Stone loaches of Choman River system, Kurdistan, Iran (Teleostei: Cypriniformes: Nemacheilidae)
Author
Kamangar, Barzan Bahrami
Author
Prokofiev, Artem M.
Author
Ghaderi, Edris
Author
Nalbant, Theodore T.
text
Zootaxa
2014
3755
1
33
61
journal article
36912
10.11646/zootaxa.3755.1.2
d165c041-bb19-478d-9011-a41450cde2f1
1175-5326
285463
C16D20B5-D480-4E7A-A64F-03281CB98E08
Oxynoemacheilus
Bănărescu & Nalbant, 1966
Type
species:
Cobitis persa
(nec Heckel, 1848)
Bănărescu & Nalbant, 1966
=
Oxynoemacheilus
cf.
brandti
(Kessler, 1877)
.
Emended diagnosis:
This genus can be distinguished from all other nemacheilid genera based on the following combination of characters: mouth unmodified, with lips furrowed to nearly smooth, processus dentiformis present or absent; preethmoidei-I absent; four cylindrical pectoral bony radials; mature males with epidermal tubercles widely distributed on head, body and paired fins, not forming separate pads; anus close to analfin origin; dorsal adipose crest present or absent, when present, of uniform height or gradually increasing in height towards base of caudal-fin; no jet-black mark at base of dorsal fin.
Remarks:
Prokofiev (2009)
transferred species having the free pelvic axillary lobe from
Oxynoemacheilus
to
Paracobitis
Bleeker, 1863
, which was not supported by Freyhof
et al.
(2011). Furthermore, in addition to the species listed by
Prokofiev (2009)
Freyhof
et al.
(2011: 303) reported the presence of the “small pelvic axillary lobe” in
O
. persa
, the
type
species of the genus. It should be noted, however, that
Bănărescu & Nalbant (1966: 153–154)
misidentified
O
. persa
with a species distributed in the Urmia Lake basin when they erected the taxon
Oxynoemacheilus
. Later, the true
O
. persa
was described by
Nalbant & Bianco (1998)
under the name of
O
. farsicus
, as clearly shown by Freyhof
et al.
(2011: 309). Thus, the taxon
Oxynoemacheilus
was based not on
O
. persa
, but on a species similar or identical with
O
. brandti
(Kessler, 1877)
according to the morphological description and Figure of the Urmian loaches in
Bănărescu & Nalbant (1966)
. Our personal data suppose a quite complex taxonomical situation in
O
brandti
/
bergianus
–complex which may represent more than two species; however, the results of the molecular analysis (I-Shiung Chen, B.A. Levin, personal communication 2012) does not correspond well with the morphological data; thus, it is not possible to separate reasonably the species within this group at current state of knowledge.
As
a result, the taxonomic position of the fishes from the Urmia Lake cannot be satisfactory determined at present.
In the present paper we accept the limits of the genera
Oxynoemacheilus
and
Paracobitis
proposed by Freyhof
et al.
(2011) due to the following reasons: (1) though we had not found other species having the free pelvic axillary lobe, we found a skin fold lacking the free posterior tip in the several specimens of the species described below. This fold can be homologous to the axillary lobe (reduced or incompletely developed), although further study is required; thus, this feature may have the mosaic distribution within the species of
Oxynoemacheilus
. (2) We studied specimens of
O
. tigris
(Heckel, 1843)
from Lake Kinneret, which possess the
type
of male breeding tubercles of
Oxynoemacheilus
. We also found both muscular cheeks and breeding tubercles in males of
Turcinoemacheilus kosswigi
(see below). Thus, the differences in the sexual dimorphic features among the genera
Oxynoemacheilus
and
Paracobitis
as proposed by
Prokofiev (2009)
may not be stable, and the interrelationships between the species of
Oxynoemacheilus
with and without pelvic axillary lobe and the species of
Paracobitis
requires further investigation.
In addition, we found high variability in the distribution of the breeding tubercles on the head and body among the species of
Oxynoemacheilus
. In the some species (i.e., the members of the
O
. angorae
-
brandti
–complexes from the Caspian Sea drainage) the breeding tubercles are rather homogeneously distributed on the head and body of the nuptial males, while in the others (including the species described in the present paper) the breeding tubercles are aggregated mostly on the snout, paired fins, ventral surface of body and on the area near the base of the dorsal fin. The phylogenetic value of these differences requires further research. The interrelationships of the species of
Oxynoemacheilus
and similar genera will be discussed in a separate paper after revision of the additional materials from the other basins.