Type Specimens Of Birds In The American Museum Of Natural History Part 8. Passeriformes:
Author
Pachycephalidae
Author
Aegithalidae
Author
Remizidae
Author
Paridae
Author
Sittidae
Author
Neosittidae
Author
Certhiidae
Author
Rhabdornithidae
Author
Climacteridae
Author
Dicaeidae
Author
Pardalotidae
Author
Nectariniidae, And
Author
Lecroy, Mary
Division of Vertebrate Zoology (Ornithology) American Museum of Natural History (lecroy @ amnh. org)
text
Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History
2010
2010-06-03
2010
333
1
178
journal article
0003-0090
Prionochilus plateni
Blasius
Prionochilus plateni
Blasius, 1888a
(February)
: 335 (
Palawan
).
Now
Prionochilus plateni plateni
Blasius, 1888
.
See
Salomonsen, 1960a
, 18–22, 25–26,
Dickinson et al., 1991: 388
, and
Cheke and Mann, 2008b: 369–370
.
LECTOTYPE
:
AMNH 698529
, adult male, collected at
Puerto Princesa
,
09.44 N
,
118.44E
(
Dickinson et al., 1991: 424
),
Palawan
Island
,
Philippines
, on
22 July 1887
, by
Carl C.
and
Margarete Platen
(specimen ‘‘b’’).
From
the
Rothschild Collection.
COMMENTS: Blasius’ descriptions, based on material collected by the Platens in 1887, have given rise to various problems, beginning with the descriptions of the new forms appearing in a local newspaper, Braunschweigische Anzeigen (on
12 February 1888
for
P. plateni
), closely followed in
April 1888
by descriptions of some of the same populations by Sharpe, based on Whitehead’s collection on
Palawan
. The problem of dating was clarified by
Blasius (1888b: 372–375)
. I have not seen the original newspaper description, but this was republished within quotation marks in
Blasius (1888c: 313)
.
Additionally, the Platens’ specimens were divided, after having been studied by Blasius, between the collections at SNMBG, where Blasius was curator, and the private collection of Adolph Nehrkorn, who had apparently sponsored the collecting (see
Hartert, 1920a: 431
). Further complicating matters, Blasius often did not designate a
type
and Nehrkorn exchanged an unknown number of Platen specimens with Rothschild, some of which were part of
type
series.
Hinkelmann and Heinze (1990)
were not aware that part of the Platen material was in AMNH (via Rothschild). At that time, I wrote Hinkelmann after checking the AMNH collection for related material. This was passed on to
Hevers (2005)
, who incorporated this material in his more extensive list of
types
in SNMBG.
In the original description of
P. plateni
, no type was designated and the number of specimens in the type series was not given. Later,
Hinkelmann and Heinze (1990: 622)
reported that there were at least 10, five of which were in SNMBG and were listed as
syntypes
of
P. plateni
. Two
syntypes
of
P. plateni
were also exchanged to Rothschild by Nehrkorn, both of which were marked ‘‘Type’’ on their labels.
Hartert (1920a: 430)
listed the male specimen, collected on
22 July 1887
, as the type, thereby designating it the
lectotype
. The second specimen,
AMNH 698533
, male, collected at
Puerto Princesa
on
13 July 1887
by the Platens (specimen ‘‘a’’), becomes a
paralectotype
, as do the rest of the
syntypes
.
See
also
Hevers (2005: 455)
. As this description was based on specimens collected in 1887, three AMNH specimens collected by the Platens in 1888 have no nomenclatural standing.
Salomonsen (1960a: 28)
noted that there was a
syntype
of
plateni
in both BMNH and AMNH, not mentioning the second
syntype
in AMNH or the
syntypes
in SNMBG, and selected the AMNH specimen as the
lectotype
, not realizing that it had already been designated the
lectotype
by Hartert.