Mitochondrial Dna Sequence Data Indicate Evidence For Multiple Species Within Peromyscus Maniculatus
Author
Bradley, Robert D.
Department of Biological Sciences and the Museum Texas Tech University Lubbock, TX 79409 - 3131
robert.bradley@ttu.edu
Author
Francis, James Q.
Department of Biological Sciences Texas Tech University Lubbock, TX 79409 - 3131
Author
Platt II, Roy N.
Department of Biological Sciences Texas Tech University Lubbock, TX 79409 - 3131
neal.platt@gmail.com
Author
Soniat, Taylor J.
Department of Biological Sciences Texas Tech University Lubbock, TX 79409 - 3131
taylor.soniat@ttu.edu
Author
Alvarez, Daysi
Author
Lindsey, Laramie L.
Department of Biological Sciences Texas Tech University Lubbock, TX 79409 - 3131
laramie.lindsey@ttu.edu
text
Special Publications of the Museum of Texas Tech University
2019
2019-10-10
70
1
59
journal article
http://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7221903
19390c14-db95-4117-a068-a097ab5fab4d
7221903
Peromyscus maniculatus
(Wagner)
Hesperomys maniculatus
Wagner, 1845:148
.
H[esperomys
]
gracilis
Le Conte, 1855:442
.
[
Hesperomys
]
arcticus
Coues, 1877:61,67
.
Sitomys americanus canadensis
Miller, 1893:55
.
Peromyscus leucopus nubiterrae
Rhoads, 1896:187
.
Peromyscus canadensis abietorium
Bangs, 1896:49
.
Peromyscus canadensis umbrinus
Miller, 1897:23
.
Peromyscus maniculatus
Bangs, 1898a:496
.
Peromyscus canadensis argentatus
Copeland and Church, 1906:122
.
Peromyscus maniculatus gracilis
Osgood, 1909:42
.
Peromyscus maniculatus abietorium
Osgood, 1909:45
.
Peromyscus maniculatus argentatus
Osgood, 1909:46
.
Peromyscus maniculatus eremus
Osgood, 1909:47
.
Peromyscus maniculatus nubiterrae
Osgood, 1909:47
.
Peromyscus maniculatus anticostiensis
Moulthrop, 1937:11
.
Peromyscus maniculatus plumbeus
C. F.
Jackson, 1939:101
.
Holotype
.—
Osgood (1909)
reported that the type specimen resided in the Zoologischer Staatssammlung in Munich, although no catalog number or ancillary data was provided. Specimens from the vicinity of Nain have been used for type location (
Osgood 1909
). Presumably collected by
Wagner
.
Type
locality.—
The exact
type
locality is not known; however, the Moravian settlements in Labrador, specimens from Nain have been used as the
type
location based on the interpretations of
Osgood (1909)
.
Subspecies.—
Although we were not able to examine all of the recognized subspecies that potentially are referable to
P
.
maniculatus
, we tentatively assign the following nine subspecies recognized in
Hall (1981)
to
P
.
maniculatus
:
abietorium
,
anticostiensis
,
argentatus
,
bairdi
,
eremus
,
gracilis
,
maniculatus
,
nubiterrae
, and
plumbeus
.
Diagnosis.—
Size is large for species group; measurements obtained from
Osgood (1909)
, for several of the subspecies now assigned to
P
.
maniculatus
, indicated a total length averaging
187 mm
; (range
174–200 mm
) and tail length averaging
91.5 mm
(range
79–104 mm
). Coloration is based on synopsis of
Osgood’s (1909)
observations of several subspecies - back and sides are dark brown and tinged with fawn (varies among subspecies); venter is white; ears are dusky with pale edges; and tail is bicolored (brownish black above and white underneath).
Genetically (mitochondrial sequences;
Dragoo et al. 2006
;
Kalkvik et al. 2012
),
P. maniculatus
(specifically, samples referable to
P
.
m
.
abietorium
,
P
.
m
.
bairdi
,
P
.
m
.
gracilis
,
P
.
m
.
plumbeus
,
P
.
m
.
maniculatus
, and
P
.
m
.
nubiterrae
) have been shown to differ from other populations formerly assigned to
P
.
maniculatus
from the southwestern and central United States (
P
.
sonoriensis
– see above; and
P. polionotus
). In this study,
Cyt
b sequences indicated that
P. maniculatus
differed from
P. gambelii
,
P
.
melanotis
,
P
.
polionotus
,
P
.
sejugis
, and
P
.
sonoriensis
, by 4.90%, 6.65%, 5.12%, 5.40%, and 4.68%, respectively. Genetic differentiation (= 1.69%) based on DNA sequences obtained from 68 individuals of
P
.
maniculatus
was among the largest intraspecific values obtained in this study; however,
P
.
maniculatus
possesses one of the broadest geographic distributions of any taxon examined.
Distribution.—
The distribution of
P
.
maniculatus
ranges from central Canada (Manitoba) eastward to Labrador then southward to Tennessee. It appears that populations of
P
.
maniculatus
are restricted to the eastern side of the Mississippi River. Samples from the western side of the Great Lakes area and boundaries of the provinces of Manitoba and Saskatchewan are needed to more accurately discern the boundaries of
P
.
maniculatus
and
P
.
sonoriensis
in this region.
Comparisons.—
A member of the
P. maniculatus
species group. Phenotypically resembles other species in terms of size and coloration; although total and tail lengths are greater (typically
187 mm
and
91.5 mm
versus
151 mm
and
65.5 mm
, respectively) than in
P
.
sonoriensis
(populations west of the Mississippi River) and especially in comparison to
P
.
polionotus
(populations in the southeastern United States which average
130 mm
and
47 mm
, respectively).
Remarks.—
One hundred-fourteen samples examined in this study were assigned to
P
.
maniculatus
. The
type
locality for
P. maniculatus
is unclear.
Osgood (1909)
interpreted the original
type
locality to be near the Moravian Settlements along the northeast coast of Labrador. In his revisionary work,
Osgood (1909)
included samples from Nain, Labrador as indicative of
P. maniculatus
. In this study, we also included two samples from Nain, Labrador; thereby following Osgood’s lead for a consistent comparison of presumably the same taxon.
Chromosomal variation reported for two of the subspecies in
P
.
maniculatus
includes a broad range of FNs for
P
.
m
.
abietorum
,
P. m. anticostiensis
,
P. m. gracillis
,
P. m.
maniculatus
, and
P. m plumbeus
(FN = 77, 82, 86–88; Singh and McMillian 1966; Myers Uncie et al. 1997). Clearly additional studies are needed to fill in the gaps for FNs that based on the current data, must range at least from 76 to 88. The FNs reported for
P
.
maniculatus
span the ranges for reported for
P
.
gambelii
,
P
.
labecula
, and
P
.
sonoriensis
; but differ substantially from those observed for
P
.
melanotis
(FN = 62, Hsu and Arrighi 1968;
Bowers et al. 1973
),
P
.
polionotus
(FN = 69–71,
Te and Dawson 1971
), and
P
.
sejugis
(FN = 76,
Smith et al. 2000
).
Recognition of
P
.
maniculatus
as a species, as outlined herein, is supported by the phylogenetic analyses of
Dragoo et al. (2006)
and
Kalkvik et al. (2012)
who suggested that a distinct lineage may occupy the northeastern United States and eastern Canada. Additionally,
Dragoo et al. (2006)
reported that the greatest genetic divergence occurred between eastern clades and western clades. DNA sequence data (
Cyt
b) and conformity to the genetic species concept (see
Bradley and Baker 2001
;
Baker and Bradley 2006
) support elevation to species status. Divergence time estimates indicate that
P. maniculatus
(
sensu stricto
) diverged from
P. labecula
approximately 1.28 mya.