The worrying arrival of the invasive Asian needle ant Brachyponera chinensis in Europe (Hymenoptera: Formicidae)
Author
Menchetti, Mattia
Institut de Biologia Evolutiva (CSIC-UPF), Passeig Marítim de la Barceloneta 37 - 49, 08003 Barcelona, Spain.
Author
Schifani, Enrico
0000-0003-0684-6229
Department of Chemistry, Life Sciences and Environmental Sustainability, University of Parma, Parco Area delle Scienze 11 / A, 43124 Parma, Italy. enrsc 8 @ gmail. com; https: // orcid. org / 0000 - 0003 - 0684 - 6229
enrsc8@gmail.com
Author
Gentile, Vincenzo
C. so Umberto I, 301, Torre Annunziata 80058 Naples, Italy
Author
Vila, Roger
0000-0002-2447-4388
Institut de Biologia Evolutiva (CSIC-UPF), Passeig Marítim de la Barceloneta 37 - 49, 08003 Barcelona, Spain. & roger. vila @ csic. es; https: // orcid. org / 0000 - 0002 - 2447 - 4388
roger.vila@csic.es
text
Zootaxa
2022
2022-03-11
5115
1
146
150
journal article
20272
10.11646/zootaxa.5115.1.10
fa2ba425-7064-4782-9103-1a186edc8fd2
1175-5326
6346008
C87A18C5-F8ED-4095-B856-85A3F0518AFB
Brachyponera chinensis
is considered a taxonomically challenging species, and past confusion over its distinction from congeneric species still hinders a full understanding of its distribution in Asia (
Guénard
et al.
2018
). It is considered to be part of an unresolved species complex, characterized by high intraspecific morphological variation (
Yamane 2007
;
Yashiro
et al.
2010
). The revision carried out by
Yashiro
et al.
(2010)
, mainly based on Japanese and Taiwanese material, distinguished three species using molecular and morphological data:
B. chinensis
,
B. nakasujii
Yashiro
et al.
, 2010
, and
B. luteipes
(Mayr, 1862)
, whose ranges considerably overlap.
Regarding Europe, the only existing record is a reported interception in
Hamburg
(
Germany
), on plants shipped from
Japan
, which dates back to the year 1900 (reported as
Ponera solitaria
by
Forel (1900))
. However, given the taxonomic confusion reigning at that time, the identity of the species recorded by
Forel (1900)
is uncertain.
In this paper, we present the first confirmed record of
B. chinensis
for Europe, initially suggested by morphological characteristics, and then confirmed by genetic analysis (DNA barcoding).
A single specimen of an unidentified
male
belonging to the genus
Brachyponera
was collected while attracted to a streetlight on the 3rd of
July 2020
by one of the authors (
VG
) in
Torre Annunziata
(
Naples
,
Italy
), in a residential area about
1 km from
the
town harbour
, at the coordinates
40.758824
,
14.434152
(uncertainty ±
10 m
, 32 m a.s.l.). The specimen is stored at the Butterfly Diversity and Evolution Lab, Institute of Evolutionary Biology (
CSIC-UPF
) (Barcelona, Spain) under the voucher code
MM21B056a1.
A first morphological investigation revealed that the specimen differed from any native Euro-Mediterranean ponerine genera and matched
Brachyponera
instead by features such as the ventral cuticular processes of the metasternum and petiole (
Figure 1c
). Moreover, the male specimen corresponded to
B. chinensis
by its light coloration and mandible shape (
Yashiro
et al.
2010
). However, like in most ant genera,
Brachyponera
taxonomy is mostly based on workers, with detailed male-based keys missing and males are undescribed for at least half of its 23 described species (
Bolton 2022
). As a result, an accurate and definitive identification on the basis of morphological features only was not possible.
Four
legs of the specimen were removed for genetic analysis and sent to the
International Barcode of Life
project (iBOL) (
deWaard
et al.
2008
). A DNA-barcoding (mitochondrial gene cytochrome c oxidase subunit I,
COI
) sequence of 658 bp was obtained using the primers LepF1 and LepR1 (
deWaard
et al.
2008
) and submitted to
GenBank
(accession number
OM604749
). For the genetic identification, we retrieved a total of 17 sequences of five
Brachyponera
species
from GenBank:
B. chinensis
(accession numbers
GQ264540
,
GQ264547
,
GQ264550
,
GQ264554
,
GQ264561
,
GQ264562
,
GQ264565
,
GQ264566
,
GQ264570
from
Yashiro
et al.
2010
and
MT800254
,
MT800255
,
MT800256
from
Park
et al.
2020
),
Brachyponera luteipes
(Mayr, 1862)
(a.n.
GQ264575
,
GQ264582
,
GQ264583
from
Yashiro
et al.
2010
),
B. nakasujii
(a.n.
GQ264583
from
Yashiro
et al.
2010
),
Brachyponera nigrita
(Emery, 1895)
(a.n.
GQ264596
from
Yashiro
et al.
2010
) and
Brachyponera obscurans
(Walker, 1859)
(a.n.
EF609925
from
Smith & Fisher 2009
).
Sequences were edited and aligned with Geneious
2020.2.4
(www.geneious.com) and a neighbour-joining tree was built with the same program, using
Ectomomyrmex javanus
Mayr, 1867 as outgroup (a.n.
GQ264573
from
Yashiro
et al.
2010
). A haplotype network of
B. chinensis
sequences was built with the program TCS 1.21 (
Clement
et al.
2002
) and later edited with tcsBU (
Múrias dos Santos
et al.
2016
) and
Adobe Illustrator CC
2019. The genetic analysis confirmed the single male as
B. chinensis
with high support (99% bootstrap value) (
Figure 1d
). The
COI
haplotype found in
Italy
is the same previously reported in the USA, suggesting a possible origin from this country or a common source of introduction (
Figure 1e
).
Besides the potential problematics related to the use of barcoding for ant species delimitation (e.g.
Schifani
et al.
2021
) and identification (e.g.
Blatrix
et al.
2020
), here this technique helped us determining a potentially established population of the highly invasive species
B. chinensis
, based on the taxonomic framework by
Yashiro
et al.
(2010)
.
As many other soil invertebrates, ants are often accidentally introduced in new environments due to the ongoing globalization and in particular to the plant trade (
Pyšek
et al.
2020
). Their frequent introduction in private gardens or greenhouses can facilitate their recording when the species are particularly charismatic and easy to spot (e.g. through citizen science,
Mori
et al.
2021
), but it can also make the field surveys harder to be carried out. The latter one is probably the case for
B. chinensis
in Torre Annunziata (Naples,
Italy
): an area of
300 m
of radius around the site where the specimen was found, as well as the area of the harbour, have been surveyed multiple times from 2016 to 2021 and no other individual belonging to this species have been found. More surveys, perhaps employing specific traps, will be useful to further verify the presence of nests. The fact that we collected a swarming male points to three potential concerns: a) At least one nest is already in an advanced stage and the species may have already overcome the typical “lag phase” after introduction and during establishment, preceding the increase-phase marking spread (
Pyšek
et al.
2020
). This is problematic considering that the high inbreeding tolerance of
B. chinensis
may allow a few foundresses to give birth to an entire population (
Eyer
et al.
2018
). b) Since the dispersal capabilities of
B. chinensis
are undocumented, and it may disperse by independent foundations, including through pleometrosis (Benoit Guénard pers. comm.), it is hard to locate the nest of origin and eradicate it. In fact, the nest of origin may be in hardly accessible private areas and the colony (or colonies) may have time to spread while remaining undetected. c) A queenless colony may have been introduced and males were produced by the workers, capable of laying haploid eggs in the
B. chinensis
complex (
Gotoh & Ito 2008
).
The Mediterranean basin hosts an increasing number of exotic species, but most of them have remained limited to indoor or at least urban environments (
Schifani 2019
). Climate change may also play a significant role for the establishment of
B. chinensis
in
Italy
(
Bertelsmeier
et al.
2013
). However, the success of
B. chinensis
in North American forest habitats suggests that this species could potentially invade European natural habitats and particularly forests, likely affecting native communities. On the other hand, its establishment in urban areas may constitute a public health concern (
Nelder
et al.
2006
). We call for action at the presumably early stage of this new potentially harmful biological invasion and propose that a detailed survey of a wide area around Torre Annunziata is conducted.