Three new species of Canthonella Chapin from Hispaniola, with new records and Nomenclatural changes for West Indian dung beetles (Coleoptera: Scarabaeidae: Scarabaeinae)
Author
Ivie, Michael A.
Author
Philips, Keith
text
Zootaxa
2008
1701
1
14
journal article
10.5281/zenodo.180818
850fc9b3-67a6-4ced-b77b-3cc2bebe8857
1175-5326
180818
Digitonthophagus gazella
(Fabricius, 1787)
This African native (sometimes known as
Onthophagus gazella
) has been widely introduced to the
US
mainland in an attempt to control dung flies and helminth parasites, and improve dung incorporation (
Fincher
et al.
1983
). Since that time, it has proven to be highly mobile and invasive. From initial releases in Texas in 1972, this species has become established from Florida,
Georgia
, and Missouri to California (
Fincher
et al.
1983
,
Vulinec & Eudy 1993
,
MacRae & Pen 2001
), and has invaded
Mexico
,
Guatemala
and
Nicaragua
, as well as the western Caribbean island of San Andrés (
Rivera-Cervantes & Garcia-Real 1991
, Montes de
Oca 2001
,
Noriega & Jorge 2002
). It is also present in South
America
, where it was introduced in the 1980s (
Aidar
et al.
2000
).
The documentation of this species in the West Indies is very weak.
Chalumeau (1983)
did not record this species from the French Antilles, but in the only published record from the West Indies it had reached the Windward
Island
of
Martinique
by 1992 (
Huchet 1992
). We have discovered that this species is present on several islands of the Greater Antilles (
Jamaica
, Hispaniola,
Puerto Rico
, and St. Croix), as well as the Leeward Islands of
St. Kitts
,
Montserrat
, and
Guadeloupe
. Although it was not recorded from
Grenada
by
Woodruff
et al.
(1998)
, it is probably now widely distributed on islands with cattle..
The earliest West Indian populations of
D. gazella
known to us were discovered in
the Dominican
Republic at
4 km
W. Oviedo,
28 November 1990
-
04 February 1991
, in flight intercept traps placed in arid thorn forest by L. Manser and S. Peck (CMNC). Later that year, it was taken on the north coast of
Jamaica
at St. Ann's,
2 mi
. E. Discovery Bay, Runaway Caves,
25 March-01 April 1991
by T. K. Philips and L. Gerofsky (TKPC). The next year, specimens were collected in widely distributed areas of
the Dominican
Republic, at Prov.
San Pedro
de Macoris, Estacion de Acuacultura,
13 April 1992
(MNHD), at Prov. La Altagracia, Parque Nacional del Este, Boca de Yuma on
30 April
by K. A. Guerrero and F. Del Monte (MNHD), and at Prov. Altagracia,
2 km
N. Bayahibe,
3 July 1992
(CMNH). Further early Hispaniolan records include Prov. Pedernales, Cabo Rojo to 9.5 km N of Cabo Rojo
5–42m
,
8–10 July 1993
(WIBF); Prov. Independencia, S. Lago Enriquillo,
12 July 1993
(WIBF); and Prov. San Juan,
11 km
SE Ingenio, Presa de Sabaneta, nr. shore,
19.021N
,
71.181W
,
31 August 1995
(CMNH).
By 1996,
D. gazella
had reached
Puerto Rico
and St. Croix, as documented by Cruzian records from
4 km
S. Fredriksted, at black light on
13 February 1996
, W.E. Steiner and J. M. Sweringen, and
4 km
NW Christiansted on 0
8 February 1996
(NMNH, WIBF). The earliest known Puerto Rican specimen is from Aricebo, vac. Cueva Vaca, 0
4 April 1996
collected by L. A. Barley, in dung (URPB).
The earliest Lesser Antillean specimens of
D. gazella
we have seen are from Marie-Gallant, taken in
August 1992
(FC-INRA). Five months later it was found on the neighboring island of Basse-Terre, taken at Montebello
10 JAN 1992
by Dubois (FC-INRA). Later, F. Chalumeau collected
D. gazella
on Basseterre at St. Rose, Sofaia, in
October 1996
(WIBF). On
Montserrat
it was common by
24 June
2000
in cow dung on the north end of the island, at least as far south as the Lower Belham River and Isles Bay (WIBF). In 2003, it was found in cow pats on
St. Kitts
at St. Peter Basseterre Parish, Bayfor’s, 0
2 JULY
July 2003
(WIBF). A partial specimen was found on
Anguilla
under a rotten log in a cow pasture at Low Ground on
17 May 2004
(WIBF).
Thus this species is now on at least nine West Indian islands, with more undiscovered populations probable. Because
D. gazella
has been implicated in the decline of native species in Texas (
Howden & Scholtz 1986
), this particular introduction comes as a very real threat to the native West Indian dung beetles we are just beginning to document. On Hispaniola,
Canthon violaceus
(Oliver)
and
C. signifer
Harold
were common in open areas before the arrival of
D. gazella
, but may already be reduced in numbers or extirpated from areas now occupied by
D. gazella
.
Both native species were seen by the hundreds in Prov. Pedernales in 1988 (Ivie, Philips, and Johnson expedition), as was
C. violaceus
in Prov. Independencia in 1991 (Rawlins expedition) and 1992 (Ivie and Ivie expedition). Neither species has been found in those areas in our visits subsequent to the establishment of
D. gazella
, and only once has either has been found elsewhere after
D. gazella
is present —
8 specimens
of
C. violaceus
were taken with the 1992 Bayahibe collection (CMNH). It would be a further sad comment on the decreasing richness of the world's biodiversity if these two beautiful scarabs were pushed out by another of man's weedy tag-alongs.
Jamaica
also has large endemic species that could be harmed by this introduction, most importantly the pasture-dwelling
Sulcophanaeus carnifex
(Linnaeus)
,
Pseudocanthon jamaicenesis
Matthews
, and even possibly the forest-endemic Jamaican genus
Anoplodrepanus
, including
A. reconditus
(Matthews)
and
A. pecki
(Howden)
. We have no data to indicate if impacts have occurred, but encourage others with access to such data to make them known as soon as possible.
Matthews' (1966) key to the West Indian genera does not include
Digitophophagus gazella
, but it cannot be confused with any of the West Indian species illustrated by him.
Huchet (1992)
gave diagnoses for both the genus and species.