Typification of Solanum species (Solanaceae) described by Casimiro Gómez Ortega
Author
Knapp, Sandra
Department of Botany, The Natural History Museum, Cromwell Road, London SW 7 5 BD, United Kingdom.
s.knapp@nhm.ac.uk
text
Anales del Jardín Botánico de Madrid
2013
2013-08-21
70
1
56
61
journal article
10.3989/ajbm.2340
e3ba0985-1b5b-4995-99c4-077c7eed9489
6327658
Solanum ficifolium
Ortega, Nov. Pl. Descr. Dec. 116. 1800
Ind. loc.: “
Habitat
in Insula Cuba.
Floret
in Horto R. Matrit. Octobri, et Novembri, è seminibus missis per
D. Espinosa
”.
Neotype
, designated here:
MA
334586
.
Current accepted name:
Solanum ferrugineum
Jacq.
Solanum ficifolium
has long been treated as a synonym of the widespread tropical weed
S. torvum
Sw.
(e.g.,
Dunal, 1813
,
1852
;
Whalen, 1984
;
Nee, 1999
) but none of the material in MA identifiable with Ortega’s epithet corresponds to that species. It is possible that this synonymy was predicated on the type locality of Cuba cited by Gómez Ortega; seeds were said to have been sent by Mariano Espinosa, a Cuban resident and correspondent of Gómez Ortega’s who was in contact with but not part of the Sessé and Mociño expedition (
McVaugh, 1977
;
Blanco & al., 2000
). All of the material annotated as
S. ficifolium
I have found at MA (with a single expection see below) corresponds to
S. ferrugineum
, a species of western Mexico that does not occur on Cuba and that differs from
S. torvum
in its deflexed fruiting pedicels and glandular stellate trichomes. It is possible that Espinosa received seeds of
S. ferrugineum
from Sessé whilst the latter was in Cuba (1795-1798) and then sent them to Gómez Ortega without provenance, hence the assumption they were from a Cuban plant. Some support for this explanation can be found also in the case of
Malvella leprosa
(Ortega) Krapovickas
(
Malvaceae
), a common Mexican species unknown from Cuba, that was originally described by Ortega based on plants grown from supposedly Cuban seeds sent by Espinosa (
Fuertes & Fryxell, 1993
).
Four sheets annotated as
S. ficifolium
were found in the general herbarium at MA, all appear to have been prepared from plants grown in the garden. MA308539 bears a label “
Solanum ficifolium Ortega
, ex horto 1803” in the hand of José Demetrio Rodriguez and has sinuate leaves and two small inflorescences; it was collected after the publication of
S. ficifolium
and possibly could be from different plants to those seen by Ortega. MA 334586/4 is a mixed collection with three plant fragments and two labels “
Solanum ficifolium Ortega
” in hand of José Demetrio Rodriguez (?) and “
Solanum ficifolium
[Lagasca hand]/ Ortega Decad [unknown hand]/Rl. Jardin de Madrid [pale brown unknown hand, see above]”. Of the three fragments on sheet two are referable to
S. ferrugineum
Jacq.
, one with more or less sinuate leaves (in the upper L of the sheet) and the other with the characteristic deflexed fruiting pedicels of that species (lower right of the sheet); neither of these fragments have flowers. The third plant fragment is a tiny piece of what appears to be
S. capense
L. A sheet (MA 334586/2) labelled “
Solanum ficifolium Ortega
” in unknown hand consists of three fragments that are clearly referable to
S. ferrugineum
, two have flowers and fruit on deflexed pedicels and the third only flowers. These fragments are from older plants with angular (not sinuate) leaves, in
Solanum
juvenile leaves are often repand and sinuate (
Roe, 1966
). Also filed as
S. ficifolium
MA
334586/3 has a typed label stating “ex. Hort Matr 1803” and is a good specimen of
S. ferrugineum
.
Fig. 1
.
a,
neotype of
Solanum cymosum
Ortega
(=
Solanum lanceolatum
Cav.
) (MA 476353);
b,
neotype of
Solanum ficifolium
Ortega
(=
Solanum ferrugineum
Jacq.
) (MA 334586);
c,
neotype of
Solanum leprosum
Ortega
(=
Solanum elaeagnifolium
Cav.
) (MA 334600);
d,
neotype of
Solanum subbiflorum
Ortega
(=
Solanum capense
L.
) (MA308482).
MA 334586 was annotated as “lectotype” by A.L. Cabrera 1971 but the lectotypification was never published. This specimen (
Fig. 1B
) has a label with “
Solanum ficifolium Ortega
/ ex Hort. Reg. Matr. anno 1803” in hand of José Demetrio Rodriguez and is a young flowering plant with sinuate leaves and three inflorescences (one of which is branched). This sheet best matches Ortega’s protologue which mentions both sinuate leaves and branched inflorescences and so is here selected as the neotype (
Fig. 1b
). Although this juvenile plant lacks the diagnostic fruiting pedicels, the stems and inflorescences have the glandular stellate trichomes characteristic of
S. ferrugineum
.