica
isabella
was not recorded during the 2002 RAP, nor the 2003 RAP. The individuals captured in the context of this study over the forest creek at FC suggests that
N. isabella
uses drainages lines as travel routes probably emerging from hollow trees or rock crevices upstream. The specimen from the Liberian portion of Mount
Nimba
was captured emerging from the roof of a hut in a small village close to the larger settlement of Yekepa (
Monadjem
et al.
, 2013
b
).
Records from adjacent regions (
Aellen, 1963
;
De Vree, 1971
; Bützler, 1994;
Fahr
et al.
, 2006
; Monadjem and Fahr, 2007) may refer either to
N. tenuipinnis
or to the new species.
Monadjem
et al.
(2013
b
)
collected both species on Mount
Nimba
. A specimen mentioned by
Roche (1971)
as
N. tenuipinnis
deviates by very small external and cranial measurements, and until a re-examination of the voucher specimen we regard this record with caution.
TABLE 4. Skull measurements (mm) of specimens of the new species
N. isabella
sp. nov.
from Guinea and Liberia and of other white-winged
Neoromicia
species from West Africa, partly quoted from
De Vree (1971)
,
Kock
et al.
(2002)
and
Monadjem
et al.
(2013
a
)
. Measurement abreviations: GSKL — greatest skull length; CIL — condylo-incisive length; CCL — condylo-canine length; ZYGO — greatest zygomatic breadth; GBW — greatest braincase width; GSH — greatest skull height; POB — postorbital width; MAST — greatest mastoid breadth; MAND — greatest mandible length; M
3
–M
3
— width across the third molars; C–M
3
— complete upper canine-molar tooth row length; C–C — width across upper canines; C–M
3
— complete mandibular canine-molar tooth row length (see
Monadjem
et al.
, 2013
a
for more details). Values taken from published resources marked by an asterisk
Taxon and/or specimen |
GSKL |
CIL |
CCL |
ZYGO |
GBW |
GSH |
POB |
MAST |
MAND |
M3–M3 |
C–M3 |
C–C |
C–M3 |
N. isabella
sp. nov.
|
12.98 |
12.47 |
11.88 |
8.48 |
6.59 |
6.30 |
3.42 |
7.26 |
9.47 |
5.40 |
4.64 |
4.57 |
5.04 |
Holotype ZFMK 2008.0292 |
N. isabella
sp. nov. DM 12619,
|
12.99 |
12.55 |
11.85 |
7.58 |
6.53 |
5.97 |
3.77 |
6.96 |
9.32 |
5.33 |
4.46 |
4.15 |
5.35 |
Nimba, Liberia (
Monadjem
et al
., 2013
a
)
|
N. tenuipinnis
Neotype DM 13235,
|
12.50 |
11.35 |
11.06 |
7.32 |
6.53 |
5.41 |
3.80 |
6.75 |
8.62 |
5.03 |
4.31 |
3.82 |
4.48 |
Nimba, Liberia (
Monadjem
et al
., 2013
a
)
|
N. tenuipinnis
12.0, 12.4
|
11.6, 11.7 |
– |
–, 7.5 |
– |
– |
– |
– |
– |
5.0, 5.1 |
– |
3.7, 3.7 |
4.7, 4.7 |
Ivory Coast (
De Vree, 1971
)*
|
N. rendalli
|
13.60 |
13.10 |
12.80 |
– |
7.50 |
5.80 |
4.00 |
7.80 |
10.00 |
6.00 |
4.80 |
4.80 |
5.10 |
Holotype BMNH 1889.3.2.3 |
N. rendalli
|
12.98 |
12.57 |
– |
9.20 |
7.18 |
– |
3.90 |
7.98 |
10.19 |
– |
4.65 |
4.35 |
5.03 |
Gambia, SMF 91086 (
Kock
et al
., 2002
)*
|
N. rendalli
|
13.61 |
12.57 |
– |
9.90 |
6.93 |
– |
3.94 |
8.05 |
10.17 |
– |
4.79 |
4.28 |
5.26 |
Gambia, SMF 91087 (
Kock
et al
., 2002
)*
|
N. rendalli
Sierra Leone, DM 13712
|
13.36 |
12.90 |
12.58 |
– |
7.27 |
5.57 |
4.09 |
7.54 |
9.55 |
5.76 |
4.44 |
4.01 |
4.98 |
N. rendalli
S. Sudan, ZFMK 77.1015
|
13.36 |
12.70 |
12.29 |
8.92 |
7.14 |
6.16 |
3.72 |
7.71 |
9.45 |
5.83 |
4.60 |
4.23 |
5.17 |
Conservation status
The conservation status of this species has not yet been evaluated (
IUCN, 2015
).
Neoromicia roseveari
Monadjem, Richards, Taylor and Stoffberg, 2013
New material
ZFMK
2008.0293,
♂
, FC,
7 March 2008
;
ZFMK
2008.0294,
♀
, FC,
7 March 2008
.
In the molecular analysis (
Fig. 3
), the two individuals of this species captured at FC group with specimens that
Monadjem
et al.
(2013
b
)
described as a new species,
N. roseveari
, from Mount
Nimba
. The dark fur colour dorsally and ventrally and measurements fit well with those published in the description. Similar to the Mount
Nimba
specimens, our individuals were caught in lower lying areas of the study area in dense rainforest over the creek at FC. The female carried an embryo of
20 mm
crownrump length.
Conservation status
The conservation status of this species has not yet evaluated (
IUCN, 2015
).