An update of the blow flies (Diptera: Calliphoridae) of the Galápagos Islands, and first record of Chrysomya rufifacies (Macquart) from mainland Ecuador
Author
Tantawi, Tarek I.
Author
Sinclair, Bradley J.
text
Zootaxa
2013
3750
3
237
250
journal article
10.11646/zootaxa.3750.3.4
cfba21cd-2767-4e6c-bb62-7db6a118917f
1175-5326
218984
51C59B89-D7A1-4650-BDA0-D16F9E52E4EC
Cochliomyia
Townsend
In this study, we consider the secondary screwworm fly
Cochliomyia macellaria
native (not an introduced species) to the Galápagos Islands because this species was first collected with
L. pionia
by Darwin in 1835 (James 1966) and it is a member of the native species composition of carrion calliphorids in the Neotropical Region (James 1970; Dear 1985). However, James (1966), Peck
et al
. (1998) and Causton
et al
. (2006) have labeled
Co. macellaria
in their studies as an introduced species.
FIGURE 3.
Lucilia pionia
. A. Head, female (Fernandina), anterolateral view showing strong head protrusion. B. Head, female (Santa Cruz), anterolateral view showing weaker head protrusion. C. Head, male (Santa Cruz), lateral view. D. Head, male (Santiago), anterolateral view showing strong head protrusion. E. Head, male (Santa Cruz), anterolateral view showing weaker head protrusion. F. Head, male (Santa Cruz), anterior view. G–H. Male terminalia (Santa Cruz). G. Posterior view. H. Lateral view. I. Male sternite 5 (Santa Cruz).
FIGURE 4.
Lucilia
sp. near
pionia
(Española Island). A. Head, female, anterolateral view. B. Head, male, anterolateral view. C. Head, male lateral view. D. Head, male, anterior view. E–F. Male terminalia. E. Posterior view. F. Lateral view. G. Male sternite 5.
Chrysomya
Robineau-Desvoidy
The hairy maggot blow fly
Chrysomya albiceps
and the Oriental latrine blow fly
Ch. megacephala
are introduced species to the Galápagos Islands, which were first collected in the Galápagos in 1989 (Peck
et al
. 1998, where first record of
Ch. albiceps
was incorrectly cited as 1985). In the same year or earlier, Olsen
et al
. (1992) recorded for the first time
Ch. megacephala
from the Ecuadorian mainland. These two species along with
Ch. putoria
(Wiedemann, 1830)
were introduced from the Old World and first recorded in southern
Brazil
in
1975–1977
(Guimarães
et al
. 1978, 1979), and since then have become widespread in South
America
.
Chrysomya albiceps
and
Ch. megacephala
are well known to breed in carrion (Vasconcelos & Araujo 2012; Moretti & Godoy 2013), and both species are of forensic and medical importance (Zumpt 1965; Greenberg 1971; Guimarães
et al
. 1983; Smith 1986; Olsen
et al
. 1993; Mavarez-Cardozo
et al
. 2005; Ferraz
et al
. 2011). Because third-instar larvae of
Ch. albiceps
are facultative predators on larvae of other necrophagous flies (Zumpt 1965; Faria
et al
. 2004), this behavior may have a negative effect on the native fly species in the Galápagos Islands.
Laboratory studies have shown that
Ch. albiceps
can dramatically lower the abundance of
Co. macellaria
and
Ch. megacephala
in South
America
(Aguiar-Coelho & Milward-de-Azevedo 1995; Aguiar-Coelho
et al
. 1995; Rosa
et al
. 2006).
Chrysomya rufifaces
(Macquart)
, a species which also has the same predatory behaviour as
Ch. albiceps
, could significantly reduce the populations of
Co. macellaria
in carrion wherever the two species coexist (Wells & Greenberg 1992a, b). In a major survey of human cases of wound myiasis in Goiás State,
Brazil
, during
February 2005
–
August 2006
, Fernandes
et al
. (2009) did not record a single case involving
Co. macellaria
. They attributed this to the ongoing dramatic decrease in the populations of this native Neotropical species resulting from competition with introduced Old World species, especially
Ch. albiceps
. Results of a study on the abundance of species of
Calliphoridae
of public health and forensic importance in the Tinguá Biological Reserve, Nova Iguaçu, R.J.,
Brazil
during
March 1995
–
February 1996
strongly suggest the displacement of
Co. macellaria
by
Ch. albiceps
(Batista-da-Silva
et al
. 2011).
Because carrion fly communities are primarily structured by competition (Norris 1965; Kneidel 1984; Hanski 1987), future field studies on carrion calliphorids in the Galápagos Islands should explore the biological and ecological interactions between introduced and endemic species (see Hanski (1977) for the Canary Islands and Sinclair (2009) for the Galápagos Islands). It should be borne in mind that small isolated islands are characterized by a lower species richness of carrion flies due to fierce interspecific competition (Hanski 1977). In contrast, a higher species richness can be found on large islands and the mainland, where competition among different fly species may be alleviated mainly by differences in habitats (Lane 1975; Martin-Vega & Baz 2013) and seasonality (Tantawi
et al
. 1996; Martin-Vega & Baz 2013), thus facilitating coexistence.