Phylogenetic relationships of family groups in Pentatomoidea based on morphology and DNA sequences (Insecta: Heteroptera)
Author
Grazia, Jocelia
Department of Zoology, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil
jocelia@ufrgs.br
Author
Schuh, Randall T.
Division of Invertebrate Zoology, American Museum of Natural History, New York, NY 10024, USA
Author
Wheeler, Ward C.
Division of Invertebrate Zoology, American Museum of Natural History, New York, NY 10024, USA
text
Cladistics
2008
2008-11-21
24
932
976
journal article
10.1111/j.1096-0031.2008.00224.x
e89a8dfa-e923-4a01-97f4-4edd4a0b8db0
3968591
DINIDORIDAE Stål
Historical
:
Durai (1987)
, in a world revision of the
Dinidoridae
, recognized the subfamilies
Dinidorinae
, with the two tribes
Dinidorini
and
Thalmini
, and
Megymeninae
, also with two tribes,
Megymenini
and
Eumenotini
.
Lis (1990)
catalogued the Old World
Dinidoridae
.
Rolston et al. (1996)
summarized the current classification in their world catalogue of Dini-
doridae.
Gapud (1991)
considered
Dinidoridae
and
Tessaratomidae
to be sister groups with two synapomorphies supporting the grouping: partially exposed spiracles on the second abdominal segment (these
becoming completely exposed in
Tessaratomidae
), and greatly enlarged ninth paratergites. The
Dinidoridae
, on the other hand, is separated from the
Tessaratomidae
by the reduced gonangulum and the enlarged and often reticulate hemelytral membrane, both of which characters are not found exclusively in this group.
Kocorek and Lis (2000)
, in a cladistic revision of the
Megymeninae
, proposed anew tribe,
Byrsodepsini
, and established
Eumenotini
as a junior synonym of
Megymenini
sensu stricto.
Analytical result:
After extensive searching, we were unable to secure, either through our own fieldwork or that of others, material adequate for sequencing other than for the genus
Megymenum
, leaving the
Dinidorinae
without molecular data. Our unweighted and successively weighted morphological analyses (
Figs 42
and
43
) treat the broadly conceived
Dinidoridae
as paraphyletic; analysis of the morphological data under implied weights using PIWE (
Fig. 44
) treats the
Dinidoridae
as a monophyletic subset of a paraphyletic
Tessaratomidae
.
Megymenum
is treated as the sister-group of
Tessaratomidae
in the 52-taxon molecular and combined analyses when using a 1: 1 cost ratio (
Figs 45
and
51
). In the 92-taxon combined analyses, the
Dinidoridae
is paraphyletic within a larger
Tessaratomidae
using a 1: 1 cost ratio (
Fig. 53
), is the monophyletic sister group of a monophyletic
Tessaratomidae
using a 1: 2 cost ratio (
Fig. 54
), and also includes
Urochela
(
Urostylididae
) when applying a 2: 2 cost ratio (
Fig. 55
). The close association of the
Dinidoridae
with the
Tessaratomidae
in our analyses is concordant with the conclusions of
Gapud (1991)
, although there is no clearcut set of morphological characters that diagnoses that larger grouping. Future efforts should aim to produce a more broad-based taxon sample of sequence data for the group to test more rigorously its monophyly as well as its relationship with the
Tessaratomidae
as well as the remaining
Pentatomoidea
.