Battling the un-dead: the status of the Diptera genus-group names originally proposed in Johann Wilhelm Meigen’s 1800 pamphlet
Author
Evenhuis, Neal L.
Author
Pape, Thomas
text
Zootaxa
2017
4275
1
1
74
journal article
32874
10.11646/zootaxa.4275.1.1
02308cb2-2ac2-407f-aa58-b7f5b657fc44
1175-5326
804234
065D531F-1095-4364-906B-EC55CFF9BFD4
23.
Euribia
[
Euribia
]
Meigen, 1800: 36
.
CURRENT STATUS: Unavailable name; work suppressed for the purposes of zoological nomenclature by action of I.C.Z.N. (1963: 339 [Opinion 678]); treated under
Urophora
Robineau-Desvoidy, 1830
[
teste
Norrbom
et al
. (1999: 241)
].
Euribia
Latreille
,
1802
:
458
.
ORIGINALLY INCLUDED SPECIES:
Musca cardui
Linnaeus, 1758
;
Musca umbellatarum
Fabricius, 1775
(in
Latreille 1802: 458
).
TYPE SPECIES:
Musca cardui
Linnaeus, 1758
, by subsequent designation (
Hendel 1927: 37
).
CURRENT STATUS: Senior synonym of
Urophora
Robineau-Desvoidy, 1830
.
New Synonymy
.
FAMILY:
TEPHRITIDAE
.
REMARKS:
Euribia
was originally proposed by
Meigen (1800: 36)
without included species and later made unavailable by the suppression of the entire work for the purposes of zoological nomenclature by action of the I.C.Z.N. (1963: 339 [Opinion 678]).
Latreille (1802: 458)
was the first subsequent usage of
Euribia
after
Meigen (1800)
where
Euribia
was placed in synonymy with
Musca
Linnaeus, 1758
,
sensu lato
, and included two species:
Musca umbellatarum
Fabricius, 1775
and
Musca cardui
Linnaeus, 1758
. The name was made available by subsequent usage as valid in
Hendel (1908: 64)
.
Coquillett (1910a: 542)
designated
Musca artemisiae
Fabricius, 1794
as
type
species of
Euribia
[with Meigen as author], but, although this was one of the four nominal species included by
Hendel (1908: 64)
, it was not one of the two originally included species in
Latreille (1802)
, thus it is an invalid designation.
Hendel’s (1927: 37)
designation of
Musca cardui
Linnaeus, 1758
is the first valid typification of
Euribia
.
Musca cardui
Linnaeus, 1758
is currently treated as a species of
Urophora
Robineau-Desvoidy, 1830
[
teste
Norrbom
et al
. (1999: 241)
], which makes
Euribia
Latreille, 1802
a
senior synonym of
Urophora
Robineau-Desvoidy, 1830
,
n. syn
. Since the inclusion of species in
Trypeta
Meigen (1803)
and
Meigen’s (1804
: xxi) synonymization of
Trypeta
Meigen, 1803
with
Latreille’s (1802: 458)
“
caudatae
” [which is the group that
Euribia
was placed in synonymy with by
Latreille (1802)
], subsequent works treating the
Meigen 1800
names (e.g.,
Coquillett 1910a
;
Stone 1941
) have synonymized
Euribia
with
Trypeta
Meigen, 1803
. However,
Hendel’s (1927: 37)
type
designation of
Musca cardui
Linnaeus, 1758
fixed the generic concept of
Euribia
as synonymous with
Urophora
Robineau-Desvoidy, 1830
. Despite the suppression of
Meigen (1800)
,
Euribia
has been used as a valid name at least up to 1974 (
Lin & Tseng 1974
) and more than 60 of the 209 species-group taxa currently listed in
Urophora
[see
Norrbom
et al
. (1999: 241)
] were originally described in
Euribia
. It is not currently clear, but if a strong case could be made that this change of name would threaten the stability of nomenclature and taxonomy, then an application should be submitted to the ICZN Commission to conserve
Urophora
Robineau-Desvoidy, 1830
over
Euribia
Latreille, 1802
.