Fossil butterflies, calibration points and the molecular clock (Lepidoptera: Papilionoidea)
Author
Jong, Rienk De
text
Zootaxa
2017
4270
1
1
63
journal article
32975
10.5281/zenodo.583183
6c479acc-8b18-4f0b-a6e5-85bcd6d7b6b7
1175-5326
583183
2D00AFF5-4FE2-4EC1-A328-C8670CFB8D6D
dramba
.
Voltinia dramba
Hall, Robbins & Harvey, 2004
Riodinidae
:
Riodininae
:
Mesosemiini
:
Voltinea
.
Dominican Republic
, Cordillera Septentrional between
Santiago
and
Puerto Plata
,
Dominican
amber; Burdigalian, early Miocene.
Depositories: USNM (holotype);
Murata
coll.,
Kyota
,
Japan
(
paratype
)
;
Morrone
coll.,
Torino
,
Italy
(
paratype
);
AMNH
(one specimen, DR-18-1).
Published figures:
Hall
et al
. (2004
:
Fig. 1
);
Peñalver & Grimaldi (2006:
Figs 1
,
2
)
.
The fossil was described by
Hall
et al
. (2004)
as a member of the extant genus
Voltinia
(Riodinidae)
after five female specimens "that collectively represent probably the best-preserved fossil record for any lepidopteran." An additional fossil specimen belonging to the same taxon was described by
Peñalver & Grimaldi (2006)
. Because of the exceptionally good quality of the fossils, there is little reason to doubt its taxonomic position, the more so since
Hall (2003)
had published a phylogenetic reassessment based on morphology of the tribes of
Riodininae
, the genus
Voltinia
belongs to, and thus, characters of all related extant genera were well known and evaluated. Very recently an extensive molecular phylogenetic analysis of the family was published (
Espeland
et al
. 2015
) covering all subfamilies, tribes and subtribes, and 98 out of 145 described genera of the
Riodinidae
, including
Voltinia
. The taxonomic position of the fossil was used as one of the calibration points (placed at the common stem of
Voltinia
and
Napaea
), with an age of 15–25 Ma as given by
Hall
et al
. (2004)
. Since the Burdigalian lasted from 20.43 Ma to 15.97 Ma, the latter (younger) age should be used for calibration. However, recent studies, soon to be published, suggest that the allocation of the fossil needs revision (Noemy Seraphim Pereira, pers. comm.), and it may be wise to postpone the use of the fossil for calibration until its position is better known.