Combining target enrichment and Sanger sequencing data to clarify the systematics of the diverse Neotropical butterfly subtribe Euptychiina (Nymphalidae, Satyrinae)
Author
Espeland, Marianne
Author
Nakahara, Shinichi
Author
Zacca, Thamara
Author
Barbosa, Eduardo P.
Author
Huertas, Blanca
Author
Marín, Mario A.
Author
Lamas, Gerardo
Author
Benmesbah, Mohamed
Author
Brévignon, Christian
Author
Casagrande, Mirna M.
Author
Fåhraeus, Christer
Author
Grishin, Nick
Author
Kawahara, Akito Y.
Author
Mielke, Olaf H. H.
Author
Miller, Jacqueline Y.
Author
Nakamura, Ichiro
Author
Navas, Vanessa
Author
Patrusky, Brooke
Author
Pyrcz, Tomasz W.
Author
Richards, Lindsay
Author
Tan, Denise
Author
Tyler, Stephanie
Author
Viloria, Angel
Author
Warren, Andrew D.
Author
Xiao, Lei
Author
Freitas, André V. L.
Author
Willmott, Keith R.
text
Zoological Research
2023
2023-02-15
2023
1
73
journal article
58039
10.1111/syen.12590
bfb878f3-8a74-46d3-a104-36485c32aaba
7909395
Cyllopsis
clade
The ‘
Cyllopsis
clade’ was recognized in
Espeland et al. (2019a)
, where it was placed as a strongly supported sister group to a much larger clade including major, species-rich clades such as the ‘
Splendeuptychia
clade’, ‘
Taygetis
clade’, ‘
Megisto
clade’, ‘
Pareuptychia
clade’. The clade was similarly recovered in previous molecular phylogenetic studies (
Murray & Prowell, 2005
; Nakahara, Janzen, et al., 2015;
Peña et al., 2010
), and in the recent study of
Rosa et al. (2021)
. Currently, four genera are recognized in the ‘
Cyllopsis
clade’, namely
Cyllopsis
(30 species),
Paramacera
(5 species),
Inbio
(monotypic) and
Atlanteuptychia
(monotypic), and our molecular data suggest further taxonomic changes at the generic level are not needed (
Figures 3
,
S
2
and
S
3
). The relationships between all genera are stable and well-supported in all analyses, with
Atlanteuptychia
being sister to the remainder of the clade,
Inbio
being sister to
Paramacera
, and these two again being sister to
Cyllopsis
. Thus, the generic classification is perhaps the most stable in comparison with other clades in the subtribe that contain multiple genera. Based on our unpublished data, the only known undescribed species within this clade are in
Cyllopsis
. Only two
Cyllopsis
species
have been described more recently, including the unique
Cyllopsis emilia
, which appears to be one of the few euptychiine species that may be involved in mimicry with
Pieridae
butterflies (
Chacon & Nishida,2002
;
Warren et al., 2018
). Conversely, there are likely several currently recognized
Cyllopsis
species
that may represent seasonal forms, so some revision to the species taxonomy is likely needed (Warren, unpublished data). Members of the ‘
Cyllopsis
clade’ are relatively small butterflies, with the forewing length of most species not exceeding
25 mm
. Possible synapomorphies (not unique) and distinctive characters for the clade include the following: (a) brachia short (about half of uncus in length or shorter),described as ‘not freely articulated’ in
Miller (1974)
; (b) smooth vesica lacking obvious sclerotized cornuti. Unlike other clades in the subtribe, members of the ‘
Cyllopsis
clade’ are most diverse in Central
America
, especially in southern
Mexico
and
Guatemala
. In fact, the monotypic genus
Atlanteuptychia
is the only taxon in this clade found east of the Andes, namely from the Atlantic Forest of
Brazil
(
Freitas et al., 2013
), resulting in a disjunct distribution for the clade. Habitat preferences of species in this clade range from lowland rainforest to cloud forest at over
2000 m
, with
Cyllopsis
being one of only three
Euptychiina
genera to have diversified extensively in montane regions (the others are
Forsterinaria
and
Moneuptychia
). The immature stages have been described for
Inbio hilara
feeding on
Rhipidocladum
(
Poaceae
: Bambusoideae: Bambuseae) (Nakahara,Janzen, et al., 2015), and various
Cyllopsis
species
have been reported feeding on bamboo and other grass genera (
Beccaloni et al., 2008
), but otherwise there are few comprehensive, detailed descriptions or hostplant records for most species in the clade.