Review of the Oxynoemacheilus tigris group with the description of two new species from the Euphrates drainage (Teleostei: Nemacheilidae)
Author
Freyhof, Jörg
Author
Kaya, Cüneyt
Author
Turan, Davut
Author
Geiger, Matthias
text
Zootaxa
2019
2019-05-28
4612
1
29
57
journal article
26666
10.11646/zootaxa.4612.1.2
b0a3a5c6-0885-4f87-a931-3d629233ad37
1175-5326
3233571
FE1913E9-E308-4807-A706-1D0F7A7C674B
Oxynoemacheilus tigris
(Heckel, 1843)
(
Fig. 10–11
)
Cobitis tigris
Heckel, 1843:1088
, Kuiek River near
Aleppo
,
Syria
.
Material examined.
NMW
48445,
2 syntypes
,
62–73 mm
SL;
NMW 49444-46
,
2 syntypes
,
55–75 mm
SL,
Syria
:
Queik River
near Aleppo.
—
FFR 1459, 11,
32–68 mm
SL;
Turkey
:
Kilis prov.
:
Qweik River
about
2 km
west of
Yavuzlu
,
36.704
37.224
.—
FFR 1481, 16,
42–67 mm
SL;
Turkey
:
Kilis prov.
: stream
Sünnep
about
8 km
west of
Yığmatepe
,
36.764
37.254
.—
FSJF
2890,
14
,
35–67 mm
SL;
Turkey
:
Gaziantep prov.
: a tributary to stream Mer- ziman south of
Yavuzeli
,
37.2769
37.5325
.—
FSJF
2925,
18
,
28–59 mm
SL;
Turkey
:
Kilis prov.
: stream
Sünnep
10 km
east of
Kilis
,
36.7641
37.2541
.—
FSJF
2934,
1
,
43 mm
SL;
Turkey
:
Gaziantep prov.
: stream
Merziman
at
Bağtepe
,
37.3248
37.6445
.—
FSJF
4030,
6
,
40–71 mm
SL;
Turkey
:
Kilis prov.
: headwater stream of
Qweik River
about
7 km
east of
Kilis
,
36.7046
37.2248
.
Material used in molecular genetic analysis.
FSJF
DNA-1317
;
Turkey
:
Gaziantep prov.
: a tributary to stream
Merziman
south of
Yavuzeli
,
37.2769
37.5325
. (
GenBank
accession numbers:
MK
546476
-
MK
546479
)
.—
FSJF
DNA 1380
;
Turkey
:
Kilis prov.
: stream
Sünnep
10 km
east of
Kilis
,
36.7641
37.2541
. (
GenBank
accession numbers:
MK
546480
-
MK
546482
)
.
Additional distribution records.
GBIF
: 36.2048 37.1365, 31.3667 49.7167, 36.7641 37.2541.
Diagnosis.
Oxynoemacheilus tigris
is distinguished from
O. ercisianus
,
O. hazarensis
and
O. kaynaki
by having a long and high dorsal adipose crest with a whitish margin, reaching beyond the vertical through the anal-fin origin, usually below the last dorsal-fin rays when folded down (vs. no or a short dorsal-adipose crest, without white margin, on the caudal peduncle not reaching to the vertical through the anal-fin base), and 10–16 bold, narrow, regularly shaped bars, very prominent on the caudal peduncle (a mottled or marmorate flank pattern or the flank with large, irregularly shaped and narrowly spaced dark-brown bars or blotches), two bold, black spots at the caudal-fin base in most individuals (vs. no spots), and many isolated, deeply embedded scales on the flank (vs. no scales in
O. ercisianus
, scales restricted to the caudal peduncle in
O. hazarensis
).
Distribution.
Oxynoemacheilus tigris
was found in a headwater stream of the Qweik and in the Merziman drainage, flowing to the Euphrates at the Birecik reservoir.
Remarks.
Oxynoemacheilus tigris
was described from the Qweik River, which was a tributary of the western Euphrates until the early Holocene, when it became isolated due to the desiccation of its connection to the Euphrates (
Hamidan
et al.
2014
). While the Qweik and its tributaries have dried out completely in
Syria
, there are still headwaters in the Turkish part of the catchment (
Hamidan
et al.
2014
). In these tributaries,
O. tigris
is found together with
O. argyrogramma
, a species also known from the western part of the Euphrates, including the Merziman River (
Freyhof & Özuluğ 2017
). As there is no more water in the Syrian part of the Qweik River,
O. tigris
must be considered as being extirpated in
Syria
.
While we first identified the barred
Oxynoemacheilus
from the Merziman River as
O. tigris
, it turned out to form a separate molecular group in our COI barcode database (
Fig. 1
). Our molecular data place
O. tigris
from the Qweik within
Oxynoemacheilus namiri
(
Fig. 1
), whereas the individuals sequenced from the Merziman River in the Euphrates drainage are placed as a separate cluster in the species group discussed in this study, differentiated from
O. namiri
by a minimum K2P distance of 9.3%.
Oxynoemacheilus namiri
is widespread in the Orontes River, which is situated adjacent to the Qweik in the west. Even through
O. tigris
is well distinguished from
O. namiri
, we were not able to find differences between the populations of
O. tigris
studied from the Qweik and the Merziman (Euphrates). We postulate that the Qweik population of
O. tigris
has completely or partly lost their own mitochondria due to introgressive hybridisation with invasive
O. namiri
from the Orontes. As
O. namiri
is absent from the Euphrates and the Qweik but widespread all over the Orontes and the coastal streams in
Syria
, we find this scenario more likely than vice versa. The recent biogeographical connection between the Orontes and the Qweik was already discussed by
Hamidan
et al.
(2014)
. These authors pointed on the occurrence of
Pseudophoxinus zeregi
(Leuciscidae)
known from both rivers, while this species is absent in the Euphrates drainage. Obviously, a recent connection between the Orontes and the Qweik allowed
P. zeregi
to invade and establish in the Qweik from the Orontes. Similar to
O. namiri
,
P. zeregi
is very widespread in the Orontes and in the coastal streams in
Syria
. Therefore this direction of the invasion seems to be more likely than the invasion from the Qweik into the Orontes.
Oxynoemacheilus namiri
might also have spread through this connection from the Orontes to the Qweik, and we speculate that it may have hybridised with
O. tigris
leading to introgressed
O. tigris
individuals with mtDNA of
O. namiri
. We did not have the opportunity to test this case with nuclear molecular marker, but encourage future studies to do so.
FIGURE 10.
Oxynoemacheilus tigris
, from top: FSJF 4030, 71 mm SL; Turkey: headwater stream of Qweik River; FSJF 2890, 62 mm SL, 58 mm SL; Turkey: stream Merziman.
Based on DNA barcoding it is well separated from all other species in the
O. ercisianus
group, and by a minimum K2P distance of 4.2% to
O. kaynaki
. It is also supported by the PTP approach and by the mPTP delimitation as a distinct entity.
Other species of
Oxynoemacheilus
in the Euphrates are not closely related to
O. tigris
. It is distinguished from
O. araxensis
,
O. argyrogramma
,
O. bergianus
,
O. euphraticus
,
and
O. samanticus
by having a long dorsal adipose crest on the caudal peduncle reaching beyond the vertical through the anal-fin origin, usually below the last dorsalfin rays when folded down (vs. no or a short dorsal-adipose crest on the caudal peduncle), 10–16 bold, narrow bars on the flank, very prominent on the caudal peduncle (vs. a mottled flank pattern or the flank with large, irregularly shaped and narrowly spaced dark-brown bars or blotches), an incomplete lateral line (vs. complete), no suborbital groove in the male (vs. present), a slightly emarginate or almost truncate caudal fin (vs. deeply emarginate in all species except
O. araxensis
), and two black spots at the caudal-fin base (vs. no bold black spots in all species except in
O. argyrogramma
and
O. euphraticus
).
Oxynoemacheilus tigris
is distinguished from
O. paucilepis
by having an incomplete lateral line (vs. complete), and a long dorsal adipose crest on the caudal peduncle (vs. no crest).