A revision of the Schinia volupia (Fitch) species complex (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae: Heliothinae) Author Pogue, Michael G. Author Ouellette, Gary D. Author Harp, Charles E. text Zootaxa 2013 3716 2 157 191 journal article 10.11646/zootaxa.3716.2.3 9589c2b5-4db3-4bb1-800c-6807de82d0c9 1175-5326 248743 768FB82B-5EA9-4C89-9F68-F5D5E6286570 Schinia volupia (Fitch) ( Figs. 12–28 , 38–40, 44 , 50–52, 56 , 60–63 , 81 –82, 109 ) Alaria volupia Fitch, 1868: 908 . Rhododipsa volupia: Grote 1880: 47 .—Grote 1883:152.—Smith 1883: 250.—Smith 1891: 53.—Smith 1893: 273.—Dyar 1903: 186.— Holland 1903: 225.—Barnes and McDunnough 1917:38.—McDunnough 1938: 104. Schinia volupia: Franclemont and Todd 1983:158 .—Poole 1989:898.—Poole and Gentili 1996:772.—Hardwick 1996:153.— Lafontaine and Schmidt 2010:69. Rhododipsa masoni Smith, 1896:284 .—Dyar 1903:186.— Holland 1903:225.—Barnes and McDunnough 1917:38.— McDunnough 1938:105. new synonym Schinia masoni: Franclemont and Todd 1983:158 .—Poole 1989:895.—Poole and Gentili 1996:771.—Hardwick 1996:154.— Byers 1989:210 [life history]. Diagnosis. Schinia volupia is an extremely variable species across its wide geographic range. Specimens most resembling the holotype have a dark reddish-pink forewing and dark pink hind wing ( Figs. 22–23 ). Forewing ground color can vary from ochreous ( Figs. 15–16 ), gradually becoming more pink ( Figs. 17–18 ), to darker pink ( Figs. 19–21 ), to dark reddish-pink, to maroon ( Figs. 24–25 ). All of these forms have a pink to slightly darker pink hind wing. In other forms the forewing is mixed with dark reddish-pink and ochreous ( Figs. 26–29 ) and these have a gray hind wing mixed with some pink. Specimens previously recognized as S. masoni (Smith) have a dark reddish-pink forewing and dark gray hind wing ( Figs. 30–31 ). There is also variation in the form of the antemedial and postmedial lines varying from a solid, thin white line ( Figs. 15–18 ) to becoming a series of short dashes along wing veins that may or may not be connected by pale pink scales ( Figs. 19–31 ). Description. Head: Frons, vertex, and labial palp ochreous; eyes large, round. Thorax: Ground color darker ochreous than head. Foretibia with an elongate, curved inner spine with 1–2 smaller more slender spines proximally and 3–4 smaller, stout outer spines that are reduced in size proximally; middle and hind legs with obvious spines with the middle leg having a few more than the hind leg. Forewing ( Figs. 12–28 , 81–82 ): Length 9.0–11.6 mm; ground color variable from pink to dark pink to maroon; antemedial line crenulate, curved; orbicular spot variable in size from a few white scales to a small spot contiguous with the antemedial line; reniform spot absent; postmedial line a white quadrate spot on the costa then forms a zigzag line to posterior margin; fringe testaceous flushed with pink. Hind wing: Ground color pink to dark pink flushed with testaceous; fringe testaceous with pink basally. Abdomen: Ochreous with a variable amount of pink caudally. Second sternite with well developed hair pencil and associated pocket. Male genitalia ( Figs. 38–40, 44 ): Uncus of moderate length, length 0.31–0.33 X length of valve; valve length 5.26–6.67 X width, apex narrow, robust setae along slightly scalloped posterior margin; corona reduced, consisting of less than eight setae or absent; ampulla large (length= 0.10–0.12 X length of valve); saccus V-shaped. Female genitalia ( Figs. 60–63 ): Papillae anales triangulate, apex narrowly rounded; eighth segment with fine, elongate spicules; seventh segment with fine spicules extending onto distal margin, an irregular row of fine, elongate setae proximal to fine spicules, and shorter fine setae sparsely scattered on rest of segment; accessory bursae with three coils; corpus bursae slightly ovate; signa consisting of four elongate scobinate ribbons. Type material. Schinia volupia : Holotype ♀, No locality; three labels: 1) 1040 (hand written in red ink), 2) Alaria volupia Fitch (hand written in black ink), 3) Type , No. 283, U.S. N.M. (red label printed and hand written in black ink). Deposited in USNM. Schinia masoni : Lectotype ♀, five labels: 1) Denver, Colo. Bruce (hand written in black ink), 2) 36511 ( type set in black ink), 3) Rhododipsa masoni Type 1 Smith (red bordered, hand written in black ink), 4) Type , No. 4842, U.S. N.M. (red label printed and hand written in black ink), 5) Rhododipsa masoni Smith (black bordered white label with Lectotype and By printed in red). Lectotype designated by Todd (1982). Deposited in USNM. FIGURES 5–19. Adults. 5, Schinia miniana , ♀, California, Inyo Co., Olancha, USNMENT 00148151; 6, S. miniana , ♀, Utah, Washington Co., Hurricane, USNMENT 00148153; 7, S. miniana , ♀, Texas, Presidio Co., Shafter, USNMENT 00148149; 8, S. miniana , ♀, Texas, Brewster Co., Big Bend National Park, Oak Spring, USNMENT 00148148; 9, S. miniana , ♂, Texas, Brewster Co., Big Bend National Park, Oak Spring; 10, S. miniana , ♂, Texas, Brewster Co., Big Bend National Park, Oak Spring, USNMENT 00148800; 11, S. sanrafaeli , ♂, Utah, Grand Co., 1 mi E of Green River, USNMENT 00158786; 12, S. volupia , ♂, New Mexico, southern, USNMENT 00148801; 13, S. volupia , ♂, New Mexico, Torrance Co., 6 mi N of Gran Quivira National Monument, USNMENT 00255726; 14, S. volupia , ♀, New Mexico, Luna Co., Deming, USNMENT 00148147; 15, S. volupia , ♂, New Mexico, Torrance Co., 6 mi N of Gran Quivira National Monument, USNMENT 00158767; 16, S. volupia , ♂, Texas, Kerr Co., Kerrville, USNMENT 00148802; 17, S. volupia , ♂, Texas, Johnson Co., Cleburne State Park, USNMENT 00147634; 18, S. volupia , ♂, Oklahoma, Murray Co., 1 km W Turner Falls, Arbuckle Mts., USNMENT 00148803; 19, S. volupia , ♂, Texas, La Salle Co., Artesia Wells, USNMENT 0 0 148804. FIGURES 20–34. Adults. 20, Schinia volupia , ♂, Texas, La Salle Co., Artesia Wells, USNMENT 00148758; 21, S. volupia , ♂, Louisiana, Natchitoches Parrish, Red Dirt National Wildlife Refuge, Kisatchie National Forest, USNMENT 00155024; 22, S. volupia , ♂, Louisiana, Natchitoches Parrish, Red Dirt National Wildlife Refuge, Kisatchie National Forest, USNMENT 00155018; 23, S. volupia , ♂, Colorado, Douglas Co., 3.5 mi E of Palmer Lake, Co. Line Rd. at Beacon Lite Rd., USNMENT 00255716; 24, S. volupia , ♂, Colorado, Douglas Co., 3 mi E of Palmer Lake, Co. Line Rd. at Beacon Lite Rd., USNMENT 00255719; 25, S. volupia , ♂, Colorado, Douglas Co., 3.5 mi E of Palmer Lake, Co. Line Rd. at Beacon Lite Rd., USNMENT 00255720; 26, S. volupia , ♂, Colorado, Douglas Co., 3.5 mi E of Palmer Lake, Co. Line Rd. at Beacon Lite Rd., USNMENT 00255721; 27, S. volupia , ♂, Colorado, Douglas Co., 3.5 mi E of Palmer Lake, Co. Line Rd. at Beacon Lite Rd., USNMENT 00255722; 28, S. volupia ( S. masoni , holotype), ♀, Colorado, Denver; 29, S. fulleri (holotype), ♂, Florida, Highlands Co., Archbold Biological Station; 30, S. fulleri , ♂, Florida, Highlands Co., Archbold Biological Station, USNMENT 00148805; 31, S. biforma , ♀, Texas, Cottle Co., Paducah, USNMENT 00147523; 32, S. biforma , ♂, Texas, San Patricio Co., Sinton Welder Wildlife Foundation, USNMENT 00148806; 33, S. biforma , ♂, Texas, San Patricio Co., Sinton Welder Wildlife Refuge, USNMENT 00147522; 34, S. biforma , ♂, Texas, San Patricio Co., Sinton Welder Wildlife Foundation, USNMENT 0 0 147521. FIGURES 35–46. Male genitalia. 35, Schinia miniana , California, Inyo Co., Olancha, USNM 49921; 36, S. miniana , Texas, Brewster Co., Big Bend National Park, Oak Spring, USNM 49477; 37, S. miniana , California, San Bernardino Co., Yermo, USNM 49479; 38, S. volupia , New Mexico, Torrance Co., 6 mi N Gran Quivira National Monument, USNM 50603; 39, S. volupia , New Mexico, Torrance Co., 6 mi N Gran Quivira National Monument, USNM 50602; 40, S. volupia , Texas, Burnet Co., Shovel Mountain, USNM 49471; 41, S. sanrafaeli , Utah, Emery Co., I-70 roadside marker #150, USNM 50607; 42, S. sanrafaeli , Utah, Emery Co., San Rafael Desert, USNM 50606; 43, S. sanrafaeli , Utah, Emery Co., San Rafael Desert, USNM 50605; 44, S. volupia , Colorado, Jefferson Co., Turkey Creek Canyon, USNM 49473; 45, S. fulleri , Florida, Levy Co., Williston, USNM 47050; 46, S. biforma , Texas, San Patricio Co., Sinton Welder Wildlife Foundation, USNM 49590. FIGURES 47–58. Male aedeagi. 47, Schinia miniana , California, Inyo Co., Olancha, USNM 49921; 48, S. miniana , Texas, Brewster Co., Big Bend National Park, Oak Spring, USNM 49477; 49, S. miniana , California, San Bernardino Co., Yermo, USNM 49479; 50, S. volupia , New Mexico, Torrance Co., 6 mi N Gran Quivira National Monument, USNM 50603; 51, S. volupia , New Mexico, Torrance Co., 6 mi N Gran Quivira National Monument, USNM 50602; 52, S. volupia , Texas, Burnet Co., Shovel Mountain, USNM 49471; 53, S. sanrafaeli , Utah, Emery Co., I-70 roadside marker #150, USNM 50607; 54, S. sanrafaeli , Utah, Emery Co., San Rafael Desert, USNM 50606; 55, S. sanrafaeli , Utah, Emery Co., San Rafael Desert, USNM 50605; 56, S. volupia , Colorado, Jefferson Co., Turkey Creek Canyon, USNM 49473; 57, S. fulleri , Florida, Levy Co., Williston, USNM 47050; 58, S. biforma , Texas, San Patricio Co., Sinton Welder Wildlife Foundation, USNM 49590. FIGURES 59–66. Female genitalia. 59, Schinia miniana , Texas, Presidio Co., Shafter, USNM 50619; 60, S. volupia , New Mexico, southern, USNM 50616; 61, S. volupia , Texas, Brazos Co., College Station, USNM 50618; 62, S. volupia , Texas, Montague Co., USNM 50617; 63, S. volupia , Colorado, Denver, USNM 50614; 64, S. sanrafaeli , Utah, Emery Co., I-70 roadside marker #150, USNM 136447; 65, S. fulleri , Florida, Highlands Co., Archbold Biological Station, USNM 47051; 66, S. biforma , Texas, San Patricio Co., Sinton Welder Wildlife Foundation, USNM 49590. Material examined. All specimens are from USNM collection except as noted. ( 198 ♂ , 127 ♀). U.S.A. : COLORADO: BOULDER CO.: Boulder, 5500 ft ., 12 June 1961 , J.R. Stainer (CNC). DENVER CO.: Denver, ( 3 ♂ , 3 ♀) ♀ genitalia slide USNM 49474, 8 –15 July ( 2 ♂ , 1 ♀). DOUGLAS CO.: 3 mi E of Palmer Lake, County Line Rd. at Beacon Lite , 7300 ft ., 27 June 2004 ( 3 ♂ , 1 ♀), C. Harp & B. Byers (CEH); 3.5 mi E of Palmer Lake, County Line Rd. at Beacon Lite , 7300 ft ., 1 July 2004 ( 3 ♂ , 1 ♀) m genitalia slide USNM 49475, 5 July 2004 ( 1 ♂ , 1 ♀) ♀ genitalia slide USNM 49476, 6 July 2004 (1 ♀), on Gaillardia aristata , C. Harp (USNM, CEH). FREMONT CO.: Canon City, 10 Aug. 1973 (1 ♀), G.F. Hevel. LARIMER CO.: Ft. Collins, (1 ♀). JEFFERSON CO.: Chimney Gulch, ( 4 ♂ , 2 ♀), 24–30 June ( 1 ♂ , 5 ♀) ♀ genitalia slide USNM 50614; Chimney Gulch, 17 June 1927 , C.L. (CNC); Golden, ( 1 ♂ , 3 ♀); Morrison, June ( 2 ♂ , 1 ♀); Turkey Creek Canyon, June ( 4 ♂ , 5 ♀) ♂ genitalia slide USNM 49473, ♀ genitalia slide USNM 50615. KANSAS: CLARK CO.: No specific locality, May 1962 ( 1 ♂ ), June 1962 ( 1 ♂ , 2 ♀), F.H. Snow. MORTON CO.: Cimarron National Grasslands, 7.5 mi N Elkhart, 26 Aug. 2000 ( 1 ♂ ), D.J. Wright (DJW). SEWARD CO.: 13 mi NE Liberal, 2700 ft ., 26 Aug. 1975 , Lafontaine & Bowen (CNC). TREGO CO.: Cedar Bluff Dam, 28 July 1999 ( 1 ♂ ), E.H. Metzler (EHM); Cedar Bluff State Park, T14S, R22W, Sec. 23 & 26, short grass prairie, 14 June 1987 ( 6 ♂ , 2 ♀), E.H. Metzler (EHM); Cedar Bluff Wildlife Area, yucca dominated prairie, CBSY, 28 July 1999 ( 2 ♂ ), E.H. Metzler (EHM). LOUISIANA: CAMERON PARISH: Johnson’s Bayou, T15S, R13W, Sec. 18, 8 Aug. 1985 ( 1 ♂ ), 12 Aug. 1985 ( 6 ♂ , 4 ♀), 10 Sep. 1985 ( 3 ♂ , 1 ♀), 14 Sep. 1985 ( 8 ♂ , 1 ♀), 19 Sep. 1985 ( 4 ♂ , 1 ♀), V.A. Brou (VAB). NATCHITOCHES PARISH: Kisatchie National Forest, W. of Gorum, 16 Aug. 1996 ( 1 ♂ , 1 ♀), V.A. Brou (VAB); Red Dirt National Wildlife Refuge, Kisatchie National Forest, 22 Aug. 1997 ( 4 ♂ ), 24 Aug. 1995 ( 10 ♂ ), 29 Aug. 1989 ( 1 ♂ , 2 ♀), 5 Sep. 1999 ( 2 ♂ ), 6 Sep. 1999 ( 2 ♂ ), V.A. Brou (VAB). NEW MEXICO : southern [no specific locality], 1–10 Sep. (1 ♀) genitalia slide USNM 50616, O. Polling. GRANT CO.: Mangas Springs, 4850 ft ., 13 Aug. 1991 (1 ♀), C.D. Ferris (CSU). QUAY CO.: Tucumcari, 26 May 1924 ( 1 ♂ ), J.R. Horton. TORRANCE CO.: 6 mi N Gran Quivira National Monument along Hwy. 55, E shoulder, 8 Aug. 2002 ( 3 ♂ , 1 ♀) ♂ genitalia slides USNM 50602, 50603, ♀ genitalia slide USNM 50604, C. Harp (CEH). OKLAHOMA: CADDO CO.: Red Rock Canyon State Park, 8 July 1987 ( 2 ♂ , 1 ♀), E.H. Metzler (EHM), 30–31 May 1979 (2 ♀), R.J. McGinley. MARSHALL CO.: University of Oklahoma Biological Station, Willis, 14 July 1952 (1 ♀), D.R. Davis. MURRAY CO.: Arbuckle Mountains, 1 km W Turner Falls, 19–30 July 1984 ( 4 ♂ ), D. & M. Davis. TEXAS: ANGELINA CO.: Zavalla, 27 Apr. 1960 ( 1 ♂ ), F.C. Pratt. ARANSAS CO.: Goose Island State Park, north of Aransas Pass, 18 June 1966 ( 1 ♂ ), J.R. Heitzman. BASTROP CO.: Bastrop State Park, 27 June 1963 (1 ♀), 30 June 1964 ( 1 ♂ , 1 ♀) ♀ genitalia slide USNM 49472, A. & M.E. Blanchard. BEXAR CO.: San Antonio, 15 May 1906 (1 ♀), F.C. Pratt. BLANCO CO.: Blanco State Park, 12 June 1963 ( 1 ♂ , 1 ♀), A. & M.E. Blanchard; Round Mt., ( 1 ♂ ). BRAZOS CO.: College Station, 20 May ( 2 ♂ ), 1 June ( 1 ♂ ), 14 June (3 ♀), 20 June ( 3 ♂ , 2 ♀), 23 June ( 1 ♂ , 3 ♀), P.O. Glick; College Station, 18 June 1979 , 13 Aug. 1979 , R.S. Peigler (CNC). BURNET CO.: Shovel Mountain, ( 3 ♂ , 2 ♀), 16–23 Apr. ( 1 ♂ , 1 ♀), 24–30 Apr. (1 ♀), 8–16 May ( 1 ♂ ), 1– 7 July ( 1 ♂ ) genitalia slide USNM 49471. CAMERON CO.: Brownsville, 1 Apr. 1929 (1 ♀), 11 June ( 1m ), 23 June 1895 ( 1 ♂ , 1 ♀); San Benito, 8–15 May (1 ♀). COTTLE CO.: Paducah, 9 July 1967 ( 1 ♂ ), A. & M.E. Blanchard. DALLAS CO.: Dallas, 21 May 1938 ( 1 ♂ ). GALVESTON CO.: Galveston, May (1 ♀), F.E. Snow. HARRIS CO.: Houston, 3 June 1960 ( 1 ♂ ), 28 July 1960 (1 ♀), A. & M.E. Blanchard. HEMPHILL CO.: 6 mi E Canadian, 2000 ft ., 8 Aug. 1975 , Lafontaine & Bowen (CNC). JIM WELLS CO.: Sandia, 7 Apr. 1981 , 19 June 1981 , D. & V. Hardwick (CNC). KENEDY CO.: Padre Island National Seashore, 24 Sep. 1979 ( 1 ♂ ), A. & M.E. Blanchard. KERR CO.: Kerrville, ( 5 ♂ , 1 ♀), Apr. (1 ♀), 31 May 1906 ( 1 ♂ ), F.C. Pratt. KLEBERG CO.: Kingsville, ( 2 ♂ ). LA SALLE CO.: Artesia Wells, 12 June 1972 ( 1 ♂ ), A. & M.E. Blanchard, 11 June 1972 ( 23 ♂ , 4 ♀), 12 June 1972 ( 12 ♂ , 1 ♀), 13 June 1972 ( 4 ♂ , 6 ♀), 20 June 1972 ( 6 ♂ , 17 ♀), 21 June 1972 ( 10 ♂ , 15 ♀), D.C. Ferguson; Cotulla, 15 Apr. 1906 ( 1 ♂ ). LLANO CO.: Llano, 23 May 1925 ( 2 ♂ ), genitalia slide FHB 1180. MATAGORDA CO.: Matagorda, 11 May 1963 (1 ♀), G.F. Hevel. MONTAGUE CO.: No specific locality, 28 May 1940 ( 1 ♂ ), 27 Aug. 1941 (1 ♀), 28 Aug. 1940 ( 1 ♂ ), 30 Aug. 1940 ( 3 ♂ ), 1 Sep. 1940 ( 1 ♂ ), 21 Sep. 1941 (2 ♀), 30 Sep. 1941 (1 ♀) genitalia slide USNM 50617; 8 mi S of Forestburg, 28 Aug. 1949 ( 1 ♂ ), 25 Aug. 1949 ( 1 ♂ ), 31 Aug. 1949 ( 1 ♂ ), 11 Sep. 1949 ( 3 ♂ , 1 ♀), 17 Sep. 1949 ( 3 ♂ ), 24 Sep. 1950 (1 ♀) genitalia slide USNM 50335. NUECES CO.: Corpus Christi, 12 Apr. 1906 ( 13 ♂ , 4 ♀), F.C. Pratt, 6 Oct. 1951 ( 1 ♂ ), O.C. Cartwright; N. Padre Island, 9 Sep. 1974 (1 ♀), A. & M.E. Blanchard; Nueces River, ( 1m ). PRESIDIO CO.: Marfa, Davis Mountains, 11 Sep. 1960 ( 1 ♂ ). SAN PATRICIO CO.: Sinton, Welder Wildlife Refuge, 5 Apr. 1972 (1 ♀), 22 Apr. 1964 ( 1 ♂ , 1 ♀), 17 May 1977 ( 1 ♂ ), 7 Oct. 1963 ( 1 ♂ , 3 ♀), A. & M.E. Blanchard; Sinton, Welder Wildlife Refuge, 25 Sep. 1984 , 15 Oct. 1987 , D.F. Hardwick (CNC). UVALDE CO.: Sabinal, 26 May 1910 ( 1 ♂ ), May 1910 ( 1 ♂ ), F.C. Pratt; Utopia, 9–15 May 1989 ( 1 ♂ ), D.E. Gaskin; Concan, Neils Lodges, 1300 ft ., 17 Apr. 1990 , 29 Apr. 1990 , N. McFarland (CNC). ZAPATA CO.: Zapata, 12 Apr. 1964 ( 1 ♂ ), A. & M.E. Blanchard. UTAH: SALT LAKE CO.: Alta Ski Area, 4 July 1976 (1 ♀), D.A. Currutt (EHM). WYOMING: ALBANY CO.: no specific locality, 8310 ft . 1 July 2002 , 8200 ft ., 7 July 2002 , C.D. Ferris (CNC). LARAMIE CO.: Curt Gowdy State Park, 6 July 1993 , B. Landry (CNC). Larval host plants. Larvae of S. volupia feed on four species of Gaillardia (Asteraceae) throughout its range. Gaillardia aestivalis (Walter) H. Rock , lanceleaf blanketflower; G. pinnatifida Torr. , red dome blanketflower; G. pulchella Foug., Indian blanket; G. aristata Pursh , blanketflower. Biology. Hardwick (1996) gave a detailed description of the life history and larva of S. volupia . The first and second instars feed within the florets. Late second and third instars feed on the developing achenes and the corolla tubes. Third instars web together a feeding nest within the head. Fourth and fifth instars migrate to new heads and tie down the rays across the disc florets presumably to form a feeding shelter. Larva matured in five instars, with a single specimen requiring six instars. Flight period. Specimens in Texas have been collected from April through September with peak abundance in June. In other parts of its range specimens in Kansas were collected in May and June, July in Oklahoma, and August in Colorado and New Mexico . Distribution ( Fig. 109 ). The front range of Colorado from Larimer, Douglas, and Fremont counties south to central and eastern New Mexico , east to western Kansas, south to southern Oklahoma, Texas, and Louisiana. FIGURES 67–72. Gaillardia pulchella host of S. volupia . 67, flowerheads, image by Max Licher, Arizona State University Herbarium; 68, Field of G. pulchella , image by Lars Paul Linden, www.mudia.com. 69, S. volupia , ♂, Texas, Johnson Co., Cleburne State Park, USNMENT 00147634; 70, S. volupia , ♂, Louisiana, Natchitoches Parrish, Kisatchie National Forest, USNMENT 00155018; 71, S. volupia , ♂, Louisiana, Cameron Parrish, Johnson’s Bayou, USNMENT 00155000; 72, S. volupia , ♀, Texas, San Patricio Co., Sinton, Welder Wildlife Refuge, USNM 0 0 147632. FIGURES 73–76. Gaillardia aestivalis probable host of S. volupia . 73, field of G. aestivalis , image by Ted Bodner @ USDA- NRCS PLANTS Database (Miller and Miller, 2005); 74, bloom; 75, S. volupia , ♂, Texas, La Salle Co., Artesia Wells, USNMENT 00148804; 76, S. volupia , ♂, Oklahoma, Murray Co., 1 km W Turner Falls, Arbuckle Mts. Discussion. As pointed out in the diagnosis both the forewing ground color and form of the antemedial and postmedial lines and ground color of the hind wing are extremely variable. This variation occurs at a single locality ( 8 mi S of Forestburg, Montague Co.:, Texas; Red Dirt National Wildlife Refuge, Natchitoches Parrish, Louisiana) where the forewing ground color ranges from pink to maroon. Byers (1989) provides some insight into the possible hybridization of S. volupia and S. masoni . An area between Denver and Colorado Springs called the Palmer Divide, which separates the Platte River watershed to the north from the Arkansas watershed to the south, may be a hybrid zone between S. volupia and S. masoni . Byers collected specimens from this area and noted that the paler pink S. volupia forms had gray scales mixed with the pink scales on the hind wings. Recent collections from this area confirm this observation of both dark pink and maroon adults having a gray hind wing mixed with pink scales. In the more northern areas of the range of S. volupia ( masoni ) in Jefferson and Larimer Counties the hind wings are pure gray. Byers stated that if these intermediate forms are hybrids then they should be treated as subspecies instead of full species. With our knowledge of S. volupia being an extremely variable species we interpret that S. masoni is a dark form of S. volupia and the hybrid specimens seen in the vicinity of Palmer Divide and Palmer Lake are actually hybrids between S. miniana and S. volupia ( Figs. 19–21 ). In these specimens the basal area, reniform spot, and subterminal area are dark pink, and the median and terminal areas are ochreous as in S. miniana . The hind wing of these specimens is gray with a few pink scales along posterior margin and anal area. Schinia miniana can have either a pinkish-gray or gray hind wing. FIGURES 77–82. Gaillardia aristata host of S. volupia . 77, S. volupia on flowerhead of G. aristata ; 78, predominantly pink flowerhead of G. aristata ; 79, flowerhead of G. aristata , photo by Steve O’Kane, used with permission; 80, field of G. aristata ; 81, S. volupia ( S. masoni , holotype), ♀, Colorado, Denver; 82, S. volupia , ♀, Colorado, Jefferson Co., Chimney Gulch, USNMENT 0 0 148807. Schinia sanrafaeli Opler ( Figs. 11 , 41–43 , 53–55 , 64 , 85–86 , 110 ) Schinia sanrafaeli Opler, 2004:45 . Schinia sanrafaeli : Lafontaine and Schmidt 2010:69 . Diagnosis/ Description. Schinia sanrafaeli is variable and some specimens can be confused with S. volupia or S. minana (Grote) . Forewing basal area pink; a wide, white antemedial line contiguous with pink basal area; ochreous median area; postmedial line wide, white, sinuous and somewhat jagged; subterminal area pink; terminal area and fringe ochreous. Hind wing is pink with gray scales along costa. The amount of gray scales on the hind wing is variable and can cover as much as half of the hind wing. FIGURES 83–86. Gaillardia spathulata host of S. sanrafaeli . 83, flowerhead, photo by Bert Nelson, used with permission; 84, plants, photo by Bert Nelson, used with permission; 85, S. sanrafaeli , ♂, Utah, Emery Co., San Rafael Desert, Goblin Valley Rd. @ Hwy. #24, SE of parking area, USNMENT 00148047; 86, S. sanrafaeli , ♀, Utah, Emery Co., San Rafael Desert, Goblin Valley Rd. @ Hwy. #24, SE of parking area, USNMENT 0 0 148146. In the female genitalia the accessory bursae has 2 coils that are tightly coiled (short) and robust. Schinia volupia , S. fulleri , S. miniana , and S. biforma all have 3 coils that are loosely coiled (elongate) and narrow. Type material. HOLOTYPE ♂, Utah, Emery Co.:, Goblin Valley St. Pk., 1 Jun 1997 , P.A. Opler and E. Buckner, u. v. light (J.D. Lafontaine genitalia slide #11881). Deposited in the CNC. Material examined. All specimens are from the USNM except as noted. ( 5 ♂ , 3 ♀). COLORADO: MESA CO.: Grand Junction (USTC). UTAH: EMERY CO.: I-70 roadside marker 150, 1 mi E of Hwy. 24 jct., 4446 ft ., 20 May 2001 ( 1 ♂ , 2 ♀), ♂ genitalia slide USNM 50607, C. Harp; San Rafael Desert, Goblin Valley Road at Hwy. 24, SE of parking area, 4980 ft ., 24 May 2005 ( 1 ♂ ), genitalia slide USNM 50605, C. Harp; San Rafael Desert, Goblin Valley Road at Hwy. 24, S end of parking area, 4920 ft ., 24 May 2005 ( 2 ♂ ), genitalia slide USNM 50606, C. Harp. GARFIELD CO.: Capitol Reef National Par, Pickaboo Ranger Station, 2 June 1994 , P.A. Opler (CNC). GRAND CO.: 0.75 mi SE of Cisco, south of I-70 , on Gaillardia , 4360 ft ., 16-17 May 2007 ( 1 ♂ ), C. Harp. SAN JUAN CO.: Canyonlands National Park, Squaw Flats, 4 June 1994 , P.A. Opler (CNC). WAYNE CO.: San Rafael Desert, 6 mi N Hanksville, off Hwy. 24 at rock tower, on Gaillardia sphathulata , 4623 ft ., 14-15 May 2010 (1 ♀), genitalia slide USNM 136447, N. Gibson & C. Harp. Larval host plant. Schinia sanrafaeli has been reared on western blanketflower; G. spathulata A. Gray (Asteraceae) . The larval host plant has a limited distribution in eastern Utah and western Colorado that corresponds to the distribution of the moth. Flight period. Late May to early June. Distribution ( Fig. 110 ). Known only from desert areas of eastern Utah and near Grand Junction, Mesa Co., Colorado. Discussion. In the original description of S. sanrafaeli Opler (2004) mentions that S. volupia , S. sanrafaeli , and S. fulleri all have 4 coils in the vesica and S. masoni has 3 1/2 coils, although he did not illustrate the male genitalia. As interpreted here, there are only 3 coils in all species of the S. volupia species complex. As defined here, S. sanrafaeli only occurs in eastern Utah and western Colorado. The specimens cited in the original description from Grant Co., New Mexico are specimens of S. volupia . There are two haplotypes of S. sanrafaeli , H2 and H11 (Table 2, Fig. 4 ). Haploptype H11 from Grand Co., Utah is unique in this study and did not associate with the other two specimens of S. sanrafaeli from the type locality, Emery Co., Utah with haploptype H2 ( Figs. 1–4 ). Haplotype H2 was shared with three specimens of S. miniana from Clark Co., Nevada and Cochise Co., Arizona and formed Clade IV in Figs. 1–4 . This sharing of haplotype H2 with S. miniana suggests that there is gene flow between populations of S. sanrafaeli from Emery Co., Utah and of S. miniana from Nevada and Arizona. Schinia fulleri ( McElvare) ( Figs. 29–30 , 45 , 57 , 65 , 89–90 , 109 ) Diagnosis/ Description. Schinia fulleri has a pale ochreous head and thorax and similar antemedial and postmedial lines to S. volupia . The forewing ground color is quite variable with some specimens a dark reddish-brown in median and subterminal areas and ochreous in basal and terminal areas. In other specimens median and subterminal areas are barely darker than the surrounding ochreous and could be considered a solid color with very faint traces of a postmedial line. The hind wing is varies from dark reddish-brown to ochreous slightly darker than the forewing.

Rhododipsa fulleri McElvare, 1961:6 .
Schinia fulleri: Franclemont and Todd	1983:158.—Poole	1989:894.—Poole	and	Gentili	1996:771.—Hardwick	1996:155.—
Lafontaine and Schmidt 2010:69.

Type material. HOLOTYPE ♂, Florida, Highlands Co.:, Archbold Biological Station, 22 Oct. 1960 , Leg: Roger W. Pease, Jr. Deposited in USNM. Material examined. All specimens are from USNM except as noted. ( 13 ♂ , 9 ♀). FLORIDA: ALACHUA CO.: Gainesville, 26 Sep. 1987 , 30 Sep. 1987 , H.D. Baggett (CNC). CITRUS CO.: Withlacoochee State Forest, Rd. M-11, 28 Sep. 1986, H.D. Baggett (CNC). HERNANDO CO.: U.S. 41 N Brooksville, Withlacoochee State Forest, 18 Sep. 1982 , H.D. Baggett (CNC). HIGHLANDS CO.: Archbold Biological Station, 9 Oct. 1960 ( 2 ♂ ) genitalia slides USNM 47051, 47054, 24 Oct. 1960 ( 1 ♂ ) genitalia slide USNM 47056, R.W. Pease, 13 Oct. 1961 ( 2 ♂ , 1 ♀), 14 Oct. 1961 ( 1 ♂ , 4 ♀), R.R. McElvare, 30 Oct. 1960 (1 ♀) genitalia slide USNM 47053, ( 1 ♂ ), L.C. Koen; Archbold Biological Station, 20 Sep. 1978 , H.V. Weems, Jr. & S. Halkin (CNC); Archbold Biological Station, Lake Placid, 19 Oct. 1979 , 20 Oct. 1979 , D. & V. Hardwick (CNC); Highlands Hammock State Park, 11 Oct. 1986 , H.D. Baggett (CNC); Lake Placid, 3 Nov. 1960 ( 1 ♂ ) genitalia slide USNM 47055, R.R. McElvare; Lake Placid, 18 Oct. 1979 , 26 Oct. 1979 D. & V. Hardwick (CNC); 2 mi E of Lake Placid, 4 Nov. 1960 (1 ♀), R.R. McElvare. HILLSBOROUGH CO.: University of Florida Ecological Preserve, 21 Sep. 1984 ( 1 ♂ ), 16 Oct. 1983 (1 ♀), H.D. Baggett; Tampa, 20 Sep. 1984 , H.D. Baggett (CNC). LEVY CO.: Williston, 3 Oct. 1983 ( 1 ♂ ) genitalia slide USNM 47050; 13 mi SW of Williston, 18 Sep. 1982 ( 2 ♂ ), H.D. Baggett. LIBERTY CO.: Torreya State Park, 1 Oct. 1983 , S. Roman (CNC). PINELLAS CO.: St. Petersburg, 24 Sep. 1914 ( 1 ♂ ), R. Ludwig, Oct. (1 ♀). WALTON CO.: vic. Campbell Lake, 4 Oct. 1981 , H.D. Baggett. Larval host plant. Coastal plain honeycombhead, Balduina angustifolia (Pursh) B.L. Rob. (Asteraceae) . Biology. Hardwick (1996) details the life history of S. fulleri . The first instar larva bores into a corolla tube and feeds on its contents. In the remaining instars the larva feed on the seeds. In the third and subsequent instars the larva forms a “feeding nest” presumably to hide in during feeding. Larvae complete development in six instars with one specimen only taking five. Flight period. Late September to early November. Distribution ( Fig. 109 ). Known only from Florida, in the west from Levy and Hillsborough Counties and from Highlands County in central Florida. Discussion. Schinia fulleri is a disjunct population of the S. volupia complex. It has a distinctive white broken pattern of the antemedial and postmedial lines that are similar in S. volupia . This species has a restricted distribution in Florida and southern Georgia although its host plant is found almost throughout the entire state and into southeastern Georgia and extreme southeastern Alabama and Mississippi (USDA, NRCS 2008).