Integrative taxonomy of a new and highly-diverse genus of onchidiid slugs from the Coral Triangle (Gastropoda, Pulmonata, Onchidiidae)
Author
Goulding, Tricia C.
Author
Khalil, Munawar
Author
Tan, Shau Hwai
Author
Dayrat, Benoit
text
ZooKeys
2018
763
1
111
http://dx.doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.763.21252
journal article
http://dx.doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.763.21252
1313-2970-763-1
90B772554C5E436CA793D924892B5B14
90B772554C5E436CA793D924892B5B14
Genus
Wallaconchis Goulding & Dayrat
gen. n.
Type species.
Wallaconchis sinanui
, designated here.
Etymology.
Combination of Wallace, for Alfred Russel Wallace, one of the first naturalists to widely study the fauna of the Indo-Malay Archipelago, and
Onchis
, one of the names used to refer to onchidiid slugs. The core of the geographic distribution of this genus in Indonesia (Bali, Lombok, Sulawesi, and eastern Indonesia) corresponds to a region sometimes referred to as Wallacea, also after A. R. Wallace, which makes it especially fitting here.
Gender.
Masculine, gender of
Onchis
.
Diagnosis.
Body not flattened. Dorsal gills absent. Dorsal eyes present on notum, mostly in groups of three or four eyes. Central dorsal papilla bearing eyes present and retractable, but usually not raised above the dorsal surface. Eyes at the tip of short ocular tentacles. Male opening below the right ocular tentacle. Oral lobes typically grey or dark brown. Pneumostome median. Foot wide. Visceral cavity pigmented (in black), which varies in intensity between individuals. Intestinal loops of type I. Rectal gland absent. Accessory penial gland absent. Penial morphology highly diverse, from short and straight to long and coiled. Penial hooks absent or present.
Remarks.
Every available genus name was carefully evaluated when searching for a name for this genus, which included examination of the type specimens of the type species of all existing genera, as well as the analysis of all the original descriptions. Nine existing species names are transferred to
Wallaconchis
, five of which are valid, one of which is a synonym, and three of which are nomina dubia. Historically, these five valid species names have been placed in three different genera:
Onchidium
Buchannan, 1800,
Paraoncidium
Labbe
, 1934, and
Scaphis
Labbe
, 1934. However, all five species were originally described in
Onchidium
(sometimes with the unjustified emendation
Oncidium
), traditionally used by default for many unrelated onchidiids (
Dayrat 2009
):
Onchidium ater
Lesson, 1830;
Onchidium graniferum
Semper, 1880;
Oncidium nangkauriense
Plate, 1893;
Oncidium buetschlii
Stantschinsky, 1907; and
Oncidium gracile
Stantschinsky, 1907. The one species name which is a synonym,
Oncidium keiense
Hoffmann, 1926, and the three species names which are nomina dubia (
Onchidium ovale
Semper, 1880;
Oncidium simrothi
Plate, 1893;
Oncidium fungiforme
Stantschinsky, 1907), were also originally created in the genus
Onchidium
. From this point forward, the unjustified emendation
Oncidium
is not repeated throughout the paper and is systematically replaced by the correct spelling
Onchidium
. The genus
Onchidium
actually refers to a different taxon including only three species and characterized by features (e.g., large dorsal conical papillae, rectal gland, accessory penial gland) that are absent in the species described here (see
Dayrat et al. 2016
).
Hoffmann (1926)
decided not to create a new genus for
Onchidium keiense
, despite the distinctive morphology of the copulatory parts: "The peculiarity of the penis could almost suggest the idea that we are dealing here with a whole new genus. In the genus
Onchidium
, however, there are already species which differ quite considerably from each other, so that I have no reason to create a new genus for my species." (1926: 24, translated from German).
Hoffmann (1928)
briefly mentioned the morphological similarity of six
Onchidium
species (
Onchidium papuanum
Semper, 1880,
Onchidium palaense
Semper, 1880,
Onchidium ovale
,
O. buetschlii
,
O. nangkauriense
, and
Onchidium chameleon
Brazier, 1886) which all lack an accessory penial gland, and five of which also lack a rectal gland: "The following six species are quite close to one another, and there are usually very few characteristic features which can be used for differentiation." (1928: 81)
Hoffmann (1928)
also mentioned that some of those six names would likely become synonyms as new material became available, but none of these names has been proposed as synonymous. Three of these names are transferred to
Wallaconchis
here (
O. ovale
,
O. buetschlii
, and
O. nangkauriense
).
Onchidium chameleon
belongs to the genus
Onchidina
Semper, 1882 (
Dayrat and Goulding 2017
).
Onchidium palaense
and
O. papuanum
are poorly known because their type material is lost. However,
Semper's
description of the position of the male aperture as "between the two very small eye tentacles" in
O. palaense
(1882: 276) and "exactly in the center line between the tentacles and mouth" in
O. papuanum
(1882: 277) indicates that they belong to another genus. A few years later,
Labbe
(1934)
created the genus name
Paraoncidium
for eleven
Onchidium
species with no accessory penial gland, including the six aforementioned species considered morphologically similar by
Hoffmann (1928)
. However,
P. chameleon
, the type species of
Paraoncidium
, belongs to the genus
Onchidina
and
Paraoncidium
is a junior synonym of
Onchidina
(
Dayrat and Goulding 2017
). The genus
Onchidina
, which so far is monotypic, differs greatly from
Wallaconchis
(e.g., dorsal eyes absent, male aperture on right lateral side of right ocular tentacle, rectal gland present).
Finally, a new combination was proposed by
Labbe
(1934)
for
Onchidium ater
as
Scaphis atra
. However,
Scaphis
Starobogatov, 1976 is a synonym of
Peronia
Fleming, 1822 which refers to a different group of onchidiids characterized by dorsal gills, which are lacking in all the species described here.
Overall, none of the three genus names historically used in binomials for the species described here (
Onchidium
,
Paraoncidium
,
Scaphis
) could apply to our new genus.
Geographic distribution
(Fig. 6).
Wallaconchis
species are distributed from the Andaman Islands (India) in the Bay of Bengal to Vanuatu in the western Pacific. Nine out of ten species are sympatric over at least part of their distribution. Eight out of ten species are found widely within the Coral Triangle. Two species are known from only one station each, which suggests that they are endemic to a small region and specialized to a particular habitat. All species are found in tropical waters.
Figure 6. Geographic distribution of
Wallaconchis
species. The colors used for each species are the same as those used in phylogenetic trees (Figs 1-5), but note that for
W. ater
,
W. graniferum
, and
W. melanesiensis
, both units #1 and #2 are included within the distribution of the species and that only the color of unit #1 is being used. Black dots show sites sampled by the authors, and grey dots (in Papua New Guinea and the Pacific) show localities where samples were borrowed from a museum collection.
Habitat
(Table 3).
Wallaconchis
slugs are found in various intertidal habitats. Two new species (
W. comendadori
and
W. melanesiensis
) live predominantly in the rocky intertidal, with large rocks covered in thin layers of algae, which may or may not be adjacent to mangrove trees. Two species (
W. nangkauriense
and
W. ater
) are commonly found in coral rubble habitats, where
Avicennia
trees often grow. Three species (
W. buetschlii
,
W. uncinus
, and
W. sinanui
) are found on firm mud (i.e., mud which is not deep and not saturated in water). Two species (
W. gracile
and
W. buetschlii
) are found on sandy mud, two species (
W. achleitneri
and
W. buetschlii
) on coarse sand, and one species (
W. graniferum
) on fine sand. Many
Wallaconchis
species can be found together on diverse substrates at stations with various habitats. For instance, at our station 198, on the southern coast of Bohol, Philippines, six species were present without any other onchidiids on just a few square meters of fine sand mixed with coral rubble and muddy sand.
Table 3. Habitats where
Wallaconchis
species occur.
Species |
Mud |
Coarse sand |
Coral rubble |
Rocks |
Sandy mud |
Fine sand |
W. sinanui
|
W. uncinus
|
W. buetschlii
|
W. gracile
|
W. nangkauriense
|
W. ater
|
W. graniferum
|
W. achleitneri
|
W. comendadori
|
W. melanesiensis
|
Distinctive diagnostic features.
A unique combination of characters can be used to determine whether a specimen is part of a
Wallaconchis
species: no dorsal gills, intestinal loops of type I, no rectal gland, and no accessory penial gland. This combination is not found in any other genus and these anatomical features can be easily and quickly observed through dissection. It is more challenging to identify
Wallaconchis
slugs using external characters, but it is not impossible.
Wallaconchis
slugs exhibit the highest degree of color variation in the
Onchidiidae
. In some species, the dorsal notum can be red, yellow, green, orange, brown, grey, black, etc., when most onchidiids are usually just brown, marbled with light to dark brown. Such bright dorsal colors are also found in
Peronia
, but
Peronia
is easily distinguished from
Wallaconchis
(the dorsal notum of
Peronia
bears gills that are absent in
Wallaconchis
). However, the three
Wallaconchis
species which are found on mud inside and around mangroves only occasionally exhibit patches of bright colors, and thus, can be easily mistaken for other genera found in mangroves. The male opening can also help identify
Wallaconchis
slugs at the generic level. In other genera, the male opening may be to the left of the right ocular tentacle (e.g.,
Melayonchis
,
Onchidium
), or to the right of the right tentacle (e.g.,
Peronina
,
Onchidina
), while in
Wallaconchis
it is directly below the right ocular tentacle (
Dayrat et al. 2016
,
2017
,
Goulding et al. in press
). Another character which may be observed in
Wallaconchis
by naturalists in the field, although difficult to appreciate, is that live animals produce a sticky mucus from the ventral surface, which is most noticeable with large animals. Other onchidiids also produce some mucus, but that mucus is usually wet, while the mucus of
Wallaconchis
can be likened to drying glue.