Thirteen new species of butterflies (Lepidoptera: Hesperiidae) from Texas
Author
Zhang, Jing
McDermott Center for Human Growth and Development and Department of Biophysics University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center 5323 Harry Hines Blvd., Dallas, TX, 75390 - 8816 USA
Author
Cong, Qian
McDermott Center for Human Growth and Development and Department of Biophysics University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center 5323 Harry Hines Blvd., Dallas, TX, 75390 - 8816 USA
Author
Grishin, Nick V.
Departments of Biophysics and Biochemistry University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center 5323 Harry Hines Blvd., Dallas, TX, 75390 - 9050 USA
text
Insecta Mundi
2023
2023-01-06
2023
969
1
58
journal article
10.5281/zenodo.7710103
1942-1354
7710103
Spicauda atelis
Grishin
,
new species
https://zoobank.org/
7F4E9AFE-1998-487A-BD6F-1841F6CB11EB
(
Fig. 1
part, 2, 3a, b, 4)
Definition and diagnosis.
In addition to species-level status of
S. zalanthus
, phylogenetic analysis of nuclear genome datasets of specimens identified as
Spicauda teleus
(e.g., Z chromosome genes,
Fig. 1a
) reveals their partitioning into 2 clades. One clade (
Fig. 1
blue) consists of specimens from South America and
Panama
, including specimens from the Guianas and
Brazil
, a region with the likely
type
locality of
S. teleus
. The other clade (
Fig. 1
red) is North American and does not have an available name.
Fst
/
Gmin
statistics for comparison of these two clades (red and blue) are 0.32/0.003 suggesting that they correspond to species-level taxa. Curiously, neither of the two species is monophyletic in mitogenomes (
Fig. 1b
) and their COI barcodes differ by only 0.3-0.6% (2-4 bp). There are no positions in the barcode that consistently differentiate the two species in all specimens we sequenced, suggesting mitochondrial introgression. The new species, represented by the red clade, is sister to
S. teleus
and keys to it (C.13.13) in
Evans (1952)
. It differs from
S. teleus
by a longer terminal spike in male genitalia and by a more robust and humped ampulla-costa, which is higher relative to the harpe and its spike than in
S. teleus
. Due to the cryptic nature of this species, most reliable identification is achieved by nuclear DNA comparison (not the COI barcodes!) and a combination of the following base pairs in the nuclear genome is diagnostic: aly5021.7.12:C2856T, aly
1779.5.1
:G723A, aly
2085.2.4
:T831A, aly536.8.1:T1305C, and aly536.8.1:C869G.
Figure 1.
Trees of
Spicauda teleus
group constructed from protein-coding regions in
a)
Z chromosome and
b)
mitochondrial genome:
S. atelis
sp. n.
(red),
S. teleus
(blue), and
S. zalanthus
(green) rooted with
S. tanna
(black). Primary type specimens are labeled in magenta. Statistical bootstrap support values are shown at nodes (regular in nuclear genome trees and ultrafast in mitogenome trees). For each specimen, the name adopted in this work is given first, and a previously used name is listed in square brackets (if different), supplemented with the DNA sample number, type status (see Materials and Methods for abbreviations) and general locality. See Table S1 in the Supplemental file <https://osf.io//vkj6d/> or NCBI database entries for additional data about these specimens. Synonyms are given in parentheses preceded by “=”. The type status refers to this synonym,if the synonym name is provided. The same notations are used throughout this work in other figures showing phylogenetic trees.
Barcode sequence of the
holotype
.
Sample NVG-14112D07, GenBank OP984702, 658 base pairs: AACTTTATATTTTATTTTCGGAATTTGAGCAGGATTAGTTGGAACTTCATTAAGATTACTTATTCGAACTGAATTAGGAATACCAGGA TCTTTAATTGGAGATGATCAAATTTATAATACTATTGTAACAGCTCATGCTTTCATTATAATTTTTTTTATAGTTATACCTATTATAATTG GAGGATTTGGAAATTGATTAATTCCTTTAATATTAGGAGCTCCTGATATAGCTTTCCCTCGTATAAATAATATAAGATTTTGATTATTAC CCCCATCTTTAACCCTTTTAATTTCAAGAAGCATTGTTGAAAATGGAGCAGGAACTGGATGAACTGTATACCCCCCTTTATCTTCTAA TATTGCCCATCAAGGAGCATCAGTAGATTTAGCAATTTTTTCTTTACATCTTGCAGGAATTTCATCAATTTTAGGAGCTATTAATTTTA TTACAACTATTATTAATATACGAATTAATAATTTATCATTTGATCAAATACCTTTATTTATTTGAGCTGTTGGAATTACAGCTTTATTATTA TTACTTTCATTACCTGTTTTAGCAGGTGCTATTACTATATTATTAACTGATCGAAATTTAAATACCTCATTTTTTGATCCTGCTGGGGGA GGAGATCCTATTTTATACCAACACCTATTT
Type material.
Holotype
:
♂
deposited in the
Texas
A&M University Insect Collection
,
College Station
,
Texas
,
USA
(
TAMU
), illustrated in
Fig. 2a
, bears the following five rectangular labels, four white: [
TEXAS
: | HIDALGO
COUNTY
| city of Mission | 10
th
Street at | irrigation ditch], [coll. |
11 Sep 1972
|
Roy O. Kendall
| &
C. A. Kendall
], [
HESPERIIDAE
, |
Pyrginae
: |
Urbanus teleus
|
♂
(
Hubner, 1821
) | det.
R
.
O. Kendall
|
M. & B. No.
28], [DNA sample ID: | NVG-14112D07 | c/o
Nick
V
.
Grishin
], and one red [
HOLOTYPE
♂
|
Spicauda atelis
|
Grishin
]
.
Paratypes
:
6♂♂
and
2♀♀
:
USA
1♀
NVG-14112D08
Texas
, Hidalgo
Co.
,
McAllen
,
18-Oct-1973
,
W. W. McGuire
[
TAMU
],
GenBank
accession OP762098 (
Fig. 2b
)
;
Mexico
:
1♂
NVG-3280
San Luis Potosi
,
El Salto Falls
,
24-Dec-1972
,
Roy O. Kendall
and
C. A. Kendall
leg., genitalia NVG150111-96, [
TAMU
] (
Fig. 3b
,
4
)
;
others in
USNM
,
1♂
NVG-19121B11
Hidalgo
,
40 mi
N of Jacala
,
18-Aug-1967
,
Gary F. Hevel
leg
;
1♂
NVG-19121A06
Oaxaca
,
Candelaria Loxicha
,
6-Jul-1974
;
Guatemala
1♂
NVG-19121A07
Peten
,
Finca Ixobel
S of Poptun
,
5-10- Jun-2003
,
R
.
Leuschner
leg.
;
Honduras
1♀
NVG-19121A08
Las Minas
,
30-Jul-1972
,
R
.
D. Lohman
;
El Salvador
1♂
NVG-19121A09
2 km
N
San Isidro
,
22-Oct-1967
,
E. L. Todd
;
Costa Rica
1♂
NVG-17106B07, 07-SRNP- 55853
Area de Conservación
Guanacaste
,
Guanacaste Prov.
,
Sector Mundo Nuevo
,
Mariano Pereira
leg. ex larva, eclosed on
23-May-2007
.
Type
locality.
USA
:
Texas
, Hidalgo Co., Mission, 10
th
Street at irrigation ditch.
Etymology.
The name of its sister species in Greek is τέλειος (téleios): perfect, complete, and this new one is incomplete: ατελής (atelís), because we do not completely know yet how to unambiguously identify this species by its phenotype. The name is a noun in apposition.
English name.
Atelis longtail.
Figure 2.
Spicauda atelis
sp. n
.
a)
holotype ♂ NVG-14112D07,
b)
paratype ♀ NVG-14112D08 dorsal (left) and ventral (right) views, data in text.
Figure 3.
Three species of
Spicauda
.
a–b)
S. atelis
sp. n
.
a)
USA: TX, Hidalgo Co., Mission, 3-Nov-2020, iNaturalist observation 64178872 © Mike Rickard.
b)
paratype NVG-3280, data in text, genitalia in Fig. 4, note the 5
th
subapical forewing spot—section of the wing magnified below.
c)
S. teleus
, Trinidad: Couva-Tabaquite-Talparo, 4-May-2022, iNaturalist observation 115731394 © ralytt.
d–e)
S. zalanthus
.
d)
NVG-19121B08 ♂ Brazil: Paraná, Curitiba, 900 m, 26-Oct-1969, O. Mielke leg. [USNM].
e)
NVG-19121F07 ♀ Brazil: Santa Catarina, Apr-1945 (no other data) [USNM]. Some images were color-corrected and/or rotated and iNaturalist photographs are available
under CC BY-NC 4.0 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
Figure 4.
Male genitalia of
Spicauda atelis
sp. n.
paratype NVG-3280 (data in text) in different views.
a)
left lateral,
b)
right dorsolateral,
c)
ventral,
d)
dorsal.
Distribution.
From the Lower Rio Grande Valley in South Texas to
Costa Rica
.
Comment.
The 5
th
forewing apical spot is sometimes present in this species, e.g., in the
paratype
NVG-3280 (
Fig. 3b
), which is not
U. tanna
Evans, 1952
by genomics (
Fig. 1
) and genitalia (
Fig. 4
).
Urbanus ehakernae
Burns, 2014
is a junior subjective synonym of
Urbanus
(
Urbanus
)
alva
Evans, 1952
Genomic analysis reveals that the type specimens of
Urbanus ehakernae
Burns, 2014
(type locality in
Costa Rica
) are intermixed in the same clade with specimens from
Mexico
(including a specimen from
Veracruz
) and
Belize
that we identified as
Urbanus alva
Evans, 1952
(type locality
Mexico
:
Veracruz
, Atoyac) (
Fig. 5a
purple). Their COI barcodes are 100% identical and all these specimens are phenotypically similar, including the
holotype
of
U. alva
. In particular, the iridescent overscaling is green (rather than blue), even partly yellowish, extensive on hindwing, reaching up to the distant third (females) or quarter (males), rather sharply transitioning to the dark brown submarginal area. This overscaling is less prominent on forewings, yellower in color, particularly distad, green scales confined to the base, but extensive olive-yellow scales approach the discal band composed of large (compared to other species) spots. The ventral hindwing discal band is only slightly forked towards the costal margin in males. Therefore, we propose to treat
Urbanus ehakernae
Burns, 2014
,
new synonym
, as a junior subjective synonym of
Urbanus alva
Evans, 1952
.