Systematics of Anopheles (Cellia) yaeyamaensis sp. n., alias species E of the An. minimus complex in southeastern Asia (Diptera: Culicidae)
Author
Somboon, Pradya
Author
Rory, Angela
Author
Tsuda, Yoshio
Author
Takagi, Masahiro
Author
Harbach, Ralph E.
text
Zootaxa
2010
2651
43
51
journal article
10.5281/zenodo.198826
a649d2be-d943-4356-87c1-2d7d02ee83b6
1175-5326
198826
Anopheles
(
Cellia
)
yaeyamaensis
Somboon & Harbach
,
sp. n.
Anopheles formosaensis
I
of
Miyasaki, 1902
: 66
(Ishigaki Island).
Anopheles minimus
of
Bohart, 1959
: 195
(Ishigaki and Iriomote Islands; L bionomics);
Tanaka
et al
., 1975
: 210
(Ishigaki and Miyako Islands; distribution, bionomics);
Harrison, 1980
: 84
(in part, Miyako and Yaeyama Guntô Islands);
Miyagi & Toma, 1980
: 83
–89, 91 (Iriomote Island; A L bionomics);
Toma & Miyagi, 1986
: 11
, 28, 33, 41, 95, 96, 102 (Ishigaki, Iriomote and Miyako Islands; A* L* keys, bionomics, distribution);
Toma
et al
., 1996a
: 63
–71 (Ishigaki Island; L bionomics);
Toma
et al
., 1996b
: 167
–169 (Miyako Island; L distribution, bionomics);
Tsuda
et al
., 1999
: 601
–603 (Ishigaki Island; A bionomics);
Somboon
et al
., 2001
: 98
–101, 102 (figs 4–6, 8), 103–111 (Ishigaki Island; A, Ƥcibarial armature* E L, metaphase karyotype*, crossmating, D3 of 28S rDNA; designation as
An. minimus
species E);
Toma
et al
., 2002a
: 29
–40 (Ishigaki Island; L bionomics);
Toma
et al
., 2002b
: 146
–149 (Ishigaki Island; susceptibility to
Plasmodium yoelii nigeriense
); Higa
et al
., 2003: 257, 258, 260–264 (Ishigaki Island; bionomics);
Sawabe
et al
., 2003
: 772
–778 (Ishigaki Island; ITS1, ITS2 and D3 of 28S rDNA); Toma
et al
., 2003: 267–273 (Iriomote and Kohama Islands; L distribution, bionomics);
Toma, 2006
: 125
–127 (Miyako Island; A L bionomics);
Nakagawa
et al
., 2009
: 97
–99, 105, 106 (Ishigaki Island; bionomics).
Anopheles minimus minimus
of
Miyagi & Toma, 1978
: 245
–247, 250 (Ishigaki and Iriomote Islands; A L bionomics).
Anopheles minimus
species E of
Somboon
et al
., 2000a
: 136
(summary);
Somboon
et al
., 2000b
: 476
–478 (Ishigaki Island; crossmating, Ƥcibarial armature*);
Harbach, 2004
: 540
, 545 (classification);
Somboon
et al
., 2005a
: 5
–9 (crossmating);
Somboon
et al
., 2005b
: 605
–608 (crossmating); Garros
et al
., 2006: 103–106, 108 (distribution);
Sungvornyothin
et al.
, 2006
: 185
(A morphology);
Harbach
et al
., 2007
: 41
, 45, 47, 49 (DNA sequence: ITS2 and D3 of 28S rDNA, COII mt DNA); Manguin
et al
., 2008: 490, 491 (taxonomy, distribution); Garros
et al
., 2008: print p. 2 (distribution).
Anopheles
(
Cellia
)
minimus
of
Tanaka
et al
., 1979
: 31
, 47–51, 554, figs 11, 12 (Miyako and Yaeyama Guntô Islands; Ƥ* 3 3G* L* P, keys, distribution, bionomics).
Diagnosis.
Sequences for the ITS1, ITS2 and the D3 domain of the 28S rDNA and COII mt DNA (
Somboon
et al
., 2001
;
Sawabe
et al
., 2003
;
Harbach
et al
., 2007
: figs 2–6) distinguish
An. yaeyamaensis
from the other members of the
Minimus
Complex, i.e.
An. minimus
and
An. harrisoni
. Comparative anatomical studies indicate that the adult and pupal stages of the three species are essentially isomorphic in all life stages, however the number of branches of larval seta 7-C will distinguish most larvae of
An. yaeyamaensis
from those of
An. minimus
. The metaphase karyotype of
An. yaeyamaensis
is distinct from that of
An. harrisoni
(see below).
Description.
ADULT (female)—As described and illustrated by
Tanaka
et al
. (1979
, available at http:// www.mosquitocatalog.org/files/pdfs/WR159.pdf), with following additional details.
Head
: Antennal length about 1.1 mm, flagellomeres 1–3 with pale scales on mesal surfaces. Proboscis length about 1.5 mm. Maxillary palpus 1.4–1.6 mm long, with 3 pale bands (in dorsal view), apical pale band about length of preapical dark band and slightly longer than preapical pale band.
Cibarial armature
: Cone filaments thornlike, relatively narrow and gradually tapered to pointed apex [filaments lancet-like in
An. minimus
and
An. harrisoni
(see
Somboon
et al
., 2001
: figs 1–8)].
Thorax
: Integument brown, pleura with darker areas; scutum with broad median pale pruinose area confluent with scutellum of similar appearance; anterior promontory with long erect white falcate scales that transition into semi-erect pale golden piliform scales on acrostichal and dorsocentral areas that extend posteriorly to and then on lateral margin of prescutellar area to scutellum; long golden-brown to brown setae on acrostichal, dorsocentral and prescutellar areas, dark setae on fossal, antealar and supraalar areas.
Wing
: Length 2.1–3.4 mm; dark scaling very black on costa, subcosta and R–R1, subdued on posterior veins, pale scaling pale yellow, not white; humeral pale spot rarely absent and presector pale spot occasionally absent on one or both wings (in 1 of 87 and 5 of 87 feral females, respectively), vein R3 often (about 50%) with median pale spot and 1A pale fringe spot frequently (about 80%) present (Somboon, unpublished observations).
Legs
: Coxae and trochanters without scales; femora, tibiae and tarsi dark-scaled, apices of tibiae indistinctly pale, tarsomeres 1–4 with minute faint dorsoapical pale spots.
Abdomen
: Integument dark with uniform covering of golden setae. ADULT (male)—As described and illustrated by
Tanaka
et al
. (1979)
, with following additional details.
Head
: Eyes more widely separated, decumbent falcate scales of interocular space slightly more numerous. Proboscis longer and more slender, approximately 1.4 length of forefemur.
Wing
: Generally paler and scaling reduced, fringe spots less distinct. PUPA—Habitus and chaetotaxy as described and illustrated for
An. minimus
by
Harbach
et al
. (2006)
, setal branching compared with that of
An. minimu
s in Table 1, differing as follows.
Trumpet
: Length 0.34–0.39 mm, meatus 0.03–0.09 mm, pinna 0.27–0.33 mm.
Abdomen
: Length 1.97–2.36 mm.
Genital lobe
: Length 0.13–0.17 mm in female; 0.34–
36 mm
in male.
Paddle
: Length 0.61–0.64 mm, width 0.41–0.47 mm, index 1.30–1.54. LARVA (fourthinstar)—Habitus and chaetotaxy as described and illustrated by
Tanaka
et al
. (1979)
, setal branching compared with that of
An. minimus
in Table 2, with following additional details.
Head
: Slightly wider than long, width 0.57–0.62 mm, length 0.54–0.60 mm; integument with variable pattern of moderately to darkly pigmented areas; collar and mentum darkly pigmented. Seta 7-C with 17–26(21) branches [14–18(16) in
type
specimens of
An. minimus
(see
Harbach
et al
., 2006
) and 19/15 [left/right sides] in
holotype
of
An. harrisoni
(see
Harbach
et al
., 2007
)].
Thorax
: Integument hyaline, smooth. Mesothorax with conjoined pair of median notal plates, sometimes also with pair of submedian notal plates; metathorax usually with separated pair of notal plates, apparently without submedian notal plates. Setae 1,2-P inserted on narrowly separated tubercles; support plate of pleural setal groups 9–12-P,M,T with short spine.
Abdomen
: Integument hyaline, smooth. Seta 0-III–VII well developed, normally branched, not noticeably larger on segments IV and V; seta 1-I–VII fully palmate with moderately pigmented leaflets, leaflets with distinct shoulders and long slender filaments (blades and shoulders narrower on segment I), blades usually with distal patch of darker pigment near shoulder. Pecten with long spines usually at each end and several interspersed among short spines. Saddle moderately to darkly pigmented, length about 0.22 mm. Seta
1-X
single, simple, inserted on saddle;
4-X
(ventral brush) with 9 offset pairs of setae, longest branches on anterior side of main stems. Dorsal and ventral anal papillae equal in length, shorter to slightly longer than saddle. EGG—In general as described for
An. minimus
by
Reid (1968)
; length 0.39–0.55 mm (mean 0.45 mm); deck usually complete (
Somboon
et al
., 2001
).
Metaphase karyotype.
The metaphase karyotype of
An. yaeyamaensis
(
Somboon
et al
., 2001
)
is similar to that of
An. minimus
but very different from that of
An. harrisoni
(
Baimai
et al
., 1996
)
.
Anopheles harrisoni
has a prominent landmark of pericentric heterochromatin in the autosomes and the short arm of the submetacentric X chromosome. The ratio of the short to long arms of the submetacentric Y chromosome is about 1:1.5 in
An. harrisoni
, whereas it is 1:3–1:
4 in
An. yaeyamaensis
and
An. minimus
.
Crossing experiments.
Crossmating carried out between
An. yaeyamaensis
and
An. minimus
(
Somboon
et al
., 2001
;
Somboon
et al
., 2005b
) and between
An. yaeyamaensis
and
An. harrisoni
(
Somboon
et al
., 2005a
) revealed postzygotic incompatibility. The former yielded hybrid progeny only when
An. minimus
females were mated with
An. yaeyamaensis
males, but the hybrid (F1) males were sterile or almost sterile with atrophied testes. No asynapsis was observed in the salivary gland polythene chromosomes of the hybrid larvae. The latter cross yielded hybrid (F1) progeny from reciprocal crosses, but the hybrid males were sterile with atrophied testes and accessory glands or were partially sterile with abnormal and inactive spermatozoa. The polythene chromosomes of hybrid larvae exhibited partial asynapsis or a fixed heterozygous inversion. Backcrosses revealed more severe incompatibility.
Molecular characterization.
Three PCR-based assays have been developed that distinguish
An. minimus
and
An. harrisoni
of the
Minimus
Complex: SSCP-PCR of D3 rDNA (
Sharpe
et al
., 1999
), RFLP-PCR of ITS2 rDNA using the restriction endonuclease BsIZI (
Van Bortel
et al
., 2000
;
Garros
et al
., 2004b
), allelespecific PCR based on SCAR markers (
Kengne
et al
., 2001
) and ITS2 nucleotide variations (
Phuc
et al
., 2003
;
Garros
et al
., 2004a
). None of these methods included
An. yaeyamaensis
, but nucleotide variation observed in the D3 and ITS2 regions of rDNA and the COII locus of mt DNA (
Harbach
et al
., 2007
: figs 2, 3, 5) readily distinguish this species from
An. minimus
and
An. harrisoni
.
Bionomics.
Anopheles yaeyamaensis
(identified as
An. minimus
) played a major role in the transmission of
falciparum
malaria in the Yaeyama and Miyako Islands before the disease was eradicated from the islands between
1957 and 1962
(
Kuroshima, 1960
;
Farid
et al
., 1966
;
Sakihara
et al
., 1994
). The immature stages typically inhabit unpolluted streams, springs and ground pools near springs. Larvae and adults are found throughout the year, but densities decrease significantly during the cold season from December to February, during which individuals are larger and darker in colour (
Miyagi & Toma, 1980
;
Toma
et al
., 1996a
,
b
;
Toma
et al
., 2002a
; Toma
et al
., 2003;
Somboon
et al.
, 2001
).
Anopheles yaeyamaensis
is stenogamous (insemination rate about 50%) and females mate readily with a stenogamous strain of
An. minimus
in
30 cm
cages (insemination rates of about 80%).
Anopheles harrisoni
is not stenogamous but females (about 20%) are able to mate with
An. yaeyamaensis
males (
Somboon
et al
., 2001
,
2005a
).
Distribution.
Anopheles yaeyamaensis
has only been found on Iriomote, Ishigaki and Kohama Islands of the Yaeyama Island Group and Miyako Island of the Miyako Island Group in the Okinawa Prefecture,
Japan
. Ishigaki and Iriomote are the largest two islands of the Yaeyama Group and Miyako is the largest and most populous island among the Miyako Islands. The two island groups form the southern part of the volcanic Ryukyu Islands. The Yaeyamas are closer to
Taiwan
, about
125 km
, than Miyako Island, which lies approximately
400 km
east of Taipei,
Taiwan
.
Etymology.
The specific name,
yaeyamaensis
, is a Latinised geographical name (yaeyama and the Latin suffix -
ensis
) denoting the
type
locality of the species in the Yaeyama Islands.
Type
series.
Eighty-nine specimens (13 Ƥ, 13 3, 26 Le, 26 Pe, 11 L).
Holotype
, Ƥ (no. 5), with LePe on microscope slide,
JAPAN
: Ryukyu Archipelago, Ishigaki Island, Ishigaki City, Nosoko, Nishihama stream,
6 July 2006
(Somboon
et al
.) (
BMNH
).
Paratypes
, same data as
holotype
, 12ƤLePe (nos. 2, 3, 8, 10, 11, 13, 15, 19–22, 24), 13 (no. 18), 123LePe (nos. 1, 4, 6, 7, 9, 12, 14, 16, 17, 23, 27, 32), 1LePe (no. 25) and 11L (nos. 1–11). All specimens are deposited in the Natural History Museum, London (
BMNH
).