Papaver recircumscribed: A review of neighbouring Papaveraceae genera, including Afropapaver nom. et stat. nov. and Oreomecon, a large, Arctic-Alpine genus
Author
Elvebakk, Arve
0000-0002-7682-3797
Arctic University Museum of Norway, UiT The Arctic University, PO Box 6050 Langnes, NO- 9037 Tromsø, Norway
Author
Bjerke, Jarle W.
0000-0003-2721-1492
Arctic University Museum of Norway, UiT The Arctic University, PO Box 6050 Langnes, NO- 9037 Tromsø, Norway & Norwegian Institute for Nature Research, FRAM – High North Research Centre for Climate and the Environment, PO Box 6606 Langnes, NO- 9296 Tromsø, Norway
text
PhytoKeys
2024
2024-10-29
248
105
188
journal article
10.3897/phytokeys.248.121011
6.
Stylomecon
G. Taylor
, J. Bot. 68: 140. 1930
Type species.
Stylomecon heterophylla
(Benth.) G. Taylor.
Notes.
Stylomecon heterophylla
(Benth.) G. Taylor
and the species known as
Papaver californicum
A. Gray
are endemic to California and adjacent parts of
Mexico
, where they are grossly disjunct as they are the only representatives of the mostly Eurasian clade of Papavereae in America. Samples from this group of species diverged from the remaining samples of
Papaver
and
Parameconopsis
at ca. 19–20 Ma according to the phylogenies by
Valtueña et al. (2012)
and
Xie et al. (2014)
and a similar phylogenetic position was shown by
Liu et al. (2014)
.
Catania et al. (2022)
concluded that
Papaver californicum
was the earliest branching species from a common ancestor in the
Papaver
lineage, which had a gene fusion event basal for the further synthesis of the morphinan group of alkaloids, a divergence dated at 16.8 Ma.
According to these phylogenies, these two species definitively should be congeneric.
Kadereit and Baldwin (2011)
dealt with their morphology, ecology and distribution in detail and showed differences in flower and capsule morphology. They concluded that the style in
S. heterophylla
probably evolved independently from other lineages and a structure similar to the stigmatic disc of
P. californicum
and they treated both species within a broad definition of
Papaver
.
Given that these two Californian-Mexican species have an old evolutionary history, a similar phylogeny and distribution and a diverging style which probably evolved relatively recently within its lineage, the clade is best treated as a separate genus. The name
Stylomecon
is available and a new combination is needed for the species known as
P. californicum
.
Stylomecon heterophylla
was briefly described as
Meconopsis heterophylla
Benth.
by
Bentham (1835)
, who also described
Meconopsis crassifolia
Benth. Both
type specimens shown by
JSTOR Global Plants (2023
) carry the label information “ Nova California, 1833, Douglas’. According to
Bentham (1835)
, David Douglas travelled from present-day Oregon to then Mexican California and carried out botany studies in the surroundings of Monterey during the years 1831 and 1832. Then he travelled to what is now named Hawaii and dispatched his plants by ship to
England
before he returned to Oregon. The year of the label should, therefore, refer to the year of the plants’ arrival in
England
and not the year of collecting. According to Brentham (1835), cultivation attempts failed and the plants preserved are, therefore, those collected by Douglas. Although classified as
isotypes
by
JSTOR Global Plants (2023
), below, we list these as
holotypes
in the absence of known duplicates.
Steudel (1841)
included both
Meconopsis heterophylla
and
Meconopsis crassifolia
within a widely defined genus
Stylophorum
Nutt.
, including two from California, two others from northern America, one from Europe and two from
Nepal
. In a flora of the San Francisco area,
Greene (1894)
accepted both names as species of
Papaver
together with
P. californicum
and
P. lemmonii
Greene. Much
later,
Kadereit (1988 a
) and
Kadereit and Baldwin (2011)
accepted only
Papaver californicum
and
Stylomecon heterophylla
and did not present interpretations of the name
Meconopsis crassifolia
.
Grey-Wilson (2014)
, however, considered the latter to be a synonym of the very different
Stylophorum diphyllum
(Michx.) Nutt.
distributed on the opposite side of the North American continent, an interpretation followed by
POWO (2023
).
Kadereit and Baldwin (2011)
explained and illustrated the leaves of
Stylomecon heterophylla
to be very different from those of
Papaver californicum
, the latter being strikingly heterophyllous. The
holotypes
of
Meconopsis heterophylla
and
M. crassifolia
illustrated by
JSTOR Global Plants (2023
) differ in the same way and also match the diagnoses by
Bentham (1835)
. We conclude that
Meconopsis crassifolia
and
Papaver californicum
are synonyms and that the former holds priority.