Two new species of the genus Encrasicholina (Clupeiformes: Engraulidae): E. intermedia from the western Indian Ocean and E. gloria from the Persian Gulf, Red Sea and Mediterranean Author Hata, Harutaka Author Motomura, Hiroyuki text Raffles Bulletin of Zoology 2016 2016-05-13 64 79 88 journal article 10.5281/zenodo.4504409 2345-7600 4504409 D6D1C4DE-58A2-4885-A199-D3CB0E3774A8 Encrasicholina gloria , new species [New English name: Red Sea anchovy] ( Figs. 2–5 ; Tables 1 , 2 ) Material examined. Holotype : MNHN 1966-0646 , 53.3 mm SL, Suez Bay , Egypt , 29°54’00”N , 32°31’12”E , 16 January 1929 , R . P. Dollfus . Paratypes : 13 specimens , 48.9–72.0 mm SL. BMNH 1984.5.16.9–15, 5 specimens , 56.4–62.2 mm SL, Khasab , Oman , P. Cornelius ; HUJ 20531, 67.9 mm SL, Jaffa , Israel ; HUJ 20269, 3, 64.2–72.0 mm SL, KAUM–I . 80906, 65.1 mm SL, off coast between Tel Aviv and Ashdod , Israel ; MNHN 1942-0049 , 3 , 48.9–57.2 mm SL, off Saudi Arabia , 1929, R . P. Dollfus. Fig. 2. Holotype of Encrasicholina gloria , new species . MNHN 1966-0646, 53.3 mm SL, Suez Bay, Egypt. Diagnosis. A species of Encrasicholina with the following combination of characters: dorsal and anal fins with two unbranched rays; pseudobranchial filaments 21–25; gill rakers 22–26 (modally 22, 24) in upper series on 1st gill arch, 29–33 (30, 31) in lower series, 51–59 (54) in total; gill rakers 15–16 (16) in upper series on 2nd gill arch, 26–29 (26) in lower series, 42–45 (42) in total; gill rakers 12–14 (12) in upper series on 3rd gill arch, 14–15 (14) in lower series, 26–29 (26) in total; gill rakers 9–11 (11) in upper series on 4th gill arch, 10–12 (11) in lower, 19–23 (22) in total; prepelvic scutes 3–6 (4); posterior tip of upper jaw not reaching to anterior margin of preopercle; length of first unbranched dorsal-fin ray 6.8–7.9% of SL. Description. Data for the holotype are presented first, followed by paratype data in parentheses. Body cylindrical, elongate; greatest body depth at dorsal-fin origin. Dorsal profile of head and body slightly convex from snout tip to dorsal-fin origin, straight along dorsal-fin base. Ventral profile of head and body slightly convex from lower-jaw tip to pelvicfin insertion, slightly convex to straight from pelvic-fin origin to anal-fin origin, almost straight along anal-fin base. Dorsal and ventral profiles of caudal peduncle slightly concave. Belly slightly rounded, covered by 5 (3–6) sharp needle-like scutes anterior to insertion of pelvic fins. Postpelvic and predorsal scutes absent. Anus situated just anterior to anal-fin origin. Caudal peduncle compressed, its depth greater than eye diameter. Head rather large, compressed. Snout length less than eye diameter, tip rounded. Interorbital width less than orbit diameter. Mouth large, inferior, ventral to body axis, extending backward beyond posterior margin of eye. Lower jaw slender, longer than upper jaw, 115.5% (105.4–115.5%) of upper-jaw length, 65.3% (61.1–72.1%) of head length. Posterior tip of maxilla blunt, scarcely projecting beyond second supra-maxilla, not reaching to anterior border of preopercle. Single rows of conical teeth on jaws and palatines. Small conical teeth on vomer. Eye large, round, covered with adipose eyelid, lateral on head, located dorsal to horizontal through pectoral-fin insertion, visible in dorsal and ventral views; pupil round. Orbit elliptical. Nostrils close to each other, positioned anterior to anterior margin of orbit and above horizontal through midline of body. Posterior margin of preopercle smooth. Subopercle with rounded posterior margin. Opercular membrane without serrations. Interorbital space flat. Pseudobranchial filaments present, length of longest filament less than eye diameter. Posterior frontal fontanelles on top of head near occiput open. Gill rakers long, slender, rough, visible from side of head when mouth open. Distance between pectoral-fin and pelvic-fin insertions slightly shorter (slightly longer in some paratypes ) than distance between dorsal-fin origin and anal-fin origin. Isthmus muscle short, not reaching anteriorly to posterior border of gill membrane, preceded by exposed urohyal between gill membranes. Exposed urohyal with two small fleshy lobes laterally. Gill membrane not broadly joined over isthmus. Scales thin, cycloid, deciduous, except for prepelvic scutes. Scales absent on head. Lateral line absent. Scales absent on fins except for broad triangular sheath of scales on caudal fin. Pectoral-fin axillary scale shorter than pectoral fin (absent in most paratypes , probably lost when collected or during storage). Pelvic-fin axillary scale absent in holotype and some paratypes (when present smaller than pectoral-fin axillary scale). Dorsal-fin origin posterior to vertical through base of last pelvic-fin ray, positioned approximately at mid body. Dorsal-fin base short, its length 69.2% (70.9–88.4%) of analfin base length. Dorsal and anal fins with two anteriormost rays unbranched. First dorsal-fin ray and first anal-fin ray rather long. Two anteriormost dorsal-fin and anal-fin rays closely spaced. Anal-fin origin posterior to vertical through base of last dorsal-fin ray; posterior tip of depressed anal fin falling short of caudal-fin base. Uppermost pectoral-fin ray unbranched, inserted below midline of body. Posterior tip of pectoral fin falling short of pelvic-fin origin; pectoral-fin rays damaged in holotype (1st or 2nd rays longest in some paratypes ). Pelvic fin shorter than pectoral fin, insertion anterior to vertical at dorsal-fin origin. Posterior tip of depressed pelvic fin not reaching to anus, reaching vertical through base of 6th (6th–8th) dorsal-fin ray. Colour of preserved specimens. Head and body almost uniformly pale brown, with a dull silver-gray, longitudinal band, its width slightly broader than pupil diameter, from just posterior to upper opercular margin to caudal-fin base. Few black melanophores scattered on occipital, upper part of opercle, and silver longitudinal band. Distribution. Currently known only from the Persian Gulf (Khasab, Oman ), the Red Sea ( Egypt and Saudi Arabia ) and the eastern Mediterranean ( State of Israel ) ( Fig. 5 ). The distribution of specimens in the Mediterranean is considered to represent Lessepsian migration. Table 1. Meristics of specimens of Encrasicholina intermedia , new species , E. gloria , new species , and E. punctifer .
Encrasicholina intermedia , new species Encrasicholina gloria , new species
Holotype Paratypes Holotype Paratypes
India Indian Ocean Egypt Red Sea, Persian Gulf and Mediterranean
RMNH. PISC 26135 n = 14 Modes MNHN 1966-0646 n = 13 Modes
Standard length (SL; mm) 57.7 49.8–75.2 53.3 48.9–72.0
Dorsal-fin rays (unbranched) 2 2 2 2 2 2
Dorsal-fin rays (branched) 11 10–13 11 12 11–13 11
Anal-fin rays (unbranched) Anal-fin rays (branched) Pectoral-fin rays (unbranched) 2 15 1 2 12–16 1 2 14 1 2 15 1 2 13–16 1 2 13 1
Pectoral-fin rays (branched) Pelvic-fin rays (unbranched) Pelvic-fin rays (branched) Caudal-fin rays (upper + lower) 14 1 6 10 + 9 12–15 1 6 10 + 9 14 1 6 10 + 9 14 1 6 10 + 9 13–15 1 6 10 + 9 14 1 6 10 + 9
Gill rakers on 1st gill arch (upper) Gill rakers on 1st gill arch (lower) Gill rakers on 1st gill arch (total) Gill rakers on 2nd gill arch (upper) Gill rakers on 2nd gill arch (lower) Gill rakers on 2nd gill arch (total) Gill rakers on 3rd gill arch (upper) 20 27 47 14 24 38 11 20–23 26–28 46–50 13–14 23–25 36–38 10–12 20 26 46 13 23 36 11 23 30 53 16 26 42 12 22–26 30–33 52–59 15–16 26–29 42–45 12–14 22 30 52, 53 16 26 42 12
Gill rakers on 3rd gill arch (lower) 13 12–13 13 14 14–16 14
Gill rakers on 3rd gill arch (total) Gill rakers on 4th gill arch (upper) 24 10 23–25 9–10 24 10 26 9 26–29 9–11 26 11
Gill rakers on 4th gill arch (lower) Gill rakers on 4th gill arch (total) 11 21 9–10 19–21 10 19, 20 11 20 10–12 19–23 11 22
Gill rakers on posterior face of 3rd gill arch Total gill rakers of all gill arches Prepelvic scutes Lateral-line scales 7 137 4 40 4–7 131–136 3–6 39–43 6 134 5 40 5 146 5 41 3–8 144–161 3–6 41–43 7 147, 155 5 42
Pseudobranch filaments 26 21–26 24 24 21–26 24
Encrasicholina punctifer
Holotype of Encrasicholina punctifer Paratypes of Encrasicholina punctifer Holotype of Stolephorus buccaneeri Paratypes of Stolephorus buccaneeri Non-type specimens
French Polynesia Hawaii Indo-Pacific
ANSP 68308 n = 12 USNM 177742 n = 27 n = 83 Modes
29.9 23.4–31.9 51.0 37.6–56.4 21.9–95.5
broken 2 2 2 2 2
broken 10–12 11 11–12 10–13 11
broken 2 2 2 2 2
broken 12–14 13 12–14 11–16 13
broken 1 1 1 1 1
broken 13–14 15 13–16 11–16 14
1 1 1 1 1 1
6 6 6 6 6 6
10 + 9 10 + 9 10 + 9 10 + 9 10 + 9 10 + 9
14 11–14 17 16–18 11–20 17
23 23–24 25 24–26 21–26 24
37 34–38 42 41–43 34–45 42
11 8–11 10 10–12 7–14 11
18 17–19 21 20–22 17–23 21
29 26–30 31 30–34 25–36 32
9 6–9 8 8–11 7–11 9
11 8–12 11 9–12 10–13 12
20 14–20 19 18–23 18–23 21
8 6–8 9 7–9 5–10 8
8 7–9 9 8–10 7–12 9
16 13–17 18 16–19 13–20 17
3 3–4 5 4–6 3–7 5
105 94–96 115 111–120 94–125 116
broken broken 7 4–6 3–5 5
broken broken 41 41–43 38–43 40
broken 18–21 23 20–24 16–28 24
Table 2. Morphometrics of specimens of Encrasicholina intermedia , new species , E. gloria , new species , and E. punctifer .
Encrasicholina intermedia , new species Encrasicholina gloria , new species
Holotype Paratypes Holotype Paratypes
India Indian Ocean Egypt Red Sea and Mediterranean
RMNH.PISC 26135 n = 14 Means MNHN 1966-0646 n = 13 Means
Standard length (SL; mm) 57.7 49.8–75.2 53.3 48.9–72.0
As % SL
Head Length 24.2 22.7–26.6 24.4 26.4 24.2–25.7 25.0
Body depth 15.6 13.9–16.8 15.6 14.9 13.3–18.1 15.7
Pre-dorsal-fin length 51.8 48.4–53.7 52.0 54.1 49.8–53.0 51.6
Snout tip to pectoral-fin insertion 25.6 23.5–28.7 25.2 26.9 23.4–27.3 25.7
Snout tip to pelvic-fin insertion 44.4 42.0–47.9 45.0 49.3 44.1–46.8 45.9
Snout to anal-fin origin 66.5 59.8–67.0 65.3 70.5 61.2–66.1 65.2
Dorsal-fin base length 11.3 10.2–12.4 11.6 11.9 9.9–12.2 11.4
Anal-fin base length 13.7 13.0–15.2 14.6 17.2 13.7–16.6 15.1
Caudal-peduncle length 17.7 17.2–21.0 19.2 18.6 18.8–21.7 20.4
Caudal-peduncle depth 7.8 7.1–8.5 7.6 8.2 7.1–8.6 7.8
Pectoral-fin length 12.8 12.3–14.1 13.2 14.6 11.8–15.2 14.2
Pelvic-fin length 7.9 7.2–9.2 8.2 9.7 8.0–10.1 9.3
Interorbital width 4.3 4.1–4.8 4.4 5.2 4.1–5.8 4.6
Upper-jaw length 14.0 13.6–15.8 14.4 14.9 14.2–16.1 15.0
Mandibular length 15.2 14.9–16.3 15.7 17.2 15.6–18.1 16.8
1st unbranched dorsal-fin ray length 5.3 4.7–5.8 5.4 7.6 6.8–7.9 7.2
2nd unbranched dorsal-fin ray length 12.3 12.1–15.2 12.2 broken 14.5–16.3 15.3
3rd dorsal-fin ray length 12.5 11.9–15.0 13.3 broken 14.3–17.3 15.6
1st unbranched anal-fin ray length broken 2.8–4.1 3.3 4.1 3.0–4.3 3.6
2nd unbranched anal-fin ray length 8.3 7.9–10.8 9.3 broken 9.8–11.8 10.9
3rd anal-fin ray length 9.3 8.6–10.5 9.3 broken 10.3–11.4 11.0
1st pectoral-fin ray length 12.5 12.0–13.8 12.8 13.9 13.1–15.2 14.4
1st pelvic-fin ray length 7.9 7.2–9.2 8.1 9.4 8.0–9.5 8.9
As % HL
Orbit diameter 29.0 28.3–34.7 31.5 30.6 30.3–35.5 32.7
Eye diameter 24.0 21.4–28.0 24.6 26.0 24.2–27.8 26.1
Snout length 15.2 13.3–17.7 15.3 17.0 14.1–18.2 16.1
D–P1 122.7 109.5–150.1 128.3 115.1 114.0–128.3 119.2
D–P2 69.1 59.2–74.6 67.5 58.6 56.2–75.3 65.3
D–A 88.9 78.2–93.5 86.3 79.4 74.2–89.6 83.1
P1–P2 82.1 71.1–104.3 86.3 86.3 80.1–88.0 84.3
P2–A 89.5 69.5–90.2 81.3 78.1 69.3–82.8 77.0
Postorbital length 55.9 48.4–57.7 53.2 49.7 47.8–54.8 50.7
Encrasicholina punctifer
Holotype of Encrasicholina punctifer Paratypes of Encrasicholina punctifer Holotype of Stolephorus buccaneeri Paratypes of Stolephorus buccaneeri Non-type specimens
French Polynesia Hawaii West Pacific and Phuket
ANSP 68308 n = 12 USNM 177742 n = 27 n = 83 Means
29.9 23.4–31.9 51.0 37.6–56.4 21.9–95.5
broken 17.3–23.0 22.4 22.2–26.4 17.2–27.0 23.5
10.8 8.5–11.8 15.1 13.7–15.8 8.7–18.8 14.1
broken 49.9–55.7 52.8 48.9–53.8 49.3–57.4 52.7
21.4 17.8–24.9 24.6 22.5–28.9 17.5–28.7 24.1
42.9 41.5–44.9 51.9 43.2–52.5 39.1–50.2 45.6
61.6 60.2–66.4 70.9 65.6–72.9 61.2–71.4 66.8
broken 10.0–12.5 10.5 9.9–12.7 9.2–14.4 11.4
13.3 11.6–15.7 11.3 12.4–15.1 12.3–16.1 14
broken 18.4–21.1 14.4 14.4–20.1 15.6–22.2 18
6.0 4.5–7.3 7.0 6.5–8.2 5.6–8.6 7.3
broken broken 12.1 11.0–14.8 10.0–15.1 13.1
broken 4.8–7.2 8.3 7.2–9.3 4.4–10.0 7.9
broken 2.7–4.1 3.8 3.7–4.3 2.9–5.5 4.2
9.8 7.4–11.3 14.1 12.7–15.6 7.5–16.7 13.5
11.9 8.5–13.0 15.4 14.0–17.9 8.9–19.6 15.0
broken 3.7–5.4 5.0 3.8–6.3 3.8–6.8 5.5
broken 8.7–11.2 13.5 11.3–16.4 10.3–16.8 13.8
broken 8.6–11.0 13.2 11.1–15.3 11.2–17.1 13.7
broken 2.6–3.4 2.4 2.1–4.0 2.0–4.3 3.2
broken 6.7 8.6 7.3–10.9 6.8–11.3 9.3
broken 7.0–8.6 8.6 8.1–11.7 7.5–11.5 9.5
broken broken 12.1 9.9–14.1 2.3–14.7 12.1
broken 4.8–7.2 7.9 7.2–9.3 5.4–10.1 8.0
broken 24.3–36.0 31.8 26.2–33.4 25.1–36.4 31.7
broken 19.3–23.3 19.6 19.2–26.9 19.1–32.5 24.3
broken 11.7–15.7 15.0 12.8–16.3 11.6–17.2 14.7
broken 136.7–193.1 135.3 104.0–140.8 106.3–212.7 135.1
broken 59.1–80.1 73.4 55.8–68.2 51.1–90.3 67.6
broken 65.3–89.1 98.9 82.7–101.0 68.2–109.8 87.8
broken 83.5–125.7 103.3 87.7–105.3 66.0–141.6 95.6
broken 89.8–106.7 100.0 72.5–99.8 61.6–133.5 91.6
broken 49.8–60.7 59.3 51.3–60.6 47.9–58.4 53.6
Etymology. The specific name gloria is derived from the Latin meaning “glory”, in reference to the brilliant silver stripe along the body. Comparisons. Eight nominal species have been attributed to the genus Encrasicholina ( Whitehead et al., 1988 ; Hata & Motomura, 2015 ). Encrasicholina intermedia new species and E. gloria new species are easily distinguished from all congeners, except for E. punctifer Fowler, 1938 , and Stolephorus buccaneeri Strasburg, 1960 , by having a short upper jaw, its posterior tip not reaching to the anterior border of the preopercle (vs. posterior tip of upper jaw reaching or extending beyond the anterior border; Hardenberg, 1933 , 1934 ; Wongratana, 1983 ; Whitehead et al., 1988 ; Wongratana et al., 1999 ; Hata et al., 2012 ; Hata & Motomura, 2015 ). The first dorsal-fin ray length also can be used for distinguishing the three species from E. devisi (0.4–1.7% SL) and E. macrocephala (0.6–1.3% SL; Hata & Motomura, 2015 ; this study). Encrasicholina intermedia , E. gloria , and E. punctifer [with its junior synonym Stolephorus buccaneeri ( Wongratana, 1983 ; Whitehead et al., 1988 ; Wongratana et al., 1999 ; this study)] resemble each other in sharing two unbranched rays in the dorsal and anal fins, a short upper jaw with its posterior tip not reaching to the anterior border of the preopercle, and an exposed urohyal with two small fleshy lobes. They can be distinguished from each other by the numbers of gill rakers on the first to fourth gill arches ( Table 1 ; Fig. 3 ). Encrasicholina gloria is also distinguished from the other two species in having a longer 1st unbranched dorsal-fin ray [6.8–7.9% (mean 7.3%) SL vs. 3.8–6.8 % (5.4%) in E. punctifer and 4.7–5.8% (5.4%) in E. intermedia ; Table 2 ; Fig. 4 .]. Comparative material examined. Encrasicholina punctifer ( 137 specimens , 21.9–95.5 mm SL): ANSP 68308, holotype of E. punctifer , 29.9 mm SL, ANSP 68309, 12 paratypes of E. punctifer , 23.4–31.9 mm SL, Fare Bay, Huaheine Island, Society Islands, French Polynesia , 17 April 1937 ; ANSP 82384, 10 of 19, 24.3–27.7 mm SL, Bora Bora Island, Society Islands, French Polynesia , 21 April 1937 ; BMNH 1965.10.19.39–40, 2, 37.4–51.5 mm SL; ca. 32 km northwest of Iriomote Island, Japan , 11 June 1965 ; BMNH 1967.11.10.1, 40.3 mm SL, taken from mouth of Coryphaena hippurus captured off Haputo, Guam , 8 August 1967 ; BMNH 1967.11.13.905–906, 2, 39.2–41.8 mm SL, Singapore , 13 July 1963 ; BMNH 1970.5.27.1–3, 2 of 3, 40.3–51.7 mm SL, taken from stomach of tuna captured off Apia Harbour, Upolu Island, Samoa ; BMNH 1971.8.26.7–8, 1 of 2, 30.1 mm SL, Suruga Bay, Japan , 1967; BMNH 1971.8.26.9–10, 2, 28.2– 19.9 mm SL, between Starbuck Island and Malden Island, Kiribati , 04°57’S , 155°07’W , 3 October 1969 ; BMNH 1972.9.7.32–33, 2, 53.2– 43.9 mm SL, Fuellerborn Harbour, New Britain Island, Papua New Guinea , 7 April 1972 ; BMNH 1976.4.27.18, 55.7 mm SL, Hong Kong ; BMNH 1978.8.17.7–8, 2, 51.8–54.2 mm SL, Pomona, Queensland , Australia ; BMNH 1988.8.1.74–86, 11, 51.1–61.8 mm SL, Hainan Island, China , 22 April 1988 ; KAUM–I. 6673, 52.7 mm SL, off Chiringa Island, Ibusuki, Kagoshima , Japan , 31°16’38”N , 130°40’18”E , 25 m , 3 October 2007 ; KAUM–I. 7374, 53.5 mm SL, off Chiringa Island, Ibusuki, Kagoshima , Japan , 31°16’38”N , 130°40’18”E , set net, 25 m , 28 November 2007 ; KAUM–I. 7398, 55.2 mm SL, off Tsushiro, Uchinoura Bay, Koyama, Kimotsuki, Kagoshima , Japan , 31°17’N , 130°41’E , set net, 40 m , 29 October 2007 ; KAUM–I. 10445, 95.5 mm SL, off Kaimon, Ibusuki, Kagoshima , Japan , 31°10’20”N , 130°32’56”E , set net, 50 m , 25 June 2008 ; KAUM–I. 22921, 57.5 mm SL, mouth of Bang Pakong River, Chachoengsao , Thailand , 13°27’N , 100°57’E ; KAUM–I. 41056, 54.1 mm SL, KAUM–I. 41057, 53.2 mm SL, KAUM–I. 41058, 53.1 mm SL, east of Sakinoyama, Kataura, Kasasa, Minami-satsuma, Kagoshima , Japan , 31°25’44”N , 130°11’49”E , 27 June 2009 , 27 m; KAUM–I. 59680, 80.0 mm SL, KAUM–I.59681, 73.9 mm SL, off Phuket , Thailand ; KAUM–I. 60391, 65.6 mm SL, KAUM–I. 60396, 68.4 mm SL, KAUM–I. 60419, 78.6 mm SL, KAUM–I. 60426, 81.9 mm SL, KAUM–I. 60430, 74.9 mm SL, KAUM–I. 60441, 79.7 mm SL, KAUM–I. 60442, 79.8 mm SL, East China Sea; MNHN 1959-0535, 53.7 mm SL, Manila , Luzon, Philippines , 14°36’00”N , 120°58’59”E ; NSMT-P. 63820, 9, 51.0– 58.6 mm SL, NSMT-P. 63833, 52.1 mm SL; NSMT-P. 68755, 71.2 mm SL, Nha Trang, Khánh Hòa , Vietnam ; USNM 177742, holotype of Stolephorus buccaneeri , 51.0 mm SL, USNM 177743, 19 paratypes of S. buccaneeri , 42.2–54.5 mm SL, ca. 1.8 km west of Lehua Island off Niihau Island, Hawaiian Islands, 15 Sept. 1958 , Noboru Tsue and crew of M/V BUCANEER OF HONOLULU; USNM 177744, 8 paratypes of S. buccaneeri , 37.6–48.3 mm SL, taken from stomach of Euthynnus affinis captured from 1.6 km off Makua, Oahu, Hawaiian Islands, 10 Sept. 1958 , M/V MAKUA OF HONOLULU; USNM 417167, 26 of 111, 21.9–70.2 mm SL, east of Agrihan Island, Northern Mariana Islands , 19°02’00”N , 148°25’00”E , 7 Nov. 1971 , trawl, 50 m ; YCM-P. 39398, 2, 34.9–35.8 mm SL, Atetsu Bay, Amami Island, Kagoshima , Japan , 4 September 1999 ; ZMA 108.384, 71.3 mm SL, Pidjot Bay, Lombok, Indonesia , 24–26 March 1899 ; ZMA 108.399, 2, 47.7–59.2 mm SL, Bitung, Sulawesi , Indonesia , 3 December 1909 . Examined specimens of other species of Encrasicholina were listed in Hata & Motomura (2015) .