Four new species, taxonomic, and nomenclatural notes in Hammatoderus Gemminger & Harold, 1873 (Coleoptera, Cerambycidae, Lamiinae)
Author
Botero, Juan Pablo
Author
Santos-Silva, Antonio
text
Zootaxa
2017
4231
3
377
397
journal article
36566
10.11646/zootaxa.4231.3.5
2961dd30-2ab9-46d6-8b8b-aeab1a90353e
1175-5326
290917
5A9D98E7-FBE5-419C-8EBA-2BC40ED4483D
On
Plagiohammus
Dillon & Dillon, 1941
Thomson (1856)
used for the first time the generic name
Hammoderus
to include a single species,
H. buquetii
Thomson, 1856
(type species by original monotypy). Currently,
Hammoderus buquetii
is known as
Taeniotes luciani
Thomson, 1859
(
nomen novum
to avoid homonymy with
Taeniotes buquetii
Tasté, 1841
). According to
Thomson (1859)
: “Le nom de
T.
Buquetii
ayant déjà été employé par M. Taslé (
Rev. zool.
, 1841, p. 14) pour désigner une espèce d’un genre voisin de celui-ci, j’ai substitué à cette première espèce celui de
T. Luciani
.”
Thomson (1857)
considered
Hammoderus
Thomson, 1856
as a subgenus of
Taeniotes
. According to him: “
L’Hammoderus
Buquetii
Thomson
(Ann. Soc. Ent. 3e série 1856, vol. IV, p. 329, pl. 8, fig. 1), doit rentrer dans le genre
Taeniotes
, parmi les espèces de la première division, dont les élytres sont arrondies à l’extrémité”. Thus,
Thomson (1857)
defined the subgenus
Taeniotes
(
Hammoderus
)
as having the elytral apex without spine, and included two species in this subgenus:
T.
(
H.
)
buquetii
and
T.
(
H.
)
inermis
.
Thomson (1859)
considered
Hammoderus
as a genus distinct from
Taeniotes
: “Le
Taeniotes inermis
, Thomson
(
Arch. Ent.
, I, 1857, p. 173), n’appartient probablement pas au genre actuel [
Taeniotes
], son dernier segment abdominal n’étant pas épineux; cette espèce peut être rapportée avec doute au G.
Hammoderus
, Dej.,
Cat
.
, 3e édit., p. 367.” Although he had considered
Hammoderus
as a distinct genus, it is evident that he was referring to
Hammoderus sensu
Thomson (1856)
for the inclusion of
H. buquetii
.
Thomson (1860)
formally differentiated
Hammoderus
from
Taeniotes
, attributing the first one to Dejean (1837). Four species were included,
H. inermis
(
Fig. 33
) and three others described in the same work:
H. lacordairei
(
Fig. 32
);
H. sallei
(
Fig. 34
) and
H. spinipennis
(
Fig. 25
). However, contrary to Thomson’s judgment, and according to
Bousquet & Bouchard (2013)
: “
Hammoderus
Dejean, 1835
: 341
. Originally included available species: none.” Thus,
Hammoderus
cannot be attributed to
Dejean (1835)
and the actual author of this name is
Thomson (1860)
.
Agassiz (1846)
replaced
Hammoderus
Dejean (1835)
as
Hammatoderus
. However, as seen before,
Hammoderus
is an unavailable name in
Dejean (1835)
. Consequently,
Hammatoderus
Agassiz, 1847
is also an unavailable name, because it is a replacement name for another unavailable name, without inclusion of species.
Thomson (1864)
designated the
type
species of
Hammoderus
Thomson, 1860
:
H. lacordairei
Thomson, 1860
(“
Hammoderus
Thomson. Ess.
Class. Céramb. p. 98.
Type
:
H. Lacordairei
Thomson
l. c.
Mexique
.”).
So, two distinct generic taxa were described with the same name by Thomson in
1856 and 1860
–
Hammoderus
Thomson, 1856
and
Hammoderus
Thomson, 1860
– and, thus, these names are homonyms. The type species of
Hammoderus
Thomson, 1856
, is now placed in
Taeniotes
; hence,
Hammoderus
Thomson, 1856
is a junior synonym of
Taeniotes
.
Hammoderus
Thomson, 1860
, in turn, is a junior homonym of
Hammoderus
Thomson, 1856
and, consequently, it is considered as permanently invalid by the
ICZN (1999, Articles 52.2 and 60.1)
. Thus, no taxon can be named using this name and one of its junior synonym must be used instead.
According to
Gemminger & Harold (1873)
: “
Hammatoderus
.
άΜΜα, nodus
;
δέρη, collum
. Thomson.
Classif. Longic. 1860. p. 98
. (
emend
.)
Hammoderus
Thoms.
” Seven species were included:
H. elatus
Bates, 1872
;
H. impluviatus
Lacordaire, 1869
;
H. inermis
;
H. lacordairei
;
H. rubefactus
Bates, 1872
;
H. sallei
;
H. spinipennis
.
Hammatoderus
Gemminger & Harold, 1873
is an unjustified emendation. Thus, according to the
ICZN (1999)
: “33.2.
Emendations.
Any demonstrably intentional change in the original spelling of a name other than a mandatory change is an "emendation"”; and, “33.2.3. Any other emendation is an "unjustified emendation"; the name thus emended is available and it has its own author and date and is a junior objective synonym of the name in its original spelling; it enters into homonymy and can be used as a substitute name.” Also according to the
ICZN (1999)
: “67.8.
Type species of nominal genus-group taxa denoted by new replacement names (nomina nova).
If an author publishes a new genus-group name expressly as a new replacement name (nomen novum) for a previously established name, or replaces a previously established genus-group name by an unjustified emendation [Art. 33.2.3], both the prior nominal taxon and its replacement have the same type species, and type fixation for either applies also to the other, despite any statement to the contrary.” Thus, the type species of
Hammatoderus
is the same of
Hammoderus
Thomson (1860)
:
Hammoderus lacordairei
.
Dillon & Dillon (1941)
established
Plagiohammus
as a replacement name for
Hammoderus
Thomson, 1860
: “Thomson in his description of
Hammoderus
in the second sense (1860), included
lacordairei
,
sallei
,
inermis
and
spinipennis
. Of these
spinipennis
is the form most frequently encountered, and is selected as the genotype. In his first use of the generic name
Hammoderus
, he described
buquetii
with it, which species is now in
Taeniotes
under
T. luciani
.” However, as seen above,
Hammatoderus
was an older available name to replace
Hammoderus
Thomson, 1857
. Hence,
Plagiohammus
is a junior synonymy of
Hammatoderus
. Article 23.9 (
ICZN 1999
) cannot be used to maintain
Plagiohammus
because the Article 23.9.1.2 is not applicable.
In summary:
Hammoderus
Thomson, 1856
, invalid name by being a junior subjective synonym of
Taeniotes
Audinet-Serville,
1835
Type species—
Hammoderus buquetii
, by original monotypy (=
Taeniotes luciani
Thomson, 1859
).
Hammoderus
Thomson, 1860
; senior objective synonym of
Hammatoderus
Gemminger & Harold, 1873
and
Plagiohammus
Dillon & Dillon, 1941
; and permanently invalid by being a junior homonym of
Hammoderus
Thomson, 1856
.
Type species—
Hammoderus lacordairei
Thomson, 1860
(designated by
Thomson, 1864
)
Hammatoderus
Gemminger & Harold, 1873
; valid name: replacement name for
Hammoderus
Thomson, 1860
(non
Hammoderus
Thomson, 1856
).
Type species—
Hammoderus lacordairei
Thomson, 1860
(designated by
Thomson, 1864
).
Plagiohammus
Dillon & Dillon, 1941
; proposed as an unnecessary replacement name for
Hammoderus
Thomson,
1860
Type species—
Hammoderus lacordairei
Thomson, 1860
, not
Hammatoderus spinipennis
as proposed by
Dillon & Dillon (1941)
(see article 67.8 of the
ICZN, 1999
)