On Bulgarian sawflies, including a new species of Empria (Hymenoptera, Symphyta)
Author
Liston, Andrew
Senckenberg Deutsches Entomologisches Institut, Eberswalder Str. 90, 15374 Muencheberg, Germany
andrew.liston@senckenberg.de
Author
Prous, Marko
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5329-7608
Senckenberg Deutsches Entomologisches Institut, Eberswalder Str. 90, 15374 Muencheberg, Germany & Department of Zoology, Institute of Ecology and Earth Sciences, University of Tartu, Vanemuise 46, 51014 Tartu, Estonia
Author
Macek, Jan
Department of Entomology, National Museum, Cirkusova 1740, 193 00 Praha - Horni Pocernice, Czech Republic
text
Deutsche Entomologische Zeitschrift
2019
2019-06-14
66
1
85
105
http://dx.doi.org/10.3897/dez.66.34309
journal article
http://dx.doi.org/10.3897/dez.66.34309
1860-1324-1-85
6A252079088045A2A9203C0DFEAC79C5
1AA06BAF62AD5064839E99F7B0A713A9
3252231
Empria parvula (Konow, 1892) *
Poecilosoma parvula
Konow, 1892: 215. Lectotype ♂ GBIF-GISHym3784 (SDEI), here designated. Type locality:
Fuerstenberg
in Mecklenburg, Germany, Brandenburg.
Empria pseudoklugi
[
pseudo-klugi
sic!] Dovnar-Zapolskij, 1929: 39. Lectotype ♀ ZIN_Empria_8 (ZIN), here designated. Type locality: Sarepta, Volgograd Oblast, Russia.
Bulgarian material.
Varna
:
1♂
(DEI-GISHym88775),
Tsonevo
5 km
S,
100 m
,
42.982N
,
27.451E
,
06.04.2018
.
1♀
, locality as previous,
08.04.2018
.
1♀
(DEI-GISHym88802),
Staro Oryahovo
2 km
SW,
120 m
,
42.976N
,
27.787E
,
08.04.2018
.
1♂
, locality as previous,
09.04.2018
.
1♀
,
1♂
,
Goren Chiflik
1 km
SW,
40 m
,
43.001N
,
27.621E
,
13.04.2018
.
Empria parvula
has an extensive distribution in Europe (
Taeger et al. 2006
) and the Palaearctic (
Sundukov 2017
;
Taeger et al. 2018
). According to morphological characters and genetic data, the species is very closely related to
E. pravei
. The only clear difference between them is the colouration of the legs in the adults. Legs in
E. parvula
are usually mostly black with small pale areas, but occasionally the hind tibia can be basally 2/3 whitish or yellowish. Nevertheless, the metafemur appears to be always completely or nearly completely black in
E. parvula
(Fig.
32
). In
E. pravei
, femora are apically and tibiae basally extensively yellowish (Fig.
33
). There could be differences also in penis valves, but because of the variation within
E. parvula
, the differences are not always clear (Figs
24-27
). The valviceps seems to usually expand basally less in
E. parvula
than in
E. pravei
(Figs
24-27
). Host plants and at least colouration of larvae are not different between
E. parvula
and
E. pravei
(Figs
34
,
35
). Based on the sequence data of three genes that we currently have,
E. parvula
does not form a monophyletic group, particularly because an
E. parvula
specimen sampled from
Bulgaria
is closer to
E. pravei
than to other
E. parvula
specimens (from
Estonia
,
Greece
, and Russian Far East) (Figs
16
,
36
). Ignoring morphological evidence, our genetic data could be interpreted as indicating either that
E. pravei
is a synonym of
E. parvula
, or that
E. parvula
consists of more than one species. Because in
Bulgaria
we found
E. pravei
and
E. parvula
in the same places at the same time and never observed overlap with regard to leg colouration, we consider
E. pravei
to be a distinct species. Although the existence of more than one species under the name
E. parvula
cannot be excluded, the data is also consistent with a single species exhibiting large genetic variation, perhaps connected with the significantly larger population size in
E. parvula
(distributed throughout the Palaearctic) compared to
E. pravei
(possibly restricted to areas not far from the Black Sea and
south
of the Caspian Sea). In other words, non-monophyly of
E. parvula
could be because of incomplete lineage sorting (maintaining of ancestral polymorphisms) due to large population size (e.g.
Degnan and Rosenberg 2009
). More specimens and genes of both species should be sequenced or mating experiments done to decide more reliably about species boundaries in this case.
Figures 24-29.
Penis valves of
Empria
.
24
Empria parvula
TUZ615399 (
Estonia
)
25
E. parvula
DEI-GISHym88775 (
Bulgaria
)
26
E. pravei
DEI-GISHym88735 (
Bulgaria
)
27
E. pravei
DEI-GISHym88758 (
Bulgaria
)
28
E. sexpunctata
DEI-GISHym88818 (
Bulgaria
)
29
E. aridicola
paratype
DEI-GISHym80304 (
Greece
).
Figures 30-35.
Empria
species.
30
Empria sexpunctata
DEI-GISHym88916, body dorsal;
31
head dorsal.
32
E. parvula
DEI-GISHym88913, ventrolateral
33
E. pravei
DEI-GISHym88735, ventrolateral.
34
E. parvula
larva TUZ615249 (
Estonia
)
35
E. pravei
larva, reared
ex ovo
from DEI-GISHym84166 (
Bulgaria
).