Call a spade a spade: taxonomy and distribution of Pelobates, with description of a new Balkan endemic
Author
Dufresnes, Christophe
Author
Strachinis, Ilias
Author
Tzoras, Elias
Author
Litvinchuk, Spartak N.
Author
Denoel, Mathieu
text
ZooKeys
2019
859
131
158
http://dx.doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.859.33634
journal article
http://dx.doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.859.33634
1313-2970-859-131
Pelobates varaldii Pasteur & Bons, 1959
Diagnosis
.
A smaller version of
P. cultripes
(Fig. 2) differing by a few phenotypic features. Unlike
P. cultripes
, the black coloration of the spades is often concentrated on the edges (
Pasteur and Bons 1959
;
Busack et al. 1985
). The cranial braincase is high and narrow in
P. varaldii
, while it is low and wide in
P. cultripes
(
Pasteur and Bons 1959
;
Rocek
1981
). The background coloration can be yellow, gray, and brown, with dark reticulate patches, and the dorsal surface is abundantly covered by orange dots, most pronounced on the eyelids (usually absent in
P. cultripes
;
Pasteur and Bons 1959
;
Beukema et al. 2013
; Fig. 3). Males are usually smaller than females (Fig. 2). Average SVL = 53 mm (range: 36-66 mm) for females (n = 4 populations) and 51 mm
(
33-65 mm) for males (n = 4 populations) (Suppl. material 1, Table S1; Fig. 2). The karyotype includes six large and seven small pairs of two-armed chromosomes. Large centromeric C-bands appears in the pairs 1, 2, 4, 9, and 12; pericentric bands in the short arms of pair 1 and long arm of pair 8; telomeric bands in the long arms of pairs 1, 2, and 11; the short arm of pair 7 is almost heterochromatic (
Herrero and Talavera 1988
). The nuclear DNA content averages 7.3 pg (
Litvinchuk et al. 2013
). As shown
in
Table 1,
P. varaldii
differs from
P. cultripes
by 6.0% at mtDNA and 0.40% at nuclear DNA (
Dufresnes et al. 2019b
).
Figure 2. Between-population variation of average size (
snout-vent
length - SVL) for each
Pelobates
species, measured separately for females (pink) and males (blue). This compiles average size-data from 82 populations, representing at least 6,004 individuals (Suppl. material 1, Table S1). For
P. balcanicus
, it only includes populations from the nominal
P. b. balcanicus
. For
P. syriacus
, it only includes populations from
P. s. boettgeri
.
Figure 3. Color variation in
Pelobates cultripes
,
P. varaldii
,
P. fuscus
and
P. vespertinus
. Photo credits and origins as follows a CD (
Herault
, France) b, c CD (Algarve, Portugal) d A Sanchez Vialas (Spain) e G Martinez (Kenitra, Morocco)
f-h
A Sanchez Vialas (Tanger, Morocco) i, j N Suriadna (Ukraine) k CD (Wojewodztwo podkarpackie, Poland) l A
Noellert
(Burgenland, Austria)
m-p
N Suriadna (Ukraine).
Table 1. Pairwise % of genetic differences between
Pelobates
taxa (from the data of
Dufresnes et al. 2019b
). The estimates below diagonal correspond to mitochondrial DNA (cyt-b + 16S, 1.2 kb); the estimates above diagonal correspond to nuclear DNA (63.5 kb of RAD tags).
P. cultripes
|
P. varaldii
|
P. fuscus
|
P. vespertinus
|
P. s. syriacus
|
P. s. boettgeri
|
P. b. balcanicus
|
P. b. chloeae
|
P. cultripes
|
P. varaldii
|
P. fuscus
|
P. vespertinus
|
P. s. syriacus
|
P. s. boettgeri
|
P. b. balcanicus
|
P. b. chloeae
|
Taxonomy.
The nomen
Pelobates varaldii
Pasteur & Bons, 1959 is the only one ever proposed for the Moroccan populations of spadefoot toads; holotype: MNHN-RA-1959.1; type locality: Merja Samora, Morocco. The ancient split of
P. varaldii
, dating back to the Messinian Salinity Crisis (5.3 My), supports its specific distinction from
P. cultripes
(
Busack et al. 1985
;
Crottini et al. 2007
).
Distribution.
It is endemic to north-western Morocco (0-350 m elevation a.s.l.), found along the Atlantic coast, from the south of Tanger to Oualidia, where it is rare (
de Pous et al. 2012
;
Beukema et al. 2013
;
Frost 2019
). IUCN status: Endangered (
Salvador et al. 2009
).
Diversity.
To our knowledge,
P. varaldii
has not been the focus of any phylogeographic or population genetic work.