Revision of Beroidae (Ctenophora) in the southern seas of Europe: systematics and distribution based on genetics and morphology
Author
Shiganova, Tamara A.
Author
Abyzova, Galina A.
text
Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society
2022
2021-08-21
194
297
322
journal article
2869
10.1093/zoolinnean/zlab021
9ad2cd5f-60d4-4c02-819f-fea89dda74f7
0024-4082
5799206
A93B7D7A-1F8E-4E59-B86D-67814E01F797
BEROE CUCUMIS
FABRICIUS, 1780
The body shape is strait or slightly oval in the oral part and oval at the aboral side, and it is more flattened in the paragastral plane than
B. pseudocucumis
(
Fig. 6C, D
). The adult length varies from
50 to 150 mm
. Its length to width ratio (l/w) ranges 1.6–2.2. This ratio is variable: we observed specimens, which were shorter and longer, wider or slenderer, but never less than for
B. pseudocucumis
.
Juvenile individuals may be narrower in the oral part of the body. Similar individuals were illustrated by
Mayer (1912)
. The meridional canals lie under eight rows of ciliary combs, which extend about three-quarters of the distance from the aboral pole towards the mouth or a bit longer, but not up to the mouth. Its meridional canals have numerous diverticulae, which may branch out in adult ctenophores, but do not anastomose with each other, and do not connect with paragastral canals. At the aboral end, two oval polar-plates (
Fig. 6A
) surround the sense organ at the oval aboral pole, and are fringed with a row of short, branched papillae. Macrociliaries have three-toothed macrociliary tips with a somewhat larger middle tooth (
Tamm & Tamm, 1993
).
Geographical distribution:
Beroe cucumis
was previously believed to be a widespread species, continuously distributed from the Arctic to the Antarctic (
Pages & Orejas, 1999
), but according to our genetic and morphological studies, and by comparison of published data, this species has a bipolar distribution, inhabiting cold polar and temperate waters, while being absent from tropical and subtropical zones.
Distribution in the Arctic: all Eurasian seas (
Sirenko, 2001
), including the Barents Sea (
Manko
et al.
, 2015
;
Bandara
et al.
, 2016
; this study), the White Sea (
Kosobokova & Pertsova, 2018
), the Kara Sea (
Dvoretsky & Dvoretsky, 2017
), the Laptev Sea (
Abramova & Tuschling, 2005
), the East-Siberian Sea and the Chukchi Sea (
Ershova
et al.
, 2015
);
Canada
Basin (
Raskoff
et al.
, 2005
;
Purcell
et al.
, 2010
).
Distribution in the Atlantic Ocean: individuals of
Beroe cucumis
were sampled from the North of
Norway
to the south-east of the North Sea and analysed genetically (this research). In the Atlantic Ocean
Beroe cucumis
individuals were sampled from the northern part of
Norway
to the south-east of the North Sea and analysed genetically (this research). Also,
B. cucumis
is known to occur in the northern and north-eastern Atlantic (
Fabricius, 1780
;
Van Soest, 1973
;
Granhag
et al.
, 2012
;
Licandro
et al.
, 2015
;
Knutsen
et al.
, 2018
), and along the eastern coasts of
Canada
and the
USA
(
Mayer, 1912
;
Harbison
et al.
, 1978
).
In the Mediterranean Sea, and the subtropical, tropical and equatorial regions of the Atlantic Ocean, it is replaced by
B. pseudocucumis
. Additional genetic studies are required to clarify the boundaries of the
B. cucumis
occurrence off the coast of South America, but presumably
B. cucumis
occurs also in the temperate and subpolar waters of the South Atlantic and Antarctic (
Siegel & Harm, 1996
;
Mianzan 1999
;
Mianzan & Guererro, 2000
;
Pakhomov
et al.
, 2000
;
Flores
et al
., 2010
,
2011
). There is evidence of
B. cucumis
occurring in the Benguela Current near
South Africa
(
Gibbons
et al.
, 1992
).
In the Pacific Ocean,
Beroe cucumis
occurs in cold waters: north-west Pacific (
Kasuya
et al.
, 2000
;
Napazakov & Chuchukalo 2011
); north-east Pacific, eastern Bering Sea (
Hoff
et al.
, 2011
); and the southeast Pacific off
Chile
(
Pages & Orejas, 1999
;
Oliveira
et al.
, 2016
). It frequently occurs in southern
Australia
(
Stiasny, 1931
;
Edgar, 1997
;
Gershwin
et al.
, 2010
) and in
New Zealand
waters (
Ralph, 1950
).
Now that we have genetic confirmation of the presence of two species with a similar morphotype (
Beroe cucumis
and
B. pseudocucumis
), it is necessary to conduct a detailed analysis of the ecology and distribution of these two species. It is possible that there are areas of overlap in their habitat and geography. According to previous records,
B. cucumis
occurs in the areas between temperate and subtropical climatic zones, like the east coast of the
USA
(
Mayer, 1912
;
Harbison
et al.
, 1978
), the west coast of the
USA
(
Wrobel & Mills, 1998
) and the Yellow and East
China
seas (
Liu, 2013
;
Yin
et al.
, 2017
;
Wang & Cheng, 2019
). However, additional ecological and genetic studies of individuals in these areas are required to clarify the species identification and distribution.
Habitat:
Cold-water boreal species, has bipolar distribution and inhabits cold polar and temperate waters, while absent in tropical and subtropical zones.