Molecular and morphological data suggest a new species of big-eared bat (Vespertilionidae: Corynorhinus) endemic to northeastern Mexico
Author
López-Cuamatzi, Issachar L.
Centro de Investigaciones Tropicales, Universidad Veracruzana, Xalapa de Enríquez, Veracruz, Mexico,
Author
Ortega, Jorge
Author
Ospina-Garcés, Sandra M.
Centro de Investigaciones Tropicales, Universidad Veracruzana, Xalapa de Enríquez, Veracruz, Mexico, & Centro de Investigación en Biodiversidad y Conservación, Universidad Autónoma del Estado de Morelos, Cuernavaca, Morelos, Mexic
Author
Zúñiga, Gerardo
Departamento de Zoología, Instituto Politécnico Nacional, Escuela Nacional de Ciencias Biológicas, Mexico City, Mexico, & @ aol. com (JO); cmacswiney @ uv. mx (MCMG)
Author
G., M. Cristina MacSwiney
text
PLoS ONE
2024
e 0296275
2024-02-21
19
2
1
35
journal article
10.1371/journal.pone.0296275
6237f2fd-84d2-4c9d-9984-e14473d561f8
1932-6203
10779341
Corynorhinus leonpaniaguae
sp. nov.
urn:lsid:zoobank.org:act:
98B459DC-ADF6-4F7A-88A7-8F5FEAC58C10
Vernacular name: León Paniagua’s Big-eared Bat, Murciélago-mula de León-Paniagua
(
Spanish
)
Synonyms.
Corynorhinus macrotis pallescens
Miller, 1897
, (Part)
Corynorhinus megalotis mexicanus
Allen, 1916
Corynorhinus rafinesquii mexicanus
Miller, 1924
, (Part)
Plecotus rafinesquii mexicanus
Dalquest, 1953
, (Part)
Plecotus mexicanus
Handley, 1959
Corynorhinus mexicanus
G. M. Allen, 1916
, (Part)
Holotype
.
Colección de Mamíferos,
Museo de Zoología Alfonso L. Herrera
(
MZFC-M
), No.
MZFC-M16326
is an
adult
female
with skin and skull dry preserved and collected on
April 18
th
, 2022
, by
Juan Cruzado
,
Silvino Hernández
and
Issachar L. López-Cuamatzi
(
Fig
12
).
Fig 12. Holotype pictures.
Coloration of the dorsal and ventral fur of the holotype (MZFC-M16326) of
Corynorhinus leonpaniaguae
sp. nov.
(A, B). Cranium, mandible (C, D, E) and lateral view of the first upper double-cuspid incisor (F) of the holotype.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0296275.g012
Type locality.
Cave El Hundido
(
25.16096
,
-100.622985
; 2072 msnm), 2.5
Km NE
from
Puerto Grande
,
Galeana
,
Nuevo León
,
Mexico
.
Etymology.
Corynorhinus leonpaniaguae
is named in honor of Dr. Livia S. León Paniagua, in recognition of her outstanding contribution to the knowledge of the systematics and natural history of Mexican mammals. In addition to being a pioneering woman in Mexican mammalogy, Livia has been a great mentor, dedicated to the training of new scientists. This species name is a noun in the genitive case formed by adding -ae to the stem of the name [
110
].
Habitat and distribution.
Corynorhinus leonpaniaguae
lives in open pine forests located on slopes and canyons of the northern Sierra Madre Oriental and mountains of the state of
Coahuila
. Records of the presence of this species occur mainly between 300 and 2000 meters above sea level (masl) in the states of
Coahuila
,
Nuevo León
, and
Tamaulipas
. It is an endemic species of
Mexico
with distribution restricted to the northeast of the country (
Fig 13
). In the localities of Galeana,
Nuevo León
, and Sierra de Zapalinamé in Arteaga,
Coahuila
, specimens were captured in sites close to forests where globose and cylindrical cacti are present. Other plant species present are
Pinus cembroides
,
Pinus
sp
,
Juniperus
sp
,
Yucca filifera
,
Y
.
linearifolia
, and
Yucca carnerosana
. The characteristics of the roosts used by this species are unknown; however, in
Coahuila
,
one specimen
was captured during the day inside an abandoned mine, and, in
Nuevo León
, a colony with pregnant females was found in a limestone, dolomite, and gypsum cave.
Fig 13. Historical records of the presence of
Corynorhinus mexicanus
and
Corynorhinus leonpaniaguae
sp. nov.
The Mexican administrative boundaries layer was downloaded from the GADM (https://gadm.org/ downloadcountryv3.html).
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0296275.g013
Description and comparison.
The specimens from
Nuevo León
present a brownish to grayish colored dorsal fur with dark bases and slightly lighter tips that appear to contrast between bands. However, this contrast is not equivalent to that observed in
Corynorhinus townsendii
(
Fig 14
). Like
C
.
mexicanus
and
C
.
rafinesquii
,
C
.
leonpaniaguae
presents a double cuspid in the first upper incisor (
Figs 12
and
14
). Its dental formula is i 2/3, c 1/1, p 2/3, and m 3/3, with a total of 36 teeth in its adult stage. The average values of cranial measurements and external measurements for females and males are reported in
Table 4
.
In external appearance, it is similar to and is almost indistinguishable from
C
.
mexicanus
specimens from the Sierra Madre Occidental (SMOC).
Corynorhinus leonpaniaguae
is distinguished from
C
.
townsendii
because the latter presents a tragus of>
13 mm
and a naked uropatagium with ten or more interfemoral grooves, while the former presents a tragus of <
13 mm
and a hairy uropatagium with nine or fewer interfemoral grooves. Moreover,
C
.
townsendii
usually has a larger forearm (
39 to 47 mm
) and cranium maximum length (
15.2 to 17.3 mm
) than
C
.
leonpaniaguae
. In external appearance,
C
.
leonpaniaguae
is also similar to
C
.
rafinesquii
; however,
C
.
leonpaniaguae
has bicolored ventral fur with brown bases and light tips, while
C
.
rafinesquii
has more contrasting fur due to the presence of hairs with black bases and white tips.
Fig 14. Comparison between
C
.
mexicanus
,
C
.
leonpaniaguae
, and
C
.
townsendii
.
Specimens shown correspond to
C
.
mexicanus
from (A) Puebla (ENCB27986), (B) Tlaxcala (ENCB4405), and (C) Durango (CRD11777);
C.
leonpaniaguae
from the cave of San Josecito, in Gral. Zaragoza, Nuevo Leon, Mexico (D- CRD11774; E- CRD11778; and F- CRD11777). Specimen of
C
.
townsendii
from Durango (G- CRD4831). Some differences in color bands on the dorsal fur are shown for
C
.
leonpaniaguae
(H),
C
.
mexicanus
(I), and
C
.
townsendii
(J). Double-cuspid on upper incisor tooth (white arrow) observed in
C
.
leonpaniaguae
(K),
C
.
mexicanus
(L), and
C
.
townsendii
(M).
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0296275.g014
Geographic variation.
With the restricted distribution and limited sample size, it was not possible to detect morphological variation associated with geography. Only two haplotypes of Cyt-
b
sequences have been detected within
Corynorhinus leonpaniaguae
.
Subspecies.
Corynorhinus leonpaniaguae
is a monotypic species.
Table 4. Morphological measurements of external structures obtained in
Corynorhinus leonpaniaguae
.
Females
|
Males
|
Mean
|
SD
|
Range
|
CV
|
Mean
|
SD
|
Range
|
CV
|
Maximum length |
14.87 |
0.34 |
14.19–15.20 |
2.28 |
15.10 |
0.31 |
14.8–15.68 |
2.05 |
Zygomatic width |
7.94 |
0.36 |
7.05–8.37 |
4.60 |
8.08 |
0.24 |
7.79–8.38 |
3.01 |
Postorbital width |
3.36 |
0.08 |
3.24–3.49 |
2.43 |
3.36 |
0.12 |
3.17–3.54 |
3.64 |
Width of the braincase |
7.73 |
0.27 |
7.33–8.07 |
3.43 |
7.72 |
0.34 |
7.35–8.38 |
4.44 |
Maxillary toothrow length |
4.74 |
0.08 |
4.67–4.94 |
1.78 |
4.69 |
0.07 |
4.60–4.80 |
1.47 |
Width between upper molars |
5.82 |
0.11 |
5.66–5.96 |
1.88 |
5.74 |
0.16 |
5.57–5.97 |
2.78 |
Total length |
91.59 |
5.73 |
84.37–102.79 |
6.25 |
90.56 |
6.00 |
82.08–101.14 |
6.62 |
Tail length |
43.37 |
6.15 |
34.95–55.75 |
14.19 |
40.12 |
3.53 |
35.20–44.91 |
8.79 |
Ear length |
28.66 |
1.24 |
27.37–30.43 |
4.33 |
28.43 |
1.39 |
27.13–31.30 |
4.89 |
Tragus length |
10.89 |
0.93 |
9.54–12 |
8.54 |
10.23 |
0.80 |
8.69–10.79 |
7.80 |
Forearm length |
41.91 |
1.48 |
38.71–43.94 |
3.54 |
40.52 |
0.99 |
39.54–42.08 |
2.44 |
Mean, standard deviation (SD), range, and coefficient of variation (CV) values are shown. Measurements are reported in millimeters (mm). |
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0296275.t004
Natural history.
There is no published information documenting the natural history of this species. Some observations made during the fieldwork of this study suggest certain aspects of the biology of
Corynorhinus leonpaniaguae
. In two expeditions conducted in
August 2021
and
April 2022
at the
type
locality of this species, several specimens of
Myotis thysanodes
,
Corynorhinus townsendii
,
Leptonycteris nivalis
,
Idionycteris phyllotis
, and
Antrozous pallidus
were captured. These specimens were captured at the entrance of the El Hundido Cave both entering and exiting the cave. This suggests that
Corynorhinus leonpaniaguae
may share its roosts with these species. Of those mentioned above,
M
.
thysanodes
and
C
.
townsendii
were the only species, apart from
Corynorhinus leonpaniaguae
, that were captured on both field trips, indicating that all three species are probably residents of the cave.
In
August 2021
,
four juvenile
male individuals were captured, indicating that weaning of these specimens had occurred in June-July, which is similar to that reported for
C
.
mexicanus
[
39
]. In
April 2022
,
twelve adult
females in an advanced state of pregnancy were captured, suggesting that births probably occur between the end of April and mid-May. All specimens captured in May and August presented a considerable number of ectoparasitic flies, presumably of the
Trichobius corynorhini
species.
The acoustic characteristics of
Corynorhinus leonpaniaguae
were obtained from ten specimens recorded using the hand-release technique and an Echo Meter Touch 2 Pro bat detector. Recordings were analyzed with the Batsound
1
software using Hanning window and 2048 of FFT size. Two sonotypes composed of modulated and harmonic pulses were observed from the recordings (
Fig 15
). The first sonotype consisted of combinations of two pulses repeated serially with a longer time interval between combinations than between the pulses in the combination. Although two-pulse combinations were predominant, three-pulse combinations were observed in some specimens. The second sonotype was characterized by the absence of pulse combinations and the presence of modulated pulses of longer duration. Details of frequency, duration, and interval are presented in
Table 5
. Differences in acoustic characteristics among the species of
Corynorhinus
are still unknown.