The significance of Buffon and Guéneau de Montbeillard’s Histoire naturelle des oiseaux ([1765] - 1783) in the taxonomy of birds: General presentation and correspondence between Buffon’s “ eagles ” and the species acknowledged by Linnaeus (1758, 1766), Brisson (1759 - 1762), and Gmelin (1788 - 1789)
Author
Schmitt, Stéphane
Archives Henri Poincaré, UMR 7117 CNRS - Université de Lorraine - Université de Strasbourg, 91 avenue de la Libération, BP 454, F- 54001 Nancy Cedex (France) stephane _ schmitt @ yahoo. fr
schmitt@yahoo.fr
Author
Gouraud, Christophe
ornithocoll@gmail.com
text
Zoosystema
2024
2024-07-04
46
16
361
409
https://sciencepress.mnhn.fr/sites/default/files/articles/pdf/zoosystema2024v46a16.pdf
journal article
299646
10.5252/zoosystema2024v46a16
0e4e840e-6fab-406b-b1af-eb73a7499182
1638-9387
12667134
1B22F210-FDA8-4F91-BFEE-10A8823E2A5D
12. Buffon’s variety of the “Jean-le-blanc”
12.1.
Linnaeus (1758)
:
not considered.
12.2.
Brisson (1759a: 367-370
,
1763a: 107
): “
LANIER
BLANC
”, “
LANARIUS
ALBICANS
”
, species 18 of genus VIII (“Épervier”, “
Accipiter
”), order III, section 1.
OBSERVATION
. — No direct observation. Description borrowed from Aldrovandi.
REFERENCES
. —
Aldrovandi (1599: 380-382)
, “
Lanarius
”, direct observation and various sources;
Schwenckfeld (1603: 304)
, “
Milvus albus
”, based on Turner and Aldrovandi;
Jonston (1657: 12
, pl. IX), “
Lanarius
”, based on Aldrovandi;
Sibbald (1684: 15)
, “
Milvus albicans. An Lanius albicans
?
” (in a list of Scottish birds)
;
Rzączyński (1745: 395)
, “
Milvus albus
”, based on Aldrovandi and Schwenckfeld.
MODERN
IDENTIFICATION
. — Doubtful species. Aldrovandi mentioned two “
Lanarii
” and considered them two varieties of the same species: the first one (total length: about
50 cm
) was probably a harrier; the second one, bigger (total length: about
70 cm
), is not identifiable with certainty (the grey, white, and brown color, as well as the longitudinal rusty spots of the belly and beneath the wings evoke a juvenile male harrier too; however, it is not in accordance with the size). Furthermore, these two birds may have been confused, in the other mentioned sources, with other unidentifiable birds of prey.
12.3.
Linnaeus (1766)
:
not considered.
12.4. Buffon
in
Buffon & Guéneau de Montbeillard (1771a: 134- 135)
, quarto edition; (1771b: 105), folio edition:
Variety of the “Jean-le-blanc” (see above, 11.4).
OBSERVATION
. — No direct observation. Short description borrowed from Brisson.
REFERENCES
. —
Aldrovandi (1599: 380-382)
;
Schwenckfeld (1603: 304)
;
Brisson (1759a: 367)
.
MODERN
IDENTIFICATION
. — See Brisson. The identification of the second “
Lanarius
” of Aldrovandi with Buffon’s “Jean-le-Blanc” (i.e., *
Circaetus gallicus
) is very improbable.
12.5.
Gmelin (1788: 276)
: “
FALCO
ALBICANS
”
G42, S102, order “
Accipitres
”. Includes a variety β.
REFERENCES
. —
Brisson (1763a: 107)
;
Aldrovandi (1599: 380-
383);
Latham (1781: 87
no. 73),
“White Lanner”; based on Brisson and Aldrovandi.
REMARK
. — Gmelin distinguishes between the two “
Lanarii
” of Aldrovandi; he considers one of them the main species, and the other the variety β; he wonders whether the species itself, “
Falco albicans
”, may be a mere variety of “
Falco
Lanarius
” (G42, S24), i.e., Buffon’s “Lanier” (among “falcons” and related species).
DISTRIBUTION
. — Europe.
MODERN
IDENTIFICATION
. — See Brisson.
MODERN
NOMENCLATURE
. —
Falco albicans
J. F. Gmelin, 1788
, is a
nomen dubium
.