Taxonomy and biostratigraphy of the elasmobranchs and bony fishes (Chondrichthyes and Osteichthyes) of the lower-to-middle Eocene (Ypresian to Bartonian) Claiborne Group in Alabama, USA, including an analysis of otoliths
Author
Ebersole, Jun A.
Author
Cicimurri, David J.
Author
Stringer, Gary L.
text
European Journal of Taxonomy
2019
2019-12-06
585
1
274
journal article
24105
10.5852/ejt.2019.585
dca608e8-fccf-4c1c-b8df-ef0c28e1d518
3660259
181B6FBA-ED75-4BB4-84C4-FB512B794749
Eutrichiurides plicidens
(
Arambourg, 1952
)
comb. nov.
Fig. 62
M–X
Trichiurus
(?)
plicidens
Arambourg, 1952: 265
, pl. 35, figs 39–42.
Trichiurus
sp. –
Clayton
et al.
2013
: fig.
6f.
Trichiurides
cf.
T. sagittidens
–
Maisch
et al.
2016
: fig. 2, 17–18.
Material examined
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
–
Alabama
• 11 isolated teeth; Claiborne Group;
MSC
188.2,
MSC
37127,
MSC
37148,
MSC
37153,
MSC
37460,
MSC
37484,
MSC
37908,
MSC
38435,
MSC
38482,
NJSM
24322,
WSU
5020.
Description
Largest tooth measuring
1.2 cm
in height. Teeth elongated, conical, posteriorly curving. Upper one-third of tooth also with medial bend; some specimens slightly sigmoidal in profile. Anterior and posterior carinae absent. Medial and/or lateral carinae developed; medial carina more pronounced. Posterior face with fine striations extending nearly two-thirds height of the crown; anterior face smooth. Tooth base flat, with wide conical pulp cavity.
Remarks
The teeth in our sample are superficially similar to those of
Trichiurides sagittidens
and
Trichiurus oshosunensis
, but differ from both taxa by having one to two lateral carinae as opposed to anterior and/ or posterior carinae. The specimens in our sample appear to be conspecific with
Arambourg’s (1952)
Trichiurus plicidens
, from the Ypresian of
Morocco
, as they are slightly sigmoidal, have one-to-two lateral carinae, lack an apical barb, and have striated ornamentation (
Arambourg 1952: 265
, pl. 35, figs 39–42).
Arambourg (1952)
tentatively placed this species within
Trichiurus
because of the striations occurring on the tooth crown.
Herein we argue for a new combination for the
plicidens
morphology, placing it within the genus
Eutrichiurides
. This stems from the fact that the
plicidens
morphology has one-to-two lateral carinae (as opposed to anterior or posterior carinae), which is a characteristic of
Eutrichiurides
as seen on the
type
specimen of
E. winkleri
(
Casier 1946
: pl. 4, fig. 19b), on
White’s (1931
: fig. 2) figured specimen of
E. orpiensis
(Leriche, 1906)
, and on specimens illustrated by
Casier (1944)
when he redescribed
E. delheidi
(Leriche, 1908)
. Although
Gago (1997)
observed that apical barbs are present on adult teeth but absent on juvenile teeth of extant
Trichiurus
species,
Casier (1944)
noted that barbs are completely lacking on teeth of all
Eutrichiurides
(see
White 1931
: fig. 2;
Casier 1944
: pl. 1 figs 5–9, 12–18, 1946: pl. 4, fig. 19b;
Arambourg 1952: 265
, pl. 35, figs 39–42). The combination of having lateral carinae, striations on the tooth crown, and the lack of an apical barb on all the observed specimens suggests these teeth are more closely aligned with
Eutrichiurides
, rather than
Trichiurides
or
Trichiurus
, and serves as the basis for this new combination. An “indeterminate fish tooth” figured by
Otero
et al.
(2015: 14
, fig. 11) from the Bartonian of
Libya
may be conspecific with
E. plicidens
comb. nov.
Stratigraphic and geographic range in
Alabama
The specimens in our sample were collected from the contact of the Tallahatta and
Lisbon
formations at sites ACh-14 and ACov-11, the basal
Lisbon
Formation at site ACov-11, and the basal Gosport Sand at site ACl-4. Lower Lutetian to middle Bartonian, zones NP14 to NP17.