Chapter 7: Linnaean Plant Names and their Types (part S)
Author
Jarvis, Charlie
Department of Botany, Natural History Museum, Cromwell Road, London, UK
text
2007
Linnaean Society of London in association with the Natural History Museum
London
Order out of Chaos. Linnaean Plant Types and their Types
806
877
book chapter
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.291971
978-0-9506207-7-0
291971
Sisyrinchium bermudiana
Linnaeus
,
Species Plantarum
2
: 954. 1753
.
"Habitat
α
in Virginia,
ss
in Bermudis." RCN: 6908.
Lectotype
(Boivin in
Phytologia
42: 24. 1979):
Kalm
, Herb. Linn. No. 1064.1 (
LINN
)
.
Generitype
of
Sisyrinchium
Linnaeus.
Current name:
Sisyrinchium bermudiana
L.
(
Iridaceae
).
Note:
Sisyrinchium bermudiana
was based on a number of disparate elements and has been treated in a variety of ways. Bicknell (in
Bull. Torrey Bot. Club
23: 131. 1896) rejected the name because of its "indiscriminate use" for a number of taxa, and several authors, including Parent (in
Lejeunia
, n.s., 99: 6-13. 1980), have rejected the name (though not formally) as a
nomen ambiguum.
Others, however, have continued to use the name, though in different senses. Farwell (in
Mem. Torrey Bot. Club
17: 82-83. 1918) and Boivin (in
Phytologia
42: 24. 1979) have applied the name to the Virginian plant (also known as
S. mucronatum
Michaux
). By contrast, Hemsley (in
J. Bot.
22: 108-110. 1884) and Ward (in
Taxon
17: 270-273. 1968), who provides an extensive review of the problem, have applied it to the Bermudan plant.
There have been several attempts to resolve matters through typification.
Guedes
(in
Taxon
18: 542. 1969) designated Miller material (BM) of the Bermudan taxon as a
neotype
for
S. bermudiana
, but this is contrary to Art. 9.11 because original material is in existence. Boivin (in
Phytologia
42: 24. 1979) designated Kalm material (1064.1, LINN) of the Virginian taxon as type. More recently, Barrie & Reveal in Jarvis & al.,
Regnum Veg.
127: 89 (1993) designated as
lectotype
van Royen material (No. 904.139-289, L) belonging to the Bermudan taxon. The possibility that the Linnaean Generic List might be available for adoption under the Names in Current Use (NCU) proposals then under discussion led Barrie & Reveal to typify the name in a way that they believed best reflected current usage. However, with the defeat of the NCU proposals,
Boivin's
type choice clearly has priority and the name should be used in the sense of
Kalm's
type. It may be that a proposal for either conservation or rejection of
S. bermudiana
would now be helpful in resolving the problems still associated with this name.