Describing the hidden species diversity of Chaetozone (Annelida, Cirratulidae) in the Norwegian Sea using morphological and molecular diagnostics
Author
Grosse, Mael
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0977-1376
University of the Balearic Island, Department of Biology, Ctra. Valldemossa km 7.5, Balearic Islands, Spain & Norwegian University of Science and Technology, NTNU University Museum, Trondheim, Norway
maelgrosse@gmail.com
Author
Capa, Maria
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5063-7961
University of the Balearic Island, Department of Biology, Ctra. Valldemossa km 7.5, Balearic Islands, Spain & Norwegian University of Science and Technology, NTNU University Museum, Trondheim, Norway
Author
Bakken, Torkild
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5188-7305
Norwegian University of Science and Technology, NTNU University Museum, Trondheim, Norway
text
ZooKeys
2021
2021-05-21
1039
139
176
http://dx.doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.1039.61098
journal article
http://dx.doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.1039.61098
1313-2970-1039-139
F2F861A533DF4B61827DEB71AB97E97F
CE0AE9A0941A5036BDBBB43C3C4B2B4A
Chaetozone
sp. 2 and sp. 4
Figures 14
Chaetozone
sp. 2
Grosse et al. 2020
: fig. 4.
Chaetozone
sp. 4
Grosse et al. 2020
: fig. 4.
Material examined.
Chaetozone
sp. 2: Norwegian Sea • 1 ind.;
61.42736°N
,
7.47479°E
;
18 Nov. 2012
;
332 m
; ZMBN125800 • 1;
62.48183°N
,
4.46550°E
;
10 Mar. 2012
;
211 m
; ZMBN125823 • 1 ind.;
61.0501°N
,
5.40055°E
;
03 May 2017
;
1236 m
; ZMBN117820 • 1 ind.;
62.482°N
,
4.466°E
;
03 Oct. 2012
;
213 m
ZMBN94537 • 1 ind.;
61.11299°N
,
5.14124°E
;
22 Jul. 2012
;
354 m
; NTNU-VM74503.
Chaetozone
sp. 4: Norwegian Sea • 3 ind.;
61.42736°N
,
7.47479°E
;
18 Nov. 2012
;
332 m
; ZMBN125796-125798 • 1 ind.;
61.21307°N
,
5.03809°E
;
14 Jul. 2015
;
379 m
; ZMBN125776 • 1 ind.;
64.804°N
,
10.111°E
;
08 Oct. 2013
;
378 m
; ZMBN94483 • 1 ind.;
62.06827°N
,
5.03811°E
;
20 Jul. 2012
;
334 m
; ZMBN125781 • 2 ind.;
61.11299°N
,
5.14124°E
;
22 Jul. 2012
;
360 m
; NTNU-VM74500, 74507.
Comparative material.
Chaetozone jubata
:
Paratypes
: Faroe-Shetland channel • 2 ind.; 61.5.57°N,
2.4093°W
;
Jul. 1996
;
710 m
; NMSZ.1999.237.4-5.
Diagnosis.
Prostomium fused with peristomium, giving the head a drop-like appearance; dorsal tentacles arising from segment 1 (achaetous), first pair of branchiae arising from segment 2 (achaetous); ventral groove; long capillary chaetae on expanded anterior, numerous long, broad flat spines on high complete cinctures (Fig.
14
). No particular methylene blue staining pattern.
Figure 14.
Chaetozone
sp. 4.
A
ZMBN125798, SEM of anterior end in dorsal view
B
ZMBN125776, SEM of posterior spines
C
ZMBN125798, SEM of peristomium epidermis
D
ZMBN125798, SEM of ciliated organ
E
ZMBN125776, SEM of neuropodial spine. Abbreviations: br, branchiae; Ch, chaetiger; cO, ciliated organ; dT, dorsal tentacles; nuO, nuchal organ; per, peristomium; pr, prostomium; Seg, segment.
Molecular diagnosis.
Chaetozone
sp. 2: COI: 130: G; 173: A; 202: T; 244: C; 293: C; 295: T; 309: G; 310: C; 395: G; 434: G; 454: T; 460: G; 470: G; 471: T; 477: C; 490: C; 302-303: AC; 564-565: CG. 28S: 408: A; 415: C; 416: A; 445: A; 571: C; 454-455: AG; 460-461: TC; 691-692: AA; 704-705: TC. (based on 8 COI sequences and 4 28S sequences)
Chaetozone
sp. 4: COI: 122: T; 487: G; 574: G (based on 10 COI sequences).
Remarks.
These considerably distinct molecular lineages but morphologically identical species,
Chaetozone
sp. 2 and
Chaetozone
sp. 4, are morphologically similar to
C. monteverdii
sp. nov. It is clear from the molecular analyses that they are different species from
C. monteverdii
sp. nov. Moreover, they are distinguished from
C. monteverdii
sp. nov. by having smooth long chaetae instead of segmented long chaetae, and a ventral groove instead of a ridge. Nevertheless, while none of the specimens of these two species examined present enlarged first segments, the condition present in
Chaetozone
spp. 2 and 4 could fit within the intra-specific variation documented in
C. monteverdii
sp. nov. The prostomium and peristomium in
Chaetozone
sp. 4 may also appear more distinctly separated than in the other species (Fig.
9
).
Chaetozone
spp. 2 and 4 resemble
C. jubata
. However, they differ in the relative position of the paired tentacles and first pair of branchiae. It will be necessary to examine more specimens of each species, including of
C. jubata
, to investigate the intra-specific diversity in each group before confirming that neither
Chaetozone
sp. 2 nor
Chaetozone
sp. 4 are
C. jubata
.
The COI distance between
Chaetozone
sp. 2 and
Chaetozone
sp. 4 is 26% (Table
2
). COI distances with other species in the area generally varies between 22% and 27%, with minimum at 9% between
Chaetozone
sp. 4 and
Chaetozone quinta
sp. nov. (Table
2
).
Distribution.
Norwegian coast and shelf, offshore and in the fjords, where they occupy a wide range of depths from ~ 200 m to 1200 m depth.